Summit stage 2 or stage 3 cam opinions
#23
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
With any performance build, the bigger diameter pushrod you can fit, the better. The reasoning behind this is pushrod flex. When…not if….when a pushrod is flexing, it’s causing two problems.
1. A flexing pushrod is a shorter pushrod. Your losing lift at the valve.
2. A flexing pushrod is causing harmonics that greatly affects spring life, as well as rocker trunnion/bushing/bearing life.
All engines fight harmonics. Harmonics are the engines enemy, fighting it against rpm potential, and overall lifespan. A larger diameter pushrod will block more harmonics because it’s flexing less than its smaller version. In pushrods, diameter trumps wall thickness for strength. Wall thickness is going to make a difference for sure, but diameter Vs. diameter, the larger diameter of the two pushrods will be stronger, irregardless of wall thickness. Always remember that the pushrod is the second spring in the valvetrain.
1. A flexing pushrod is a shorter pushrod. Your losing lift at the valve.
2. A flexing pushrod is causing harmonics that greatly affects spring life, as well as rocker trunnion/bushing/bearing life.
All engines fight harmonics. Harmonics are the engines enemy, fighting it against rpm potential, and overall lifespan. A larger diameter pushrod will block more harmonics because it’s flexing less than its smaller version. In pushrods, diameter trumps wall thickness for strength. Wall thickness is going to make a difference for sure, but diameter Vs. diameter, the larger diameter of the two pushrods will be stronger, irregardless of wall thickness. Always remember that the pushrod is the second spring in the valvetrain.
The following users liked this post:
G Atsma (01-06-2024)
#24
8 Second Club
iTrader: (4)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
With any performance build, the bigger diameter pushrod you can fit, the better. The reasoning behind this is pushrod flex. When…not if….when a pushrod is flexing, it’s causing two problems.
1. A flexing pushrod is a shorter pushrod. Your losing lift at the valve.
2. A flexing pushrod is causing harmonics that greatly affects spring life, as well as rocker trunnion/bushing/bearing life.
All engines fight harmonics. Harmonics are the engines enemy, fighting it against rpm potential, and overall lifespan. A larger diameter pushrod will block more harmonics because it’s flexing less than its smaller version. In pushrods, diameter trumps wall thickness for strength. Wall thickness is going to make a difference for sure, but diameter Vs. diameter, the larger diameter of the two pushrods will be stronger, irregardless of wall thickness. Always remember that the pushrod is the second spring in the valvetrain.
1. A flexing pushrod is a shorter pushrod. Your losing lift at the valve.
2. A flexing pushrod is causing harmonics that greatly affects spring life, as well as rocker trunnion/bushing/bearing life.
All engines fight harmonics. Harmonics are the engines enemy, fighting it against rpm potential, and overall lifespan. A larger diameter pushrod will block more harmonics because it’s flexing less than its smaller version. In pushrods, diameter trumps wall thickness for strength. Wall thickness is going to make a difference for sure, but diameter Vs. diameter, the larger diameter of the two pushrods will be stronger, irregardless of wall thickness. Always remember that the pushrod is the second spring in the valvetrain.
As mentioned I've leaned on the OEM stuff really hard and never seen a failure or had an issues valvetrain related. Also never saw improvements ET/Trap wise when I replaced them. What I did have was people telling me I needed larger springs and better push rods... which never helped any of my issues. Just hurt my pocket book.
What I'm wondering is if this is similar to the usual band wagon bs... like rod bolts, main studs, fancy head gaskets, head studs, forged rotating assy's etc etc...
#25
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Right I know the reason they are used. At what point are they flexing enough to make a nats *** worth of difference VS a "real" difference is my point.
As mentioned I've leaned on the OEM stuff really hard and never seen a failure or had an issues valvetrain related. Also never saw improvements ET/Trap wise when I replaced them. What I did have was people telling me I needed larger springs and better push rods... which never helped any of my issues. Just hurt my pocket book.
What I'm wondering is if this is similar to the usual band wagon bs... like rod bolts, main studs, fancy head gaskets, head studs, forged rotating assy's etc etc...
As mentioned I've leaned on the OEM stuff really hard and never seen a failure or had an issues valvetrain related. Also never saw improvements ET/Trap wise when I replaced them. What I did have was people telling me I needed larger springs and better push rods... which never helped any of my issues. Just hurt my pocket book.
What I'm wondering is if this is similar to the usual band wagon bs... like rod bolts, main studs, fancy head gaskets, head studs, forged rotating assy's etc etc...
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...stiffness.html
#26
8 Second Club
iTrader: (4)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Don't get me wrong, appreciate the comments. Not trying to argue with ya. Just not sure its a warranted upgrade in some cases when you compare the failure rate and gains VS the cost. I put my 3/8 push rods in at the track and did back to back pulls. I'm not saying the valve train isn't happier... only that the previous part didn't fail and I saw no gains so to speak. Once you get into "big" aggressive ramp rates and "big" spring pressures I know the factory stuff won't be up for the job. Just wondering what that point really is.
#27
TECH Veteran
iTrader: (1)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
100% will make a real difference. Rather than bore you with more rambling from me, here’s a link to a real world experiment with larger diameter pushrods with real world results. Fwiw here, each build will require its own unique pushrod spec that’s determined by rpm, spring pressure, pushrod length (the longer the rod, the weaker), rocker ratio, etc. I know you already know all of this, so I’ll hush. The thread in this link is a very quick read with scientific modeling and results…enjoy.
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...stiffness.html
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...stiffness.html
#28
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
While I have no doubt that many experiments have shown better results with bigger/thicker/more hardened pushrods, the linked thread is nearly useless speculation. The data put into the modeling software was inaccurate, and the real world tests were done with different fuels in different conditions. Overall mass and hardness have a significant effect on the harmonics of any item, and he fudges one number while ignoring the other.
#29
TECH Veteran
iTrader: (1)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Well that stinks. It’s a thread I stumbled across while looking at what the author of the thread had previously done, as his engine threads are typically informational and thorough. I honestly never bothered to check his data. I agree completely with you about the end result numbers being curious because of the fuels, but then again I never considered there being a performance inducing difference between a summer blend and a winter blend pump fuel. My main point of the link was an attempt to help Forcefed see the strength differences between the different pushrods. I suppose the bottom line here in all this pushrod talk is that, if one can’t understand the simple logic of a stronger pushrod (spring) being responsible for improved valvetrain control, and therefore improved engine performance, well…I dunno what else I can add to the discussion.
#30
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
#32
8 Second Club
iTrader: (4)
![Default](https://ls1tech.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Also want to say I'm in no way stating the OEM pushrod is capable of the above.... But if it is.. I will save my money for other things and put push rods in the same file as rod bolts and head studs.
The following users liked this post:
Che70velle (01-07-2024)