Car was hit while PARKED

so my car was hit on the front while it was parked at the mall, no witnesses, no cameras, anyway Geico is repairing it,
it needs a new front fender, a new front bumper cover, the headlight is broken too, but it's an aftermarket headlight.
question is, I know the nose is plastic, it looks like the fender is plastic/composite right?
when they get aftermarket fenders are they palstic too? does it make a difference?
how do they handle the aftermarket headlight situation?what are they actually responsible for? do they have to get oem parts or just the cheapest aftermarket pieces they can get?
sorry, lot of questions, very upset the car got hit,
thanks
I believe the only panels that are metal are the rear quarters...so the front would be composite and will probably replaced with an OEM fender. No idea on the headlight. That might depend on the shop you take it to.
the headlight will prolly be replacd with a stocker but you may be able to squeak the same aftermarket light out of them
Now we'll see how consistent it is though. I busted it up this past January (snow + ice + guardrail = no good) so it is getting replaced again. I got one from the same place so we'll see how consistent this particular aftermarket is.









