BW s475, 476, 480 users come in :)
I wish they would all go back to cast and cut the price of these turbos in half.
I wish they would all go back to cast and cut the price of these turbos in half.
Last edited by Forcefed86; Jan 7, 2014 at 06:30 PM.
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
I wish they would all go back to cast and cut the price of these turbos in half.
On race applications your not going to stress a cast blades. Billet was introduced for for longevity in the big rigs. 300k+ at a constant 20+psi on a diesel would eventually stress the blades. Light duty drag/street applications don't have this issue. I've seen cast wheels withstand 120psi+ without an issue on compound tractor setups. Durability IS NOT an issue with drag racing.
Where are you getting your information from? I'm not saying your wrong, but I've yet to see anyone weigh the compressors your talking about VS a cast replica of the same wheel. The billet unit would have to be considerably "thinner" to be lighter than a cast unit. None of the billet wheels I've personally had my hands on ran a blade any thinner than the cast units. I've yet to see this. Also you can't compare wheels with totally different profiles and claim one out performs the other because of the material it's made of. It doesn't matter if the company sells a billet s475 and a cast s475. Those are just names, the wheels are totally different.
On race applications your not going to stress a cast blades. Billet was introduced for for longevity in the big rigs. 300k+ at a constant 20+psi on a diesel would eventually stress the blades. Light duty drag/street applications don't have this issue. I've seen cast wheels withstand 120psi+ without an issue on compound tractor setups. Durability IS NOT an issue with drag racing.
Where are you getting your information from? I'm not saying your wrong, but I've yet to see anyone weigh the compressors your talking about VS a cast replica of the same wheel. The billet unit would have to be considerably "thinner" to be lighter than a cast unit. None of the billet wheels I've personally had my hands on ran a blade any thinner than the cast units. I've yet to see this. Also you can't compare wheels with totally different profiles and claim one out performs the other because of the material it's made of. It doesn't matter if the company sells a billet s475 and a cast s475. Those are just names, the wheels are totally different.
Impressive. Who's billet 76 are you running (there are so many out there). Also- the 92mm turbine is the "new tech" BW stuff correct? Last question-what AR t4?
Thanks a ton!
Unless you tested an exact cast copy of the billet wheel you claim is "faster spooling" and tested them back to back you aren't saying anything useful. Of course the "billet" wheels will run better. They are a better (and usually larger) profile wheel.
What I'm saying is the current wheels aren't so complex that you need a 5 axis CNC machine and a chunk of billet to make them. Take that same "super billet" wheel and make a casting of it. Then mass produce it for half the cost. It could easily be done. It isn't because there is a larger profit margin for the shiny wheel turbos.
Here is a great article on it...
http://www.enginebasics.com/Advanced...%20Wheels.html
Straight from BW....
Now ask your self how many times you've seen a race car's CW split in half... I have never, and I've seen a LOT of failures. Even the billet aluminum isn't enough in some newer applications and we've turned to titanium which in its FMW form, is nearly indestructible. I've heard all the propaganda surrounding the billet wheel myths: higher boost capability, higher flow, higher efficiency, etc... The higher boost capability is the only one which is true, but not because it's machined and not true for racing use. OE diesel applications using FMW compressors can run higher boost pressures more reliably simply because they are less susceptible to fatigue as they're cycled from higher speeds (required to make more pressure) to low speeds.
Last edited by Forcefed86; Jan 7, 2014 at 10:18 PM.
On race applications your not going to stress a cast blades. Billet was introduced for for longevity in the big rigs. 300k+ at a constant 20+psi on a diesel would eventually stress the blades. Light duty drag/street applications don't have this issue. I've seen cast wheels withstand 120psi+ without an issue on compound tractor setups. Durability IS NOT an issue with drag racing.
Where are you getting your information from? I'm not saying your wrong, but I've yet to see anyone weigh the compressors your talking about VS a cast replica of the same wheel. The billet unit would have to be considerably "thinner" to be lighter than a cast unit. None of the billet wheels I've personally had my hands on ran a blade any thinner than the cast units. I've yet to see this. Also you can't compare wheels with totally different profiles and claim one out performs the other because of the material it's made of. It doesn't matter if the company sells a billet s475 and a cast s475. Those are just names, the wheels are totally different.
You are correct that a billet wheel vs a cast wheel for the exact same dimension will perform the same-but you (and Dmax to a point) are bit off everywhere else.
You have to take the BW quote with a grain of salt-after all, he is trying to sell turbos! The true reason of why there is so many billet options on the market is low production number turbos (its cheaper to cut billet than create a casting for low production) and the fact that billet is significantly stronger means you can get away smaller shank and blades-which was mentioned. PTE's billet wheels for example are MUCH thinner-and allow for more effective area. The PTE6266's inducer for example is only 1mm lager than a 35r, but because the Shank is almost 2mm thinner (and the turbine blades are also significantly thinner) you get much more effective area-and in turn a turbo that can flow 150 more CFM with the same or better spool characteristics. Not because it is lighter-its larger-heavier-but simply flows more air than the 35r at any given shaft speed.
The notion that it was for OE use is silly. A good friend is the lead tech at the local Truck (Semi) shop. He sees about 20-25 new rigs in the shop for service a week. I have asked him to take note of the turbos on the tucks for the past month. You know how many have come through with OE billet turbos? Zero. Obviously this is third hand info-but I also asked my local freightliner dealer-and he told me none of the trucks on his lot came with a billet turbo stock-but you can upgrade for a price

Also-saying they don't blow up in drag racing or at @ XXX psi is also silly-you know better than anyone-pressure vs flow. If you go to any event where turbo pro mod cars are running, you are all but guaranteed to see a turbo grenade due to the wild shaft speeds they run. Hell I think atomicfusion even narked a few turbos-one almost causing his car to burn down. He's not running anything near 120psi.
You have to take the BW quote with a grain of salt-after all, he is trying to sell turbos! The true reason of why there is so many billet options on the market is low production number turbos (its cheaper to cut billet than create a casting for low production) and the fact that billet is significantly stronger means you can get away smaller shank and blades-which was mentioned. PTE's billet wheels for example are MUCH thinner-and allow for more effective area. The PTE6266's inducer for example is only 1mm lager than a 35r, but because the Shank is almost 2mm thinner (and the turbine blades are also significantly thinner) you get much more effective area-and in turn a turbo that can flow 150 more CFM with the same or better spool characteristics. Not because it is lighter-its larger-heavier-but simply flows more air than the 35r at any given shaft speed.
The notion that it was for OE use is silly. A good friend is the lead tech at the local Truck (Semi) shop. He sees about 20-25 new rigs in the shop for service a week. I have asked him to take note of the turbos on the tucks for the past month. You know how many have come through with OE billet turbos? Zero. Obviously this is third hand info-but I also asked my local freightliner dealer-and he told me none of the trucks on his lot came with a billet turbo stock-but you can upgrade for a price

Also-saying they don't blow up in drag racing or at @ XXX psi is also silly-you know better than anyone-pressure vs flow. If you go to any event where turbo pro mod cars are running, you are all but guaranteed to see a turbo grenade due to the wild shaft speeds they run. Hell I think atomicfusion even narked a few turbos-one almost causing his car to burn down. He's not running anything near 120psi.
I'll give you the easier to manufacturer for low production volumes... but that has NOTHING to do with performance VS a cast wheel. Read the link above...
Last edited by Forcefed86; Jan 7, 2014 at 10:14 PM.
You have to take the BW quote with a grain of salt-after all, he is trying to sell turbos! The true reason of why there is so many billet options on the market is low production number turbos (its cheaper to cut billet than create a casting for low production) and the fact that billet is significantly stronger means you can get away smaller shank and blades-which was mentioned. PTE's billet wheels for example are MUCH thinner-and allow for more effective area. The PTE6266's inducer for example is only 1mm lager than a 35r, but because the Shank is almost 2mm thinner (and the turbine blades are also significantly thinner) you get much more effective area-and in turn a turbo that can flow 150 more CFM with the same or better spool characteristics. Not because it is lighter-its larger-heavier-but simply flows more air than the 35r at any given shaft speed.
The notion that it was for OE use is silly. A good friend is the lead tech at the local Truck (Semi) shop. He sees about 20-25 new rigs in the shop for service a week. I have asked him to take note of the turbos on the tucks for the past month. You know how many have come through with OE billet turbos? Zero. Obviously this is third hand info-but I also asked my local freightliner dealer-and he told me none of the trucks on his lot came with a billet turbo stock-but you can upgrade for a price

Also-saying they don't blow up in drag racing or at @ XXX psi is also silly-you know better than anyone-pressure vs flow. If you go to any event where turbo pro mod cars are running, you are all but guaranteed to see a turbo grenade due to the wild shaft speeds they run. Hell I think atomicfusion even narked a few turbos-one almost causing his car to burn down. He's not running anything near 120psi.









