Bearing change and rear end gears are now toast
#1
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: GA/SC
Posts: 499
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Bearing change and rear end gears are now toast
Ok...so here is what happened. A friend of mine and myself changed the carrier and pinion bearings Thursday night after work. He is an ASE certified Master Tech (15 years all on Fords). I have 4 ASE's but I don't know **** about a rear end other than every time I touch one it breaks. This makes #4. This one worked perfectly and was so quiet after the bearing change until the pinion seal blew today. That's approximately 20 miles since the bearing change.
This is what I think happened and tell me if I'm wrong because I really need to know why a $5 seal is costing me more money
I installed the pinion seal with a seal installer. He installed the bearings on the pinion and set the pre-load. After he tightened the pinion nut you couldn't turn the pinion at all. So he loosened the nut and pulled the yoke off and the pinion back out. The rear race wasn't seated properly, although by sight, you couldn't tell. So the pinion was put back in and retorqued. I noticed the seal wasn't seated and he popped that side of the seal with a small hammer to seat it back in. This time you could turn the pinion but I think the damage was done before. When you put the pinion nut on and tighten it you in turn use the crush sleeve up.
By removing the pinion and not using another crush sleeve or shimming the difference could that cause the pinion seal to fail?
In all fairness the rearend was quieter than it has ever been. Bottom line is now I need a gear change. Under acceleration there is 0 noise but as soon as decel starts it whines bad.
This is what I think happened and tell me if I'm wrong because I really need to know why a $5 seal is costing me more money
I installed the pinion seal with a seal installer. He installed the bearings on the pinion and set the pre-load. After he tightened the pinion nut you couldn't turn the pinion at all. So he loosened the nut and pulled the yoke off and the pinion back out. The rear race wasn't seated properly, although by sight, you couldn't tell. So the pinion was put back in and retorqued. I noticed the seal wasn't seated and he popped that side of the seal with a small hammer to seat it back in. This time you could turn the pinion but I think the damage was done before. When you put the pinion nut on and tighten it you in turn use the crush sleeve up.
By removing the pinion and not using another crush sleeve or shimming the difference could that cause the pinion seal to fail?
In all fairness the rearend was quieter than it has ever been. Bottom line is now I need a gear change. Under acceleration there is 0 noise but as soon as decel starts it whines bad.
#2
TECH Addict
iTrader: (11)
Its not the seal causing the problems, sounds like the gear tooth contact pattern isnt set up right. Did you use contact paste & check the gear pattern? The seal might have got damaged from not installing it straight enough & got bent slightly. How did you torque the pinion nut? A new pinion nut & crush sleeve always, unless youre only changing the pinion seal. Proper pinion nut torque should take 25-35 in. lbs to turn, used bearings only 15-20 in. lbs. turning force. An impact gun works best tightening a lil at a time to achieve proper pinion nut torque & in. lb. torque wrench to check the turning force. From the sounds of it this wasnt done? Oh yeah & backlash with a dial indicator.
#3
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: GA/SC
Posts: 499
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Its not the seal causing the problems, sounds like the gear tooth contact pattern isnt set up right. Did you use contact paste & check the gear pattern? The seal might have got damaged from not installing it straight enough & got bent slightly. How did you torque the pinion nut? A new pinion nut & crush sleeve always, unless youre only changing the pinion seal. Proper pinion nut torque should take 25-35 in. lbs to turn, used bearings only 15-20 in. lbs. turning force. An impact gun works best tightening a lil at a time to achieve proper pinion nut torque & in. lb. torque wrench to check the turning force. From the sounds of it this wasnt done? Oh yeah & backlash with a dial indicator.
I would rather work on a Yugo as I would a rear end.
#4
11 Second Club
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: SILSBEE TX
Posts: 1,782
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
" I " think here in ("The rear race wasn't seated properly, although by sight, you ...") is your problem, " I" think you should have used new sleeve, re shim and retork the pinoin AND reset the pattern and back lash
Johnny
Johnny
#5
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: GA/SC
Posts: 499
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Honestly I don't have the money for a 9" or 12 bolt either so I'll have to put gears in this until I can save up for a complete rear end. POS GM rear ends.
#6
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (96)
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Turnin' Wrenches Infractions: 005
Posts: 24,241
Likes: 0
Received 81 Likes
on
72 Posts
What you're saying makes perfect sense. Sounds like he damaged the seal. Once the seal is in-place you cannot remove the pinion gear. The reason why is because the outer/smaller bearing is very tight on the pinion shaft. Hitting the gear back into the housing is fine, because the bearing hits the race. But re-inserting the pinion in causes that bearing to bump the inside of the seal which will tear it up. You must pull the seal if the pinion needs to come back out. Second, you don't setup crush sleeves with impact guns. Way too easy to miss your mark.
#7
Never torque a pinion nut with a impact wrench. If you crush the crush sleeve you replace it. When you remove a pinion nut, even if it's only been on 10 seconds you throw it away. If he did what you said and used an impact to tighten the pinion nut to the point you couldn't turn the pinion he most likely damaged one of the pinion bearings. Take it apart BEFORE you drive it and find out what happened.
Al 95 Z28
Al 95 Z28
Trending Topics
#8
TECH Addict
iTrader: (11)
Oh yea? Tell us why & what you would use, & what you use to hold the pinion in place? I have used an impact gun plenty of times gradually tightening the pinion nut in small increments until it has the proper amount of preload, usually 25-35 in. lb turning force.
I agree.
Yes, if you cant turn it by hand its def. overtightened, & most likely the whole reason why it makes noise. About just changing the bearings, yes usually you can get away with just doing that & not making any adjustments using the original gears, shims & carrier. Having the correct pinion bearing preload is very important & a good idea to check the tooth contact pattern in case it needs adjusted.
If you crush the crush sleeve you replace it. When you remove a pinion nut, even if it's only been on 10 seconds you throw it away.
If he did what you said and used an impact to tighten the pinion nut to the point you couldn't turn the pinion he most likely damaged one of the pinion bearings.
#9
I use a long 3/4" ratchet reduced to half inch socket. Also made a bar with two pins on it to catch the u joint strap holes. Then one can rest on the ground or whatever and you can have leverage to tighten the nut. Not to hard at all really...if you dont have the ability to figure that out, I wouldn't be messin with the rear to begin with. That being said, I have used an impact once or twice...can be very touchy and not advised for a rookie. Chuck
#10
Al 95 Z28
#14
11 Second Club
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: GA/SC
Posts: 499
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Got new gears and bearings for the rear end. All ready to go again. This time I had someone who knows a lot about rear ends help me. Now I actually know why all the adjustments are made not just THAT they are made. It's quiet now, no clunking or popping and feels "tight". I can say the crush sleeve was never crushed after doing it this time. lol