oem water pump?
"Thank you for your email. The 251744 is the Original Equipment (OE) design with a steel impeller that Pontiac/GM used originally on the vehicle. The 252846 is the aftermarket replacement version with a cast iron impeller"
The pump with the steel impeller is a quality aftermarket unit, and you pay for it.
The pump with a cast iron impeller is a cheap aftermarket and probably has other compromises elsewhere to meet a price point. Take your chances...





