I Thought Cutting Stock Springs Were Frowned Upon?
#1
I Thought Cutting Stock Springs Were Frowned Upon?
Well I'm looking for a setup that'll ride smoother on rough roads. Here is my tweaked setup:
- Strano Springs w/rear spring isolator
- Strano 35/Adj 22 Sway Bars (Set on the middle hole because of staggered setup)
- Koni 4/3 Shocks (played with settings multiple times)
- UMI bolt-on 2-point Subframe Connectors (Removed)
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. Panhard Bar
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. LCA's (Switched to BMR Adj. with Rubber Bushings)
- UMI bolt-on Relocation Brackets
Additional Info:
- No added weight in the rear
- On 18's but running taller profile tires (275/40R18 & 295/40R18)
I was planning on switching out the Strano's for stock springs and putting in my BMR 1" lowering A-arm but I'm thinking the Koni shocks will still interfere with my quest for a smoother ride. I am contemplating purchasing Bilsteins with stock cut springs and selling my BMR A-arms or should I keep the A-arms and run uncut springs? I thought cutting stock springs were frowned upon and never considered that as a viable option. What sayeth LS1Tech?
- Strano Springs w/rear spring isolator
- Strano 35/Adj 22 Sway Bars (Set on the middle hole because of staggered setup)
- Koni 4/3 Shocks (played with settings multiple times)
- UMI bolt-on 2-point Subframe Connectors (Removed)
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. Panhard Bar
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. LCA's (Switched to BMR Adj. with Rubber Bushings)
- UMI bolt-on Relocation Brackets
Additional Info:
- No added weight in the rear
- On 18's but running taller profile tires (275/40R18 & 295/40R18)
I was planning on switching out the Strano's for stock springs and putting in my BMR 1" lowering A-arm but I'm thinking the Koni shocks will still interfere with my quest for a smoother ride. I am contemplating purchasing Bilsteins with stock cut springs and selling my BMR A-arms or should I keep the A-arms and run uncut springs? I thought cutting stock springs were frowned upon and never considered that as a viable option. What sayeth LS1Tech?
#7
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (1)
FWIW, I am running SLP Bilsteins on cut springs with modified upper mounts on the front and I can't really complain. I also put much better (more progressive) bump stops in the front.
I'd like to meet up with a local member on Stranos or BMR's and do a side by side comparison of ride quality so I can accurately describe how it compares to the two most popular aftermarket springs.
The key also is cutting them properly - keep them as cool as possible, don't go cutting with a torch.
I'd like to meet up with a local member on Stranos or BMR's and do a side by side comparison of ride quality so I can accurately describe how it compares to the two most popular aftermarket springs.
The key also is cutting them properly - keep them as cool as possible, don't go cutting with a torch.
Trending Topics
#8
10 Second Club
iTrader: (8)
You can cut springs. It's no big deal. What do you think people did before there were lowering springs for everything? Ride is dependent on multiple things and can be very subjective.
#10
TECH Regular
iTrader: (3)
As long as the springs aren't variable rate, cutting them is perfectly acceptable. I'm not sure how they are on our cars.. Keep in mind every coil you remove you increase the stiffness by roughly 10%.
I cut one coil (about 1") off the fronts of my Fiero matched with my own fabricated coilovers using AFCO springs and adjusters in the rear and the ride was still great.
I think the Koni's may be your issue, even on full soft they are probably too firm for you.
I cut one coil (about 1") off the fronts of my Fiero matched with my own fabricated coilovers using AFCO springs and adjusters in the rear and the ride was still great.
I think the Koni's may be your issue, even on full soft they are probably too firm for you.
#11
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (1)
It's gotta be OK, I mean....Gas Monkey does it:
Honestly, I think it's a good option, but it's more work. Do research, consider the wheel and tire combo you'll be running, the condition of the roads. Look up the "upper mount mod" on here, and consider swapping out those rock hard factory bump stops.
And, yeah - could be the Konis - I don't know as I have never even been in a Koni car, but reading between the lines here on Tech, I got the feeling they'd be too stiff for my taste/usage. I love my Bilsteins.
Honestly, I think it's a good option, but it's more work. Do research, consider the wheel and tire combo you'll be running, the condition of the roads. Look up the "upper mount mod" on here, and consider swapping out those rock hard factory bump stops.
And, yeah - could be the Konis - I don't know as I have never even been in a Koni car, but reading between the lines here on Tech, I got the feeling they'd be too stiff for my taste/usage. I love my Bilsteins.
#12
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (1)
That's what I mean by more work - took me two iteration to get it right. I cut 1 coil off the fronts and reassembled and wasn't fully happy with how the front sat - looked kind of like one of the taller Strano setups, and I wanted more of a "BMR" stance. So, I broke it down again and cut another 1/2 a coil. I wouldn't go any lower than I am right now. Sometimes I second guess myself and think I should have cut 1.25 coils. Nice thing is OE springs are cheap and plentiful....if I change my mind, I can swap them out for very little $$.
#13
11 Second Club
iTrader: (74)
I've got cut stock springs on mine, did it as a temporary deal while I get other stuff on the car done. I cut 1 coil off the fronts and 1.5 coils off the rear with the isolator removed. The shocks are a set from a friend that have 50k miles on them. It rides just like a stock f-body with a slight improvement in cornering ability. It has bottomed out the rear suspension a couple times - I think this is due to hitting the bumpstops as the thud is pretty loud the couple times it's happened. I had the same thing happen with bilsteins on a previous car so I don't think it's the shocks causing this.
#14
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (8)
In regards to your primary question, new Bilsteins and the cut stock springs should yield a relatively smooth ride. The Koni + Strano springs would be the ideal combination for handling purposes, however the stiffness leads to a little harshness on the streets.
As an aside, how well did your 275/40/18 tires fit on the front? Do you have rubbing issues? What wheels did you mount those on? I'm contemplating going from a 275/35/18 to a 275/40/18 on my lowered setup (Strano springs and I got the full 1.25" drop) just to get an extra half inch of clearance up front however I'm concerned they will rub really bad when wrapped around 18" x 9.5" C6 replica wheels (+58mm offset).
As an aside, how well did your 275/40/18 tires fit on the front? Do you have rubbing issues? What wheels did you mount those on? I'm contemplating going from a 275/35/18 to a 275/40/18 on my lowered setup (Strano springs and I got the full 1.25" drop) just to get an extra half inch of clearance up front however I'm concerned they will rub really bad when wrapped around 18" x 9.5" C6 replica wheels (+58mm offset).
#15
TECH Junkie
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: MA
Posts: 3,934
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think before you try to find a solution, you should try to figure out what the suspension is doing that causes you to dislike the ride. Rough ride is usually one of two things if it's shocks/springs.
1. Compression is too much.. your body absorbs the bumps
2. Compression is not enough.. you impact bumpstops at a high velocity
Which case do you think you are experiencing?
1. Compression is too much.. your body absorbs the bumps
2. Compression is not enough.. you impact bumpstops at a high velocity
Which case do you think you are experiencing?
#16
TECH Addict
iTrader: (46)
Well I'm looking for a setup that'll ride smoother on rough roads. Here is my tweaked setup:
- Strano Springs w/rear spring isolator
- Strano 35/Adj 22 Sway Bars (Set on the middle hole because of staggered setup)
- Koni 4/3 Shocks (played with settings multiple times)
- UMI bolt-on 2-point Subframe Connectors (Removed)
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. Panhard Bar
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. LCA's (Switched to BMR Adj. with Rubber Bushings)
- UMI bolt-on Relocation Brackets
Additional Info:
- No added weight in the rear
- On 18's but running taller profile tires (275/40R18 & 295/40R18)
I was planning on switching out the Strano's for stock springs and putting in my BMR 1" lowering A-arm but I'm thinking the Koni shocks will still interfere with my quest for a smoother ride. I am contemplating purchasing Bilsteins with stock cut springs and selling my BMR A-arms or should I keep the A-arms and run uncut springs? I thought cutting stock springs were frowned upon and never considered that as a viable option. What sayeth LS1Tech?
- Strano Springs w/rear spring isolator
- Strano 35/Adj 22 Sway Bars (Set on the middle hole because of staggered setup)
- Koni 4/3 Shocks (played with settings multiple times)
- UMI bolt-on 2-point Subframe Connectors (Removed)
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. Panhard Bar
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. LCA's (Switched to BMR Adj. with Rubber Bushings)
- UMI bolt-on Relocation Brackets
Additional Info:
- No added weight in the rear
- On 18's but running taller profile tires (275/40R18 & 295/40R18)
I was planning on switching out the Strano's for stock springs and putting in my BMR 1" lowering A-arm but I'm thinking the Koni shocks will still interfere with my quest for a smoother ride. I am contemplating purchasing Bilsteins with stock cut springs and selling my BMR A-arms or should I keep the A-arms and run uncut springs? I thought cutting stock springs were frowned upon and never considered that as a viable option. What sayeth LS1Tech?
I wonder what my 3/4 Koni's/Stranos would feel like on full soft. Still better than stock? or worse?
#17
TECH Senior Member
Well I'm looking for a setup that'll ride smoother on rough roads. Here is my tweaked setup:
- Strano Springs w/rear spring isolator
- Strano 35/Adj 22 Sway Bars (Set on the middle hole because of staggered setup)
- Koni 4/3 Shocks (played with settings multiple times)
- UMI bolt-on 2-point Subframe Connectors (Removed)
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. Panhard Bar
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. LCA's (Switched to BMR Adj. with Rubber Bushings)
- UMI bolt-on Relocation Brackets
Additional Info:
- No added weight in the rear
- On 18's but running taller profile tires (275/40R18 & 295/40R18)
I was planning on switching out the Strano's for stock springs and putting in my BMR 1" lowering A-arm but I'm thinking the Koni shocks will still interfere with my quest for a smoother ride. I am contemplating purchasing Bilsteins with stock cut springs and selling my BMR A-arms or should I keep the A-arms and run uncut springs? I thought cutting stock springs were frowned upon and never considered that as a viable option. What sayeth LS1Tech?
- Strano Springs w/rear spring isolator
- Strano 35/Adj 22 Sway Bars (Set on the middle hole because of staggered setup)
- Koni 4/3 Shocks (played with settings multiple times)
- UMI bolt-on 2-point Subframe Connectors (Removed)
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. Panhard Bar
- UMI Poly/Roto Adj. LCA's (Switched to BMR Adj. with Rubber Bushings)
- UMI bolt-on Relocation Brackets
Additional Info:
- No added weight in the rear
- On 18's but running taller profile tires (275/40R18 & 295/40R18)
I was planning on switching out the Strano's for stock springs and putting in my BMR 1" lowering A-arm but I'm thinking the Koni shocks will still interfere with my quest for a smoother ride. I am contemplating purchasing Bilsteins with stock cut springs and selling my BMR A-arms or should I keep the A-arms and run uncut springs? I thought cutting stock springs were frowned upon and never considered that as a viable option. What sayeth LS1Tech?
In your case, have you tried smaller (17") wheels? What about tires with softer sidewalls?
You may have larger sidewalls than normal for 18"s, but you still have the extra weight of the wheels/tires which certainly doesn't help.
Also noticed you have the adjustable rear bar, have you tried playing with that setting, setting it to softer? I know the rear bar will play a pretty big factor in how the rear of these cars ride.
#18
TECH Senior Member
Spring rate is a function of the spring height, coil thickness, number of coils (active) and diameter of the spring.
You could have a really tall soft spring you cut a coil off of and not gain near "10% stiffness", or a really short, stiff spring you cut a coil off of and get way more than "10% stiffness" increased.
#19
TECH Regular
iTrader: (3)
Way too vague of an assumption.
Spring rate is a function of the spring height, coil thickness, number of coils (active) and diameter of the spring.
You could have a really tall soft spring you cut a coil off of and not gain near "10% stiffness", or a really short, stiff spring you cut a coil off of and get way more than "10% stiffness" increased.
Spring rate is a function of the spring height, coil thickness, number of coils (active) and diameter of the spring.
You could have a really tall soft spring you cut a coil off of and not gain near "10% stiffness", or a really short, stiff spring you cut a coil off of and get way more than "10% stiffness" increased.
#20
In regards to your primary question, new Bilsteins and the cut stock springs should yield a relatively smooth ride. The Koni + Strano springs would be the ideal combination for handling purposes, however the stiffness leads to a little harshness on the streets.
As an aside, how well did your 275/40/18 tires fit on the front? Do you have rubbing issues? What wheels did you mount those on? I'm contemplating going from a 275/35/18 to a 275/40/18 on my lowered setup (Strano springs and I got the full 1.25" drop) just to get an extra half inch of clearance up front however I'm concerned they will rub really bad when wrapped around 18" x 9.5" C6 replica wheels (+58mm offset).
As an aside, how well did your 275/40/18 tires fit on the front? Do you have rubbing issues? What wheels did you mount those on? I'm contemplating going from a 275/35/18 to a 275/40/18 on my lowered setup (Strano springs and I got the full 1.25" drop) just to get an extra half inch of clearance up front however I'm concerned they will rub really bad when wrapped around 18" x 9.5" C6 replica wheels (+58mm offset).
Edit: figured out how to do it:
https://ls1tech.com/forums/wheels-ti...ano-konis.html
Last edited by 02TransAm/Batmobile; 06-18-2013 at 05:41 PM.