What would you do? 178k mile motor
#1
What would you do? 178k mile motor
I recently bought a bone stock '99 TA. It has 178k miles on the motor and overall the car has needed some TLC. It has the typical oil pan leak, and honestly the car just feels low on power. I am looking to make it reliable enough to dd with decent n/a power.
I have been looking into buying a Thompson Motorsports stage 1 5.3 or 6.0 long block (not much difference in price)to cut down on the cars down time and to get a fresh setup in it.
local rebuilders quotes have started around $3k with me bringing the motor to them to rebuild with stock components, and around $5k with minor head work and a few upgraded internal components.
Would you guys do anything different to get some reliability and power out of a motor with the mileage it has? I don't want to throw a heads/cam package on it and turn it into a ticking time bomb.
not looking to be cheap about it, also don't want to unnecessarily spend excess money.
I have been looking into buying a Thompson Motorsports stage 1 5.3 or 6.0 long block (not much difference in price)to cut down on the cars down time and to get a fresh setup in it.
local rebuilders quotes have started around $3k with me bringing the motor to them to rebuild with stock components, and around $5k with minor head work and a few upgraded internal components.
Would you guys do anything different to get some reliability and power out of a motor with the mileage it has? I don't want to throw a heads/cam package on it and turn it into a ticking time bomb.
not looking to be cheap about it, also don't want to unnecessarily spend excess money.
#3
You would be ok with throwing a h/c/I setup on a 178k LS1 so long as compression is good?
I'm asking, not to question you, but just out of curiosity. I just feel that may expose other weak points in the drive train and end up costing me more as I hunt down issues.
If that been done without issue repeatedly then I'm all for it and I'll just have a rainy day fund set aside.
I'm asking, not to question you, but just out of curiosity. I just feel that may expose other weak points in the drive train and end up costing me more as I hunt down issues.
If that been done without issue repeatedly then I'm all for it and I'll just have a rainy day fund set aside.
#5
yes, looking to stay n/a for now. What kind of power are you making with the 6.0? The stg 1 TMS 5.3 is a couple hundred cheaper, but also seems to have a little more work done to it when comparing it to the stg 1 TMS 6.0 so I'm really curious to know the power differences between the two.
#7
http://www.thompsonmotorsports.net/p...roducts_id=212
stg 1 6.0
http://www.thompsonmotorsports.net/p...roducts_id=222
I'm going to give them a call in the morning and see what they say about the power differences, I would expect the 6.0 to have more tq throughout, but not sure about overall hp #'s
Trending Topics
#8
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: Howell & Fenton MI
Posts: 11,145
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
15 Posts
Just based on a quick glance they both will make aimilar peak power, since they both have the same basic top end, but the 6.0 will have much better low and mid range power with a lot better torque. I run the same 862 casting that they are offering but with their 236/242 cam.
#9
Just based on a quick glance they both will make aimilar peak power, since they both have the same basic top end, but the 6.0 will have much better low and mid range power with a lot better torque. I run the same 862 casting that they are offering but with their 236/242 cam.
The only question now: is it worth it to go ahead and get the new motor or would it be considered reasonably safe to start the modification process on a 178k mile motor.
#10
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: Howell & Fenton MI
Posts: 11,145
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
15 Posts
And that is a good question lol. My line of thinking says 178k is lot...on the other hand if everything checks out and is in good shape then it might be better to stay with that. The only reason I went with the TMS 6.0 was because my LS1 blew up. At the time it was the most reasonable and cheapest option to get what I wanted
#11
And that is a good question lol. My line of thinking says 178k is lot...on the other hand if everything checks out and is in good shape then it might be better to stay with that. The only reason I went with the TMS 6.0 was because my LS1 blew up. At the time it was the most reasonable and cheapest option to get what I wanted
#14
TECH Fanatic
Why put the added weight of iron over the nose for an NA setup? I'd roll with what you have if it isn't burning copious amounts of oil and the compression checks out.
Those rebuild quotes are insane for a stock rebuild. I had $2800 in my 404 shortblock's machine work, and that included new pistons, turning the crank, and bushing two lifter bores.
Those rebuild quotes are insane for a stock rebuild. I had $2800 in my 404 shortblock's machine work, and that included new pistons, turning the crank, and bushing two lifter bores.
#15
Why put the added weight of iron over the nose for an NA setup? I'd roll with what you have if it isn't burning copious amounts of oil and the compression checks out.
Those rebuild quotes are insane for a stock rebuild. I had $2800 in my 404 shortblock's machine work, and that included new pistons, turning the crank, and bushing two lifter bores.
Those rebuild quotes are insane for a stock rebuild. I had $2800 in my 404 shortblock's machine work, and that included new pistons, turning the crank, and bushing two lifter bores.
The rebuild prices are insane! We have two performance shops around here that do LS specific motor work and they charge a real premium for them.....which is why I've just considered a whole new long block considering the price isn't much more
#17
lol. That was the original plan. But I plan on going back to school next year for my masters. I'd like the car to remain reliable during that time, and a turbo build will not be reliable with me in control. I'll just keep turning it up. :/.
so, a nice n/a build is the right thing for me at this time.
so, a nice n/a build is the right thing for me at this time.
#19
I did. The guy I talked to recommended just buying a motor, but in the same breath was trying to sell me on a 418 stroker long block for ~$7,400 that they had discounted.... So it's hard to take their recommendation seriously. No doubt they have great products or I wouldn't be set on using them, but this guy wasn't trying to listen as much as he was trying to sell.
I'm going to get a compression test this week if I can and go from there I guess.
I'm going to get a compression test this week if I can and go from there I guess.
#20
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: Howell & Fenton MI
Posts: 11,145
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
15 Posts
I did. The guy I talked to recommended just buying a motor, but in the same breath was trying to sell me on a 418 stroker long block for ~$7,400 that they had discounted.... So it's hard to take their recommendation seriously. No doubt they have great products or I wouldn't be set on using them, but this guy wasn't trying to listen as much as he was trying to sell.
I'm going to get a compression test this week if I can and go from there I guess.
I'm going to get a compression test this week if I can and go from there I guess.