New, to me, truck with tons of KR no matter what fuel
#1
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (43)
New, to me, truck with tons of KR no matter what fuel
2008 Silverado, 63,000 miles, 5.3, 4L60E, 3.73, NON Flex Fuel, with AFM, seems to run very well, but shows a LOT of KR at random times all over the datalogs
My old 2002 5.3 Silverado (same drivetrain numbers) allowed a good amount of timing before any hint of KR, was tuned for towing and 87 octane.
I thought a log I took yesterday (first one for this vehicle), was showing false knock, and of course it's a tad too large to attach here, so this morning, took another log, halfway to work, with 87 octane, then filled (1/2 tank to fill), with 93 octane, to see if KR disappeared, or minimized.
If anything, it showed more often KR.
I bought the truck from the original, older owner, so highly doubt there's ever been any "tuning" done to it.
I just don't get why there is so much KR?
Can anyone shed any light, or point me in the right direction?
Not asking for a free tune. I just have never seen so much KR on a stock vehicle, and am hoping someone with more experience than I, can take a look and offer an opinion.
LOG 111111 is 87 octane
LOG 222222 is 93 octane (mixed w/half tank 87)
p.s.
Pay no attention to WIDEBAND reading. Just got the truck and wideband is showing it's DEFAULT, since it is not connected yet.
My old 2002 5.3 Silverado (same drivetrain numbers) allowed a good amount of timing before any hint of KR, was tuned for towing and 87 octane.
I thought a log I took yesterday (first one for this vehicle), was showing false knock, and of course it's a tad too large to attach here, so this morning, took another log, halfway to work, with 87 octane, then filled (1/2 tank to fill), with 93 octane, to see if KR disappeared, or minimized.
If anything, it showed more often KR.
I bought the truck from the original, older owner, so highly doubt there's ever been any "tuning" done to it.
I just don't get why there is so much KR?
Can anyone shed any light, or point me in the right direction?
Not asking for a free tune. I just have never seen so much KR on a stock vehicle, and am hoping someone with more experience than I, can take a look and offer an opinion.
LOG 111111 is 87 octane
LOG 222222 is 93 octane (mixed w/half tank 87)
p.s.
Pay no attention to WIDEBAND reading. Just got the truck and wideband is showing it's DEFAULT, since it is not connected yet.
Last edited by rel3rd; 02-06-2020 at 08:42 AM.
#5
TECH Veteran
iTrader: (1)
Are you sure it is real KR, or "burst KR"? Real knock retard happens when the sensors detect actual knock, but burst knock retard can show up when the computer program is set to prevent knock. some of the truck tunes are very conservative in this regard, and will kill timing preemptively, no matter the real knock status.
edit- Unless you specifically set your scanner to show the difference, any KR will read, whether real or computer imagined.
edit- Unless you specifically set your scanner to show the difference, any KR will read, whether real or computer imagined.
#6
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (43)
I zeroed out all retard in the BASE vs. CYL AIR DELTA section
Are you sure it is real KR, or "burst KR"? Real knock retard happens when the sensors detect actual knock, but burst knock retard can show up when the computer program is set to prevent knock. some of the truck tunes are very conservative in this regard, and will kill timing preemptively, no matter the real knock status.
edit- Unless you specifically set your scanner to show the difference, any KR will read, whether real or computer imagined.
edit- Unless you specifically set your scanner to show the difference, any KR will read, whether real or computer imagined.
I also screenshotted, Knock Retard, Burst Knock, and Knock Learn Factor
This is a log with 100% STOCK GM TUNE, with only mod being DoD DISABLED.
Last edited by rel3rd; 02-06-2020 at 08:42 AM.
Trending Topics
#8
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (43)
Here is a good chamber cleaner.
http://Genuine Chrysler Accessories ..._l3JhDb6C02P1P
http://Genuine Chrysler Accessories ..._l3JhDb6C02P1P
#10
TECH Senior Member
Berryman's Chemtool B-12 works pretty well too.
#14
TECH Addict
iTrader: (32)
Base vs Cyl delta table. Max it out.
all the multipliers below it set them to zero.
Have u checked and made sure there is nothing hitting under the truck that would make the knock sensors go crazy? Like exhaust, motor mounts, driveshaft etc. Ive seen stuff like tht make them go crazy
all the multipliers below it set them to zero.
Have u checked and made sure there is nothing hitting under the truck that would make the knock sensors go crazy? Like exhaust, motor mounts, driveshaft etc. Ive seen stuff like tht make them go crazy
#15
Moderator
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: My own internal universe
Posts: 10,446
Received 1,835 Likes
on
1,145 Posts
What do your fuel trims look like? You could just simply be lean
#17
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (43)
They were pretty close, but have only had the truck a week and haven't put my wideband in it yet.
Heck, I cant even figure out how to make a change to the VE table since I can't find it in the tune, lol
I noticed yesterday it logged like 2 degrees KR pulling out of my driveway...no load, no quick throttle...weird, and if someone can share where the eff the VE table is, please do...
I havent had it on a lift yet to see if some wwutd rattle is happening
Heck, I cant even figure out how to make a change to the VE table since I can't find it in the tune, lol
I noticed yesterday it logged like 2 degrees KR pulling out of my driveway...no load, no quick throttle...weird, and if someone can share where the eff the VE table is, please do...
I havent had it on a lift yet to see if some wwutd rattle is happening
#19
7 Second Club
iTrader: (7)
Oh boy, Gen4 is very different than Gen3 so start reading. 87 octane will almost always make those gen trucks ping with their higher compression, etc. I almost always recommend people run 91 octane if they don't want it to head straight to the lower octane timing table with the knock learn factor.
#20
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (43)
Oh boy, Gen4 is very different than Gen3 so start reading. 87 octane will almost always make those gen trucks ping with their higher compression, etc. I almost always recommend people run 91 octane if they don't want it to head straight to the lower octane timing table with the knock learn factor.
I wish I would have known about this year truck not liking 87. It probably would have finished steering me towards a diesel, since I do tow fairly regularly.
I know a place called DSX tuning sells a flex fuel conversion kit. A friend of mine did it to his truck and runs a 50/50 mix of E85 and unleaded. Dont know if the headaches involved with that whole deal outweigh running 93 all the time, but I guess if I have ti run it, I have to run it. I'm at about a third of a tank now, so HOPE that straight 93 eliminates the KR without having to keep dicking around with a stock truck