window regulator motor or both?
the two spots where its scratching your tint are felt-covered guides - when you take your door panel off to replace the motor, you'll see them. Most times the felt has come off or worn through. Any automotive glass shop should have rolls and rolls of the stuff. If not, the fuzzy side of velcro works just as well
finally, unless you do the window motor mod (search, its everywhere), really doesnt matter what brand of motor you use since they'll all fail eventually
or
the guides (mentioned above) have come loose or broken off
or both






