Exhaust Clarification
#1
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lino Lakes, MN
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Exhaust Clarification
After searching this board for the last few months, i have decided against true duals, to go with a y pipe. With that said, i have some money coming back on taxes, and i wanted to replace my stock exhaust. It seams as there is a good deals on Kooks products right now. Other then a lid, this would be my first mod, and definately my first major mod.
With that said, it is to my understanding that i can either get headers with EGR / AIR fittings on them or Kooks race headers.
1. As far as i understand it, the EGR / AIR is not something that i need. I am leaning towards getting race headers and removing all of this crap as i live in MN and do not have any omissions. Any suggestions on which headers to get or what experience you have had?
2. I am leaning towards a catted y pipe. Going to an ORY typically leads to a "raspy" sounding exhaust. Any suggestions?
3. I have listened to LS1sounds and know what i want as far as sound. I am looking for something that is relatively quiet at idle, but sounds great when i get on it.
4. Is it difficult to remove and plug the EGR / Air?
Thanks,
BLKZ28VERT
With that said, it is to my understanding that i can either get headers with EGR / AIR fittings on them or Kooks race headers.
1. As far as i understand it, the EGR / AIR is not something that i need. I am leaning towards getting race headers and removing all of this crap as i live in MN and do not have any omissions. Any suggestions on which headers to get or what experience you have had?
2. I am leaning towards a catted y pipe. Going to an ORY typically leads to a "raspy" sounding exhaust. Any suggestions?
3. I have listened to LS1sounds and know what i want as far as sound. I am looking for something that is relatively quiet at idle, but sounds great when i get on it.
4. Is it difficult to remove and plug the EGR / Air?
Thanks,
BLKZ28VERT
Last edited by BLKZ28VERT; 03-05-2011 at 11:31 AM.
#2
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (3)
After searching this board for the last few months, i have decided against true duals, to go with a y pipe. With that said, i have some money coming back on taxes, and i wanted to replace my stock exhaust. It seams as there is a good deals on Kooks products right now. Other then a lid, this would be my first mod, and definately my first major mod.
With that said, it is to my understanding that i can either get headers with EGR / AIR fittings on them or Kooks race headers.
1. As far as i understand it, the EGR / AIR is not something that i need. I am leaning towards getting race headers and removing all of this crap as i live in MN and do not have any omissions. Any suggestions on which headers to get or what experience you have had?
2. I am leaning towards a catted y pipe. Going to an ORY typically leads to a "raspy" sounding exhaust. Any suggestions?
3. I have listened to LS1sounds and know what i want as far as sound. I am looking for something that is relatively quiet at idle, but sounds great when i get on it.
3. Is it difficult to remove and plug the EGR / Air?
Thanks,
BLKZ28VERT
With that said, it is to my understanding that i can either get headers with EGR / AIR fittings on them or Kooks race headers.
1. As far as i understand it, the EGR / AIR is not something that i need. I am leaning towards getting race headers and removing all of this crap as i live in MN and do not have any omissions. Any suggestions on which headers to get or what experience you have had?
2. I am leaning towards a catted y pipe. Going to an ORY typically leads to a "raspy" sounding exhaust. Any suggestions?
3. I have listened to LS1sounds and know what i want as far as sound. I am looking for something that is relatively quiet at idle, but sounds great when i get on it.
3. Is it difficult to remove and plug the EGR / Air?
Thanks,
BLKZ28VERT
2) Magnaflow is queit at idle, and sounds good at Wot
3) Piece of cake.
#4
LS1Tech Administrator
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Schiller Park, IL Member: #317
Posts: 32,033
Likes: 0
Received 1,486 Likes
on
1,069 Posts
If you live in an area with no emissions testing, then you will be fine with removing AIR and EGR.
Furthermore, there is no reason to spend money on cats if you do not have emissions testing. Even the best flowing cats will not outflow an ORY, so you will be spending more money for less performance. IMO, this is counter productive to the purpose of buying headers, and unnecessary since you don't have any sort of sniff/visual emissions testing.
Rasping can be an issue with an ORY, but if you use a high quality Y-merge (something built like the Flowmaster Y-merge) and a one of the mellower sounding mufflers, rasp will be minimal. If there is still enough rasp to bother you, then Dynomax race bullets can be added to the I or Y pipe. These are cheap, flow better than cats, and normally will remove any rasp in combination with most mufflers.
Furthermore, there is no reason to spend money on cats if you do not have emissions testing. Even the best flowing cats will not outflow an ORY, so you will be spending more money for less performance. IMO, this is counter productive to the purpose of buying headers, and unnecessary since you don't have any sort of sniff/visual emissions testing.
Rasping can be an issue with an ORY, but if you use a high quality Y-merge (something built like the Flowmaster Y-merge) and a one of the mellower sounding mufflers, rasp will be minimal. If there is still enough rasp to bother you, then Dynomax race bullets can be added to the I or Y pipe. These are cheap, flow better than cats, and normally will remove any rasp in combination with most mufflers.
#6
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lino Lakes, MN
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
you say lol......are you kidding or serious. I have the money now, and really would like to do this once, which is why i am leaning towards getting the catted Y. Are the CATS that are on the Kooks catted Y considered high flow cats??? Or am i better off buying an ory and purchasing higher flowing cats.
Also, if i am deleting the EGR / AIR, i read that i may need to plug a line that runs to the back of my intake??? Do you know if this exists on a 98 z28? If so, i would rather replace the ls1 intake with an ls6, and really get it all done at once.
Also, if i am deleting the EGR / AIR, i read that i may need to plug a line that runs to the back of my intake??? Do you know if this exists on a 98 z28? If so, i would rather replace the ls1 intake with an ls6, and really get it all done at once.
Trending Topics
#8
12 Second Club
iTrader: (13)
As RPM said, you can add a bullet to the exhaust if it's too raspy for your tastes (mine were $45/each). THe only real reason I would go with cats is to cut down on the fumes associated with any non-catted, free flowing exhaust. They won't be much at all, but some people can't stand the smell at all so I can see it from all perspectives.
#9
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lino Lakes, MN
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
...fumes associated with non catted free flowing exhaust? So when removing the cats, it creates an odor? By using cats, how much hp am i really sacrificing?
Like i said before, i really only want to do this once, which is why i am asking the questions.
Race headers = Best Choice
ORY = better flowing and more HP
CATTED Y = possibly causing odors?
Like i said before, i really only want to do this once, which is why i am asking the questions.
Race headers = Best Choice
ORY = better flowing and more HP
CATTED Y = possibly causing odors?
Last edited by BLKZ28VERT; 03-05-2011 at 12:58 PM.
#10
12 Second Club
iTrader: (13)
Have you ever been in or around a car with true duals with no cats? I own one with that setup, and my girlfriend complains all the time about how I smell like exhaust. Cats + running the exhaust out the back help cure this. You aren't giving up a ton of power as such a low power level 10hp max.
I'd get the race headers so you don't have to deal with the EGR nonsense.
I'd get the race headers so you don't have to deal with the EGR nonsense.
#11
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lino Lakes, MN
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes, i used to have a true duals on my 80 malibu. I did smell like gas fumes when i drove with that car. I thought that maybe removing the cats caused a different smell then typical exhaust fumes.
Are there any other parts that i am going to need to do the install for Kooks Race Headers, Kooks Catted Y pipe? I would assume that i would need new header gaskets and i am planning on buying some new header bolts as well. Anything else that i would need?
Are there any other parts that i am going to need to do the install for Kooks Race Headers, Kooks Catted Y pipe? I would assume that i would need new header gaskets and i am planning on buying some new header bolts as well. Anything else that i would need?
#12
On The Tree
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Rosemount, MN
Posts: 141
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My wife complains about the exhaust smell every time shes in the car. To be honest, it is very annoying. Im considering cats myself.
1) Race headers. You will be surprized how much junk you pull out of the car when you take all the EGR/AIR parts out. The AIR pump weighs a ton! No performance gain but does clean up the engine bay.
2) Your decision. I have a pacesetter ORY and was disappointed when I got it. The merge sucks, just a hole cut in one pipe and the other welded to it. It does have that nasty rasp between 2200-2500 rpm.
I bought my car with a custom Y-pipe with bullets in place of the cats. The left bullet hit the floor board under accel. Poly engine mounts fixed that, but added engine vibration into the car. Also, long tube headers and ORY got more louder/raspy with my cam.
I have a Magnaflow cat back for sale if you're interested. Im in Burnsville if you have any questions or need some help.
1) Race headers. You will be surprized how much junk you pull out of the car when you take all the EGR/AIR parts out. The AIR pump weighs a ton! No performance gain but does clean up the engine bay.
2) Your decision. I have a pacesetter ORY and was disappointed when I got it. The merge sucks, just a hole cut in one pipe and the other welded to it. It does have that nasty rasp between 2200-2500 rpm.
I bought my car with a custom Y-pipe with bullets in place of the cats. The left bullet hit the floor board under accel. Poly engine mounts fixed that, but added engine vibration into the car. Also, long tube headers and ORY got more louder/raspy with my cam.
I have a Magnaflow cat back for sale if you're interested. Im in Burnsville if you have any questions or need some help.
#14
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Cairo, GA
Posts: 1,235
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i'd get an ORY and just use a muffler that's a little on the quiet side to cut down on rasp. a hooker aerochamber would be a good choice. i can smell fumes with the exhaust dumped but with it ran out the back i don't even think it's enouth to notice. besides emissions purposes, cats are a huge waste of money in my opinion. as said, any rasp can be cut down with a quieter muffler, a good merge, and if it's still there, put a bullet muffler in the I-pipe.
#15
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (5)
Honestly man you'll just have to pull the trigger on a setup and see if you like it. People can go back and forth on here about what sounds good to them, or smells bad, or whatever else. The only way to find out what works best for you is trial and error. I've gone through a couple different exhaust setups before I settled on my longtubes and true duals run out the back with no cats. Personally I love my setup. No Y-Pipe setup can compete IMO, but that's just my taste. If after all the sound clips and research you want to run longtube headers with cats, y-pipe, and something like Magnaflow then go for it and see how you like it. If you don't like it, then there are always other setups you can try. I know that you want "to do this once" and do it "right", but that's just part of the hobby. I've redone things on my cars tons of times. Either it wasn't what I wanted or envisioned at first, or I just grew out of it and moved on to something different. Like I said though, line something up that fits your parameters and make the purchase. If you like the sound, keep it. If not, tweak with the sound a bit by swapping out mufflers or removing the cats. You'll eventually fine tune your car's sound to exactly how you want it.
#16
LS1Tech Administrator
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Schiller Park, IL Member: #317
Posts: 32,033
Likes: 0
Received 1,486 Likes
on
1,069 Posts
This is another key consideration. I think a lot of the people that are bothered by the smell are people with exhaust dumped under the cabin. If you run it out the back of the car it shouldn't really be noticeable. I've had it exit just behind the tires as well as at the bumper, and neither one has ever bothered me in the least.
The only way to find out what works best for you is trial and error. I've gone through a couple different exhaust setups before I settled on my longtubes and true duals run out the back with no cats.......I know that you want "to do this once" and do it "right", but that's just part of the hobby. I've redone things on my cars tons of times. Either it wasn't what I wanted or envisioned at first, or I just grew out of it and moved on to something different.
I agree completely. Over the last 10+ years I've gone through about 10 different exhaust setups on various LS1s and at least 3 on my old SBC. Since exhaust note is subjective, nobody is going to be able to tell you what will sound best to YOU. Like said above, listen to the sound files and such, but at the end of the day it's still going to be a bit of a gamble. If you don't nail it the first time, that doesn't mean you have to live with it forever. Don't feel bad if you have to make a change; we've ALL been there at some point.