Broke a valve spring. Yep a comp 918.
#1
Broke a valve spring. Yep a comp 918.
You would think there are enough examples out there that people would stop cheaping out over $100-150.
Cruising home in the V. Cruise set and about 2000rpms. Hadn't beat on it at all that day. Check engine light starts flashing like crazy. Car starts to shimmy. Look down and still have oil pressure. Car dies. Coast off to the side of the road. Grabbed my laptop and had a missfire code.Try to restart and it fires but sounds like crap. Tow it home and knew the problem before I ever popped the hood.
I may have lucked out. The spring broke in one spot and all of it stayed on the valve. The valve is still straight. Took the spring off, ran the piston to tdc, and I can spin the valve on the piston without any rough spots. Hopefully no other damage. I'll check compression once I have a spring back on it.
Texas speed got springs out the door last minute for me last night. Hope to see them today. They said the pac518 was plenty but I'm going dual spring just to be sure. Room to grow too if I go with a bigger cam later.
I have a set of 918s on my lt1 motor that hasn't been started yet. They will be coming off most likely too.
Cam is a 228/234 .59x/.59x if anyone is curious. Not very big.
Cruising home in the V. Cruise set and about 2000rpms. Hadn't beat on it at all that day. Check engine light starts flashing like crazy. Car starts to shimmy. Look down and still have oil pressure. Car dies. Coast off to the side of the road. Grabbed my laptop and had a missfire code.Try to restart and it fires but sounds like crap. Tow it home and knew the problem before I ever popped the hood.
I may have lucked out. The spring broke in one spot and all of it stayed on the valve. The valve is still straight. Took the spring off, ran the piston to tdc, and I can spin the valve on the piston without any rough spots. Hopefully no other damage. I'll check compression once I have a spring back on it.
Texas speed got springs out the door last minute for me last night. Hope to see them today. They said the pac518 was plenty but I'm going dual spring just to be sure. Room to grow too if I go with a bigger cam later.
I have a set of 918s on my lt1 motor that hasn't been started yet. They will be coming off most likely too.
Cam is a 228/234 .59x/.59x if anyone is curious. Not very big.
#5
TECH Senior Member
#7
12 Second Club
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: 5.0
Posts: 1,302
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i think these beehives are super tempermental. if they pop out halfway out of a crappy valvespring compressor or you scratch them in the process you have a very good chance they will break.
funny most people that now run duals have broken springs before... just my .02
funny most people that now run duals have broken springs before... just my .02
Trending Topics
#10
I've broken the blue striped 918's, they sent new ones,traded them for arp headbolts,bought some 1518's,snapped those, called pac, gave them the batch number, yep, you guessed it, recalled batch...
Received the replacement springs, all good for the last 20000 miles...
Received the replacement springs, all good for the last 20000 miles...
#12
TECH Senior Member
IME over 90% of the breakages happen because of poor install/and or maintenance. I've used various singles on various lobes and yet to break one. Proper install protocol is imperative for long service.
#13
I agree, Also sometimes stuff breaks no matter what. I wouldnt trash a spring type or a company for one failure.
#15
TECH Addict
iTrader: (39)
Ive had 2 918 failures, on different cars/different engines, but strangly enough, same valve on both. Both lost the number 8 intake valve. Neither were installed by me. One, I take the blame for. I knew they had some miles on em, but threw a 224R at em anyway. The second set (4 months later) failed, and I checked the spring pressures on the other good springs, and they were within 5#s of what they should have been.