Calling all experts and guru's
If problem persists inspect fuel pump. I had a pressure line leak in tank and it would cause the fuel pump to stress itself and best I can figure evaporate fuel as it over heated from all the extra work
Not sure how it could be that bad without tripping a MIL and/or having other driveability issues, unless you spend 95% of your time at WOT. Are you sure you don't have a fuel leak somewhere? Otherwise, MAF and/or front O2s need some attention - but the exhaust should smell so rich that you almost can't stand anywhere near it with the engine running.
To those saying BS - nah dude. This **** happens. My car has 30K BTW and is 100% stock except for pulley and lid - with a PAPER filter.
FWIW, I had no issues getting ~12mpg out of my '00 WS6 with an A4, 3.23s and a 3500 stall TC in city driving. That was not being easy on the throttle either. My stock LS1s have usually gotten 14-16mpg with all city driving, all A4 cars.
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
If the cats are clogged bad enough to cause this sort of MPG loss even with ultra-conservative driving, I don't see how the engine could run/feel 100% even at part throttle. But it would be a simple test; the OP could do a WOT run and if the engine pulls strong all the way to redline without any issues, and the cats aren't glowing red after the fact, then his problem likely lies elsewhere.
But plugged cars cost me 70+ hp on a dyno a couple years back now. You can definitely feel it
Maybe a small line leak under pressure, perhaps only during times of heavier fuel flow and maybe not even visible at idle. If none of the scanner data looks out of sorts, it might be worth inspecting the system for any signs of leaks.
The OP should set up a security camera on the car 24/7 and look out for bums siphoning gas out of the tank.












