discussion: is the muscle car dead?
#1
TECH Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 495
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
discussion: is the muscle car dead?
In the 70's the muscle car was defined as an american made car with an american made v8 engine that cranked out serious torque to the rear tires. Less was considered more with simple designs and simple engineering. The only things that mattered was going fast!
Today people seem to have trouble defining what a muscle car is. For example The corvette is loosing its reputation as a muscle car as it creeps closer and closer to the world of exotics while some imports are creeping closer andto closer to the muscle catagory. Another example is that Some people argue wether or not CTSV's are muscle or sport-luxury.
No matter how you look at it today's muscle cars and the 70's muscle cars are not the same. Too much has changed.
So my question is... Has the muscle car gone extinct or has it evolved? What is your opinion?
Today people seem to have trouble defining what a muscle car is. For example The corvette is loosing its reputation as a muscle car as it creeps closer and closer to the world of exotics while some imports are creeping closer andto closer to the muscle catagory. Another example is that Some people argue wether or not CTSV's are muscle or sport-luxury.
No matter how you look at it today's muscle cars and the 70's muscle cars are not the same. Too much has changed.
So my question is... Has the muscle car gone extinct or has it evolved? What is your opinion?
#2
LS1Tech Co-Founder
iTrader: (38)
The Corvette has never been considered a "Muscle Car". The Corvette is a "Sports Car", and does fit into the category of other sports cars like the Porsche 911, Ferrari's, etc..
Camaro/Firebird/Mustang were also not musclecars, they were considered "Pony Cars" back then. The term muscle car was mostly meant to describe mid/full size 2-door sporty versions of cars, like the Chevelle, GTO, Torino, Fairlane, 442, etc...
Camaro/Firebird/Mustang were also not musclecars, they were considered "Pony Cars" back then. The term muscle car was mostly meant to describe mid/full size 2-door sporty versions of cars, like the Chevelle, GTO, Torino, Fairlane, 442, etc...
#4
I agree with both Nineball and Tardpenguin above^ Brings a better question. What does the modern day Mustang, GTO, and Camaro classify as ?
I have Ideas...Politically Correct and with the Pussification of the U.S. PussPony ?
Any others?
I have Ideas...Politically Correct and with the Pussification of the U.S. PussPony ?
Any others?
#6
TECH Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 495
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What nineball said is very true however many people consider pony cars to be muscle cars.
http://www.musclecarclub.com/musclec...finition.shtml
There is one source of debate.
http://www.musclecarclub.com/musclec...finition.shtml
There is one source of debate.
Trending Topics
#8
TECH Resident
iTrader: (4)
I don't believe that you can classify the newer cars as muscle cars. "Real" muscle cars died in 1972. The newer ones, yes they outperform the older ones by a long shot, but are they really musclecars? The debate continues. I would rather have a 1st gen Camaro than a 5th gen as a play toy. But then again, I would rather have a playmate as a playtoy.
#9
11 Second Club
iTrader: (6)
i consider pony cars to be a class of muscle cars. i also think that the term "muscle car" has changed over the years. if we go by the old definition, the ctsv and g8 are real muscle cars but by todays definition, so are camaros and mustangs. niether definition puts the vette in muscle cars
#11
Cars wont be built the same with all the safety and emmisions. I know id be damned if i drove anything without atleast an A/C in this texas heat. If you convert what it used to cost for vehicles back in the day to our cost nowdays you get way more for your money right? And yeah my next car is gonna be a 09+cts-v. 4 Doors 556hp v8 supercharged.......and fits the family.
#13
9 Second Club
iTrader: (5)
died, i dont think so. evolved or changed, greatly. what would you consider a nova, falcon, or dart? would you consider those a muscle car? back in the day those were the cobalts, cavaliers or escorts. look at the s10 would you consider those muscle trucks? those are popping up more frequently. from what i have seen, people build what is easy to get and can go faster with less money. today its corvettes. 10 years ago, it was fox body mustangs. 15 years ago the quintessential muscle, pony car was what everybody was building. back then you could get a very nice 69 camaro for a couple grand. its not like that today. to find a decent 69 camaro rolling shell would be a minimum of $5k. not everybody has that kind of expendable cash laying around, but they do have a monthly car note to pay for their 2010 Z06 Vette.
So I do not think the "Muscle Car" has died, just greatly evolved.
So I do not think the "Muscle Car" has died, just greatly evolved.
#14
9 Second Club
iTrader: (21)
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: League City, Texas
Posts: 616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think today's average Joe considers a muscle car to be something that is a car, has a V8 or better, is RWD, and is by an American automaker. By those specs, a Vette IS a muscle car. But we know better.
#15
On The Tree
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Clarksville, TN
Posts: 171
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
my personal definition of muscle car requires that the car must handle like ****, so the vette is def out. to me, a muscle car is a rwd v8 designed to do one thing: go fast in a straight line. plenty of modern cars fit that description. the fact that they're not old doesn't mean anything. if anything, they're faster, more efficient, and more durable than their predecessors. nothing wrong with that
#16
It is fitting to say that true muscle cars died in 72.... The GM A body (GTO, cutlass, chevelle, skylark) had all ballooned up for '73 saddled with emissions and safety add ons. The charger and roadrunner took on their more refined look for the 70's and not really sure what ford was doing.
Still- the 'muscle cars' of today are much bigger than the cars they are trying to look like. This became painfully obvious when I got in our 69 firebird last week. I would say that the muscle car was brought back from the dead to replace the pony car market.
Still- the 'muscle cars' of today are much bigger than the cars they are trying to look like. This became painfully obvious when I got in our 69 firebird last week. I would say that the muscle car was brought back from the dead to replace the pony car market.
#17
TECH Regular
died, i dont think so. evolved or changed, greatly. what would you consider a nova, falcon, or dart? would you consider those a muscle car? back in the day those were the cobalts, cavaliers or escorts. look at the s10 would you consider those muscle trucks? those are popping up more frequently. from what i have seen, people build what is easy to get and can go faster with less money. today its corvettes. 10 years ago, it was fox body mustangs. 15 years ago the quintessential muscle, pony car was what everybody was building. back then you could get a very nice 69 camaro for a couple grand. its not like that today. to find a decent 69 camaro rolling shell would be a minimum of $5k. not everybody has that kind of expendable cash laying around, but they do have a monthly car note to pay for their 2010 Z06 Vette.
So I do not think the "Muscle Car" has died, just greatly evolved.
So I do not think the "Muscle Car" has died, just greatly evolved.
#18
In-Zane Moderator
iTrader: (25)
Change, it is what happens, through the smog era and fuel crisis, fuel injection ect, the die hard gear heads are still here.
Although some are confused, like homosexuals, it used to be if you were gay, you were in the closet, but now it is something that the world has tried to make OK, same for liking 4 cylinders, you might like them, but to many out there, it is the same as being a guy that likes men, it is just gay no matter how you look at it.
The ******* is always there, everyone has one, and they are opinions, no two are the same, American iron is what some consider "muscle", that means 1974 and older, everything after that is junk to some. But now with the fast and queerious lovers that screwed up the street scene, it is making things dies out for allot of the car enthusiasts, it is life and the muscle car era of time past is basically dead for the large majority, but many keep it alive and make sure that it never goes away.
Although some are confused, like homosexuals, it used to be if you were gay, you were in the closet, but now it is something that the world has tried to make OK, same for liking 4 cylinders, you might like them, but to many out there, it is the same as being a guy that likes men, it is just gay no matter how you look at it.
The ******* is always there, everyone has one, and they are opinions, no two are the same, American iron is what some consider "muscle", that means 1974 and older, everything after that is junk to some. But now with the fast and queerious lovers that screwed up the street scene, it is making things dies out for allot of the car enthusiasts, it is life and the muscle car era of time past is basically dead for the large majority, but many keep it alive and make sure that it never goes away.
#19
When all the baby boomers are dead and buried, it will be my (our) generation talking **** about our childrens cars and tell them about the all mighty LSx (or whatever) era while they charge their **** in the garage wondering how we ever drove something that exploded 48000 times a minute.. lol
#20
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Ft. Worth-ish
Posts: 600
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This is like debating if rock and roll is dead. It sure isn't what it was in the 50's, 60's or 70's (modern country is more 70's rock than country anymore), but it isn't dead and neither are muscle cars. So I agree with the evolution statement. Muscle cars have evolved. I cut my teeth working on old cars. I remember having to mess with points and drum brakes, and I for one am glad for the progress.