ls1 Tapping noise we cannot get to the bottom of. Please help
When we got the car in may we noticed it had unusually low oil pressure and there was a tapping sound. So the next day we had the oil changed which improved the low oil pressure a little. What we found next in the oil was even more unusual. A piece of what appeared to be a dowel pin or something of the sort. It was a pin the same exact size in diameter as the pin in the camshaft sprocket under the front cover. So, we pull EVERYTHING APART! We removed the heads, and the entire front cover etc. We found nothing unusual. No broken valve springs, no broken retainers, all the rockers and their needle bearings were in tact, and the pin for the camshaft sprocket was also there and in one piece. The camshaft had no unusual scoring on it, and appeared to be well. So, now we were thinking its lifter failure maybe. So we buy all brand new lifters and pushrods from gm, all new head gaskets and bolts. We put the entire motor back togethor, and it runs, and still has this tapping sound.
The tapping sound is still coming from the same place on the left side of the motor. It seems to match the rpms as you hit the gas. The oil pressure is still pretty low. When cold its around 22 psi, and when hot, it can fall as low as 5-8psi. It will NOT go above 40 psi under WOT. This motor does have about 90k miles on it. There was no physical damage to the pistons, and I do not know where else to look.
We noticed no shards of metal in the oil, and no silverish looking tint to the oil indicated bearings are going out, and the worst part is even though the motor taps... it runs wonderfully. Doesnt skip a beat, doesnt smoke, and it idles fine.
Im stumped. We were thinking to replace the oil pump, but still cant say if that oil pump would be the source of the tap.
Does it sound like valve train clatter or possibly piston slap ? Piston slap should change with the operating temperature of the engine.
Any way you can record a sound clip or a Video ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EWgekjQTNs0
there is some whirring noise also at under 2k rpms when its warm
Trending Topics
As for that noise, sounds to me like a Rod bearing has too much clearance !
It sounds too,,,, heavy or deep (metallic) for a valve train noise.
In fact sounds almost like my 01 TA when I bought it. It had a rod bearing that had gone south....
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
Also post up some pictures of the part you found laying inside. AND a video of you revving the engine from a idle quick up to like 3k. If its a bearing it will knock harder as it revs.
Suppose its in the trans and you put another engine in and it does the same thing............................
Dig into it and diagnose the noise.

