Is drivetrain loss a percentage of total power & torque or a fixed amount?
#1
Launching!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Monticello, MN
Posts: 224
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is drivetrain loss a percentage of total power & torque or a fixed amount?
Question pretty well says it. I've been told Y-body transmission losses are about 15% for an M6 and about 20% for an A4. I realize gearing has some effect, as would greater rpm, but do not understand why power and torque loss would be greatly affected by increasing the total engine output. Therefore, I was wondering if it's rather closer to a fixed loss (at max power and torque) rather than a percentage of whatever total your engine is capable of producing. All thoughts and opinions welcome, but if anyone has any documented evidence one way or the other, it would be really appreciated also. Thanks!
Ed
Ed
#4
Launching!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Monticello, MN
Posts: 224
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by john kilgore
l think if you think about it you'll see that it always takes more power to do any amount of work if it is done quickly.
Ed
#5
TECH Addict
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Lincoln, NE
Posts: 2,869
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just do a simple comparison...look at high HP cars...like George Baxters 1100hp 383 LT1 making 800-900 to the wheels. Compare it to your daily LS1, 350rwhp which makes around 400 at the crank. There's your answer.
#6
Moderator
iTrader: (11)
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: East Central Florida
Posts: 12,604
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
There are loss components that vary purely with RPM, and
speed, and there are those that vary with load.
For example, the gear-in-oil loss in the rear end will be purely
MPH. The rear gear scrub losses in the hypoid gears will vary
with load however. And your 9" drag car will differ from your
skinny 10-bolt, in both (bigger gear radius in the soup, more
drag torque; more off-center, more drag).
The A4 takes shaft power to spin the oil pump and the
pressure head is varied with load, so you have a loss that
depends on both load and RPM.
Thye A4 converter used on a big power car, you can bet will
be well different in stall speed and efficiency from a stocker
or a "street performance" bolt-on car. Easily 5%, maybe 10%
loss in efficiency right there if you go from a 3000 to a 4000
stall speed. Efficiency becomes peakier as well, another point
of variability.
So much for rules of thumb.
speed, and there are those that vary with load.
For example, the gear-in-oil loss in the rear end will be purely
MPH. The rear gear scrub losses in the hypoid gears will vary
with load however. And your 9" drag car will differ from your
skinny 10-bolt, in both (bigger gear radius in the soup, more
drag torque; more off-center, more drag).
The A4 takes shaft power to spin the oil pump and the
pressure head is varied with load, so you have a loss that
depends on both load and RPM.
Thye A4 converter used on a big power car, you can bet will
be well different in stall speed and efficiency from a stocker
or a "street performance" bolt-on car. Easily 5%, maybe 10%
loss in efficiency right there if you go from a 3000 to a 4000
stall speed. Efficiency becomes peakier as well, another point
of variability.
So much for rules of thumb.
#7
johns statement is true.most of us have been led to believe that with a given weight of rotating internal components and frictional losses that regardless of input torque or horsepower it will take the same amount of energy to spin them up and complete power transmission.dynamometer results have proven this to be incorrect due to other variables at work.the engines ability to gain rpm against the transmission ,final drive,tires,resistance and vehicle weight,extended rpm needed to produce extra power,component spin up time ,converter and inertia etc all increase horsepower and frictional losses created and consumed before exiting the output shaft as usable power.i have seen this power loss ratio to be not as biased towards higher horsepower losses as power goes up with the 2004r verses the th400 however.this produced confusion for me after spending some time on a chassis dyno before i had time to think about why.
Trending Topics
#8
losses
also if it helps, the power loss is directed connected to time. time is your killer, if you cut the time in half that you are in first gear the power loss might be squared. in other words if you cut the time in half the power loss could be squared(5hp squared or 25hp). but sometimes more rear end gear makes up for the loss because your car moves easier.