Bigsky

Hey guys. I have an almost stock 1999 Z28 (aftermarket exhaust) I am thinking about selling. I recently had a woman pull out in front of me and smacked my front left. It needs a new front left fender and the left headlight. Other than that it just needs some paint. The car runs well with 110,000 miles. The body shop said they would fix it for $2,200. The car is perfectly driveable, safe a legal. I was hoping to get $4,500 for it. Is that a fare price, should I go higher or lower? I would keep it myself but dont want to drive it witht he damage and can not afford to fix it. I am in the Atlanta area.