What is the normal battery draw?
#21
Here we go.. I unhooked the alternator, the draw went away. Did the diode test from the video Anthony Toal posted. The alternator pasted. Connected the power wire back to the alternator and there is no draw. I disconnected my multimeter, plugged the pig tail back into the alternator, run the test again, there's a draw. I disconnect the pig tail, draw is still there. I unhook the multimeter. Wait a few minutes for the system to shut off. Run the test again, this time only the power wire is connect in the back, I am still getting a draw. I disconnect the multimeter, disconnect the power wire in the back, run the test, no draw. Ok connect the power wire back, run the test, no draw, so I connect the pig tail back while the test is running, no draw. I also ran the test with power disconnect from the alt. but the pig tail still plugged in and there was no draw. WTF is going on? Every time I do something different I get a different result. One thing is for sure though, If the alternator is disconnected from the battery, there is no draw.
#22
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Okay, first what equipment are you using (Fluke, Knight, Southwire, etc) and how are you reading the draw with it? From what you shared so far, it may seem that a hot wiring is either shorting or grounding. Next thing you can do is Ohm the lug on the alternator to housing of the alternator, you may be experiencing a float.
#23
Okay, so just to confirm, you are putting the probes in series with the cable and the battery? Such that battery cable <---- probe <---- DMM ----> Probe ----> Battery terminal. Also, I would use the positive side, electrons actually work backwards then what everyone thinks, the whole negative charge argument and how it should be laid out, though your value shouldnt change if the draw is there. The other problem using the negative side is that if you do have a short, the grounds can act as a float and give you a weird reading. This is all through my own experience, so take it with a grain of salt.
The lug on the alternator is where you connect the power wire to, sorry, but that what I call them, lugs. Take positive probe (red) to the lug, with power wire disconnected, and then the com probe (black) to the housing of the alternator. You may have to spin the alternator some, you should get OL or 0ohms. What I am trying to confirm is if you have a bad winding and it is brushing up against something it shouldn't and that could be why every time you did your test you did or didn't have a draw, although if the diode is good, the alternator shouldnt be in play period, one of the wires could either be shorting or grounding and you plugging and unplugging them can make that change. Time to do the wiggle test! Your next bet is just get another alternator and slap it on their and see what happens, if nothing changes, return it and start over.
The lug on the alternator is where you connect the power wire to, sorry, but that what I call them, lugs. Take positive probe (red) to the lug, with power wire disconnected, and then the com probe (black) to the housing of the alternator. You may have to spin the alternator some, you should get OL or 0ohms. What I am trying to confirm is if you have a bad winding and it is brushing up against something it shouldn't and that could be why every time you did your test you did or didn't have a draw, although if the diode is good, the alternator shouldnt be in play period, one of the wires could either be shorting or grounding and you plugging and unplugging them can make that change. Time to do the wiggle test! Your next bet is just get another alternator and slap it on their and see what happens, if nothing changes, return it and start over.
Last edited by Anthony Toal; 04-04-2017 at 09:59 AM.
#24
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Okay, so just to confirm, you are putting the probes in series with the cable and the battery? Such that battery cable <---- probe <---- DMM ----> Probe ----> Battery terminal. Also, I would use the positive side, electrons actually work backwards then what everyone thinks, the whole negative charge argument and how it should be laid out, though your value shouldnt change if the draw is there. The other problem using the negative side is that if you do have a short, the grounds can act as a float and give you a weird reading. This is all through my own experience, so take it with a grain of salt.
The lug on the alternator is where you connect the power wire to, sorry, but that what I call them, lugs. Take positive probe (red) to the lug, with power wire disconnected, and then the com probe (black) to the housing of the alternator. You may have to spin the alternator some, you should get OL or 0ohms. What I am trying to confirm is if you have a bad winding and it is brushing up against something it shouldn't and that could be why every time you did your test you did or didn't have a draw, although if the diode is good, the alternator shouldnt be in play period, one of the wires could either be shorting or grounding and you plugging and unplugging them can make that change. Time to do the wiggle test! Your next bet is just get another alternator and slap it on their and see what happens, if nothing changes, return it and start over.
The lug on the alternator is where you connect the power wire to, sorry, but that what I call them, lugs. Take positive probe (red) to the lug, with power wire disconnected, and then the com probe (black) to the housing of the alternator. You may have to spin the alternator some, you should get OL or 0ohms. What I am trying to confirm is if you have a bad winding and it is brushing up against something it shouldn't and that could be why every time you did your test you did or didn't have a draw, although if the diode is good, the alternator shouldnt be in play period, one of the wires could either be shorting or grounding and you plugging and unplugging them can make that change. Time to do the wiggle test! Your next bet is just get another alternator and slap it on their and see what happens, if nothing changes, return it and start over.
#25
I am making my connections just as you described. I will try using the positive side of the battery and see what happens with that. I have been wiggling the power wire around and it hasn't had any effect. I wonder if I take the alternator to a parts store and have them test it if it will show anything?
#26
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (1)
I'm pretty sure the car's brains wake up off and on throughout the first little bot the car has been turned off. I wonder if it also happens when you reconnect the battery. This is a tough thing to troubleshoot on a car like this. I sent my Lincoln Mark VII to auction for something similar and that would've been way easier to find I bet.
#28
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm pretty sure the car's brains wake up off and on throughout the first little bot the car has been turned off. I wonder if it also happens when you reconnect the battery. This is a tough thing to troubleshoot on a car like this. I sent my Lincoln Mark VII to auction for something similar and that would've been way easier to find I bet.
I did the parasitic draw test using the positive terminal on the battery this time. The draw was the same, still getting getting a draw when the alternator is connected and then the draw goes away when it's not. I didn't bother trying to trouble shoot it any further. Now I am just waiting on Rockauto.com to accept my warranty exchange. When I get the new alternator I'll let you guys know if that fixes the problem.
#31
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sssnake View Post
I cannot swear this is true for the 04 and 05 Vs but I know it is true for the 06 and 07 Vs... the alt needs a PWM signal to the alt to control the charging. Jumpering to a battery hot will likely cause over charging which will kill your battery.
I'm not sure what will happen. I'll keep you posted if my battery dies from this. If it does hopefully it will still be under warranty. I was getting really tired of the Battery Not Charging popping up on my screen.
Originally Posted by Sssnake View Post
I cannot swear this is true for the 04 and 05 Vs but I know it is true for the 06 and 07 Vs... the alt needs a PWM signal to the alt to control the charging. Jumpering to a battery hot will likely cause over charging which will kill your battery.
I'm not sure what will happen. I'll keep you posted if my battery dies from this. If it does hopefully it will still be under warranty. I was getting really tired of the Battery Not Charging popping up on my screen.
I still believe that alt needs a PWM signal NOT a battery hot. Connecting like you did would very likely cause the parasitic draw you have now. Also, once you put in the new alt you will likely get a similar result. Now the alt may be bad but the symptoms you are now describing are exactly what I would expect (along with a few others) by using the "fix" you implemented.
#32
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From your other thread.^^^^^
I still believe that alt needs a PWM signal NOT a battery hot. Connecting like you did would very likely cause the parasitic draw you have now. Also, once you put in the new alt you will likely get a similar result. Now the alt may be bad but the symptoms you are now describing are exactly what I would expect (along with a few others) by using the "fix" you implemented.
I still believe that alt needs a PWM signal NOT a battery hot. Connecting like you did would very likely cause the parasitic draw you have now. Also, once you put in the new alt you will likely get a similar result. Now the alt may be bad but the symptoms you are now describing are exactly what I would expect (along with a few others) by using the "fix" you implemented.
#33
Great catch, sssnake.
#34
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes, you need a control signal. On my Mechman alternator, I opted for their AVBM II voltage controller, which allow you to adjust the desired output voltage through the same type of 4-pin connector.
Great catch, sssnake.
Great catch, sssnake.
#35
To be fair to the V1, any modern domestic or import car will have electrical problems if the alternator control signal is interrupted.
#37
TECH Addict
iTrader: (19)
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Where the Navy tells me to go
Posts: 2,397
Received 106 Likes
on
88 Posts
My is at Lindsay now to troubleshoot something else, and I asked them to locate the parasitic draw (it would kill the battery in a day if I didn't drive it). They found 2 loads - headlight washers relay and Onstar module - creating a 300ma draw. I don't use either of those, so I told 'em to just leave those disconnected. With those disconnected, it's down to a 13ma draw.
Hindsight being 20/20, wish I had thought to pull the relays/fuses for stuff I never use, on the off chance those components were the source(s) of the parasitic draw - I could've ruled some **** out without impacting my use of the car at all.
Hindsight being 20/20, wish I had thought to pull the relays/fuses for stuff I never use, on the off chance those components were the source(s) of the parasitic draw - I could've ruled some **** out without impacting my use of the car at all.
#38
My is at Lindsay now to troubleshoot something else, and I asked them to locate the parasitic draw (it would kill the battery in a day if I didn't drive it). They found 2 loads - headlight washers relay and Onstar module - creating a 300ma draw. I don't use either of those, so I told 'em to just leave those disconnected. With those disconnected, it's down to a 13ma draw.
Hindsight being 20/20, wish I had thought to pull the relays/fuses for stuff I never use, on the off chance those components were the source(s) of the parasitic draw - I could've ruled some **** out without impacting my use of the car at all.
Hindsight being 20/20, wish I had thought to pull the relays/fuses for stuff I never use, on the off chance those components were the source(s) of the parasitic draw - I could've ruled some **** out without impacting my use of the car at all.
#40
Staging Lane
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My headlight washer weren't working until I replace the fuse. Though the fuse that I took out still works fine. Anyway, I am still waiting on my alternator to be replaced under warranty and of course they're out of stock at the moment.