Open or closed Air cleaner?
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 28
Likes: 0
From: Union City, GA
Open or closed Air cleaner? Settle this argument between me and a co-worker:
Regarding my 85 Chevy Impala, I say that an open Air Cleaner allows more air into the carb. HE says that the air going into the carb with an open Air Cleaner installed is going to be hot air, since the open air cleaner basically takes in the air from the engine compartment and can't be routed there from anywhere else, by design. The stock Air cleaner works better in his opinion.
What do YOU say?
Regarding my 85 Chevy Impala, I say that an open Air Cleaner allows more air into the carb. HE says that the air going into the carb with an open Air Cleaner installed is going to be hot air, since the open air cleaner basically takes in the air from the engine compartment and can't be routed there from anywhere else, by design. The stock Air cleaner works better in his opinion.
What do YOU say?
7 Second Club
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 8,834
Likes: 1
From: Gainesville, Florida # of drag strips runs: ?!?!?
Closed is better if the air is being taken from outside the engine compartment (example of this would be a cold or ram air style system). Otherwise an open cleaner will work fine.
Just my $.02
Derek
Just my $.02
Derek
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 28
Likes: 0
From: Union City, GA
Originally Posted by Villain281H
Closed is better if the air is being taken from outside the engine compartment (example of this would be a cold or ram air style system). Otherwise an open cleaner will work fine.
Just my $.02
Derek
Just my $.02
Derek
When I do swap out the engine, I'm sticking with a carbed setup so if you say open Air cleaner is better, I'll stick with that, after getting one. I was looking at an Edlebrock 14 inch tonight, then read the small print that says- "not for sale or use on pollution controlled vehicles. I know I have to test for emmissions next year and since I don't have OBD II in this car, they're going to look for the emmissions equipment. I figure I can swap out the Open Air for the stock before testing. Your thoughts?
7 Second Club
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 8,834
Likes: 1
From: Gainesville, Florida # of drag strips runs: ?!?!?
You're correct in that a stock closed air cleaner with a snorkel is usually more restrictive than an open element style one. Chances are a 14 inch diameter should work fine, but try to use at least a 3" high element, and a K & N (or other washable filter than flows better than paper) for best performance. My Nova had a 14 x 4 air cleaner, and going to a ram air kit made for better performance at the track and on the street, but an open cleaner will still offer you better performance than the stock set-up. And the swapping out for emissions should work fine.
Derek
Derek
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 28
Likes: 0
From: Union City, GA
Thanks Derek,
I got the Edelbrock Pro-Flo 14" Open Air Cleaner. Will get the K&N filter in a day or two. It turns out that this open Air Cleaner has holes for both my PCV Valve and the tube coming from my Air Reaction Injection (AIR) system, so I should be fine for emissions with all my tubes hooked up.
I'll have more questions for you later. Thanks again.
I got the Edelbrock Pro-Flo 14" Open Air Cleaner. Will get the K&N filter in a day or two. It turns out that this open Air Cleaner has holes for both my PCV Valve and the tube coming from my Air Reaction Injection (AIR) system, so I should be fine for emissions with all my tubes hooked up.
I'll have more questions for you later. Thanks again.
