i was going to go w/ the s2, but the guys at spec said if you ever plan on putting some power in the car, if you spin that clutch once it will glaze over, he talked me into the s3, and i love it, once its broke it u can drive just as smooth as stock w/ some finess, there will be some slight chatter in 1st if u dont give it enough power, all in all the clutch is great and i wouldnt even mess with a stage 2 now, took 3-4 days for me to get used to, and i have never owned a manual before this so its for easy for a daily driver, my guess is you beat the s2 a little to hard, also, when you do the install, drill ot the restrictor on the hydro line, the clutch will feel like butter, friends get in my car and push the pedal in, and the just smile, it grabs on the last 3-4" of the pedal so u can shift quit fast