Service engine light code... Cat gone bad?
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
From: Aberdump, MD
UPDATE: Service engine light code... Cat gone bad? 2001 WS6 with 52,000 miles. About two years ago Service engine light comes on. I took it to Auto Zone to have it scaned, it said catalyst/ plugs are defective (or something along those lines). Car is running fine. I cleared the code. Code didn't return.
Two years later I get the same code. Car runs fine. The manager at Auto Zone recomended Seafoam (I didn't know what it was at the time, I just read the sticky). So I ran a can of Seafoam and filled up the tank. Cleared the code. About a week later I now have a code. I'm assuming it is the same.
Could it be possible the cats are going bad at only 52,000 miles?! Owner's manual says to change the plugs @ 100,000 miles?!
Two years later I get the same code. Car runs fine. The manager at Auto Zone recomended Seafoam (I didn't know what it was at the time, I just read the sticky). So I ran a can of Seafoam and filled up the tank. Cleared the code. About a week later I now have a code. I'm assuming it is the same.
Could it be possible the cats are going bad at only 52,000 miles?! Owner's manual says to change the plugs @ 100,000 miles?!
Last edited by m-port-h8r; Sep 11, 2006 at 07:11 AM.
no expert here, but i wouldnt wait to change the plugs that long. ive got 55k on mine and ill be changing them in a couple of hrs. and i believe theres some type of warranty on the stock cats for up to 80k, so if yours are bad you can get themchanged at the dealer.
I would suspect a bad rear O2 sensor before a bad cat. Your cat typically will show other symptoms like lack of power, rattling, smelling, etc. I'm pretty sure most cats are warrented 10 years and 80K at least.
I didn't replace my plugs until 112,000 miles and they weren't even that bad then.
I didn't replace my plugs until 112,000 miles and they weren't even that bad then.
Trending Topics
LS1 Tech Stories
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
Topdon ONE vs. Artidiag 800 BT2: Which is the Diagnostic Tablet For You?
Pouria Savadkouei
Gas Monkey Built a 6-Wheel Ferrari Testarossa With a Corvette LT4 Engine
Verdad Gallardo
7 Most Reliable High-Performance Engines GM Has Ever Built
Verdad Gallardo
Amazing '71 Camaro Restomod Is Modern Muscle Car Under the Skin
Verdad Gallardo
6 Common C5 Corvette Failures and What's Involved In Repairing Them
Pouria Savadkouei
Retro Modern Bandit Pontiac Trans AM Comes With Burt Reynolds' Autograph
Verdad Gallardo
Top 10 Greatest Cadillac V Series Performance Models Ever, Ranked
Pouria Savadkouei
Top 10 Most Powerful Chevy Trucks Ever Made!
Hennessey's New Supercharged Silverado ZR2 Has 700 HP
Verdad Gallardo Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
From: Aberdump, MD
I'll check again and post back. Thanks gentlemen 
Edit:
You were correct!!
PO420
cataylst below threshold
bank 1
Even the Auto Zone dude said to take it to the dealer and by law they have to replace the catalytic converter if under 80,000 miles
Thanks again.
Well, if they don't replace it for free, it'll be an excuse to go with LTH and high flow cats
Edit:
You were correct!!
PO420
cataylst below threshold
bank 1
Even the Auto Zone dude said to take it to the dealer and by law they have to replace the catalytic converter if under 80,000 miles
Thanks again.Well, if they don't replace it for free, it'll be an excuse to go with LTH and high flow cats
Last edited by m-port-h8r; Aug 28, 2006 at 07:05 PM.
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
From: Aberdump, MD
One more note.
I wouldn't think this would have anything to do with it but figured I'd ask.
I just put an SLP lid on this summer. There shouldn't be any reason that would effect anything, correct. I'm just trying to get my story straight before I take it to the dealer and they might say somthin'.
"AHH you got one of those new fangled after market deals, well that voids any warranty indefinately"
I wouldn't think this would have anything to do with it but figured I'd ask.
I just put an SLP lid on this summer. There shouldn't be any reason that would effect anything, correct. I'm just trying to get my story straight before I take it to the dealer and they might say somthin'.
"AHH you got one of those new fangled after market deals, well that voids any warranty indefinately"
TECH Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 5,399
Likes: 3
From: Jacksonville, FL
Na...but put a stock filter in just in case (if you have an oiled one)...leave the code stored. Most dealers will tell you might be an 02, diagnostic fee required, etc. but shouldn't charge anything once they diagnose a bad cat.
Originally Posted by m-port-h8r
I'll check again and post back. Thanks gentlemen
Edit:
You were correct!!
PO420
cataylst below threshold
bank 1
Even the Auto Zone dude said to take it to the dealer and by law they have to replace the catalytic converter if under 80,000 miles
Thanks again.
Well, if they don't replace it for free, it'll be an excuse to go with LTH and high flow cats
Edit:
You were correct!!
PO420
cataylst below threshold
bank 1
Even the Auto Zone dude said to take it to the dealer and by law they have to replace the catalytic converter if under 80,000 miles
Thanks again.Well, if they don't replace it for free, it'll be an excuse to go with LTH and high flow cats
I've had both of my cats replaced under the Federal Emissions Warranty (8yrs/80K miles). The last one was replaced about two months ago with 60K miles on my WS6. Oh... I have a Volant CAI on my car, so your lid shouldn't cause any problems. My stealership didn't give me any problems. I told them what code I was getting, what I did to diagnose the problem, and I told them what to do. After they picked their collective jaws up off the floor, they swapped out my cats (didn't even hook up their TechII to scan for codes) and said thanks.
Good luck,
Marc
I had a similiar problem about a month ago, but the check engine light turned off after two weeks. I had the code scanned at autozone, and it was the driver's side. Should I be worried or should I take it to the dealership to have the cat replaced?
Originally Posted by kny3twalker
I had a similiar problem about a month ago, but the check engine light turned off after two weeks. I had the code scanned at autozone, and it was the driver's side. Should I be worried or should I take it to the dealership to have the cat replaced?
I'd suggest taking the car in and getting the cat replaced. Hell... it's free! I'd do it on principle alone. I just love getting the stealership to give something up for free. Particularly when you know that parts and labor would come to well over $400 if you had to pay for it.
Marc
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
From: Aberdump, MD
Well I took the car to the dealership and they replaced the cat at no charge what so-ever.
I drove about two blocks away and the car seemed to run a little different. Now it smells like rotten eggs
New cat smell?
Later that day I got another code: P0151
Passenger side o2 sensor
I drove about two blocks away and the car seemed to run a little different. Now it smells like rotten eggs
New cat smell?Later that day I got another code: P0151
Passenger side o2 sensor
Last edited by m-port-h8r; Sep 11, 2006 at 07:28 AM.
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
From: Aberdump, MD
I started to wonder, why would something happen on the passenger side now?
I jacked up the car to see if maybe they left an o2 connection loose.
The passenger side cat had been replaced, not the driver side
I thought that bank 1 was drivers side:1,3,7 ?
So I pulled both before cat o2 sensors and compared the two.
The drivers side was white and the passengers side was black sooty. I sprayed them with carb cleaner just to see if they would clean up. I thought about swaping the sides but one pig tail was shorter and I didn't think it would reach.
I took the car back to the Zone and now I have: P0151, P1153, P0155, P0174.
I'm thinking about changing the fuel filter and both front o2 sensors and hopefully that will fix it
I jacked up the car to see if maybe they left an o2 connection loose.
The passenger side cat had been replaced, not the driver side
I thought that bank 1 was drivers side:1,3,7 ?
So I pulled both before cat o2 sensors and compared the two.
The drivers side was white and the passengers side was black sooty. I sprayed them with carb cleaner just to see if they would clean up. I thought about swaping the sides but one pig tail was shorter and I didn't think it would reach.
I took the car back to the Zone and now I have: P0151, P1153, P0155, P0174.
I'm thinking about changing the fuel filter and both front o2 sensors and hopefully that will fix it
The stealership wants to charge me 80 dollars for check out. (Vista Ridge)
And now apparently GM will only allow my car to be serviced at pontiac stealerships for warranty work???
While my car was under factory and extended warranty, it was serviced at Pontiac, Chevy and Cadillac stealerships.
And the thing is all the pontiac stealerships in Dallas/Forth Worth suck!
Ewing is always trying to charge way too much (ex. double the list price for parts, etc...). Also they do work you did not ask to be done and charge you for it. Any type of warranty work was always an arguement, where they have been known to boldly accuse me of causing the problem.
**** Ewing!
Vista Ridge is full idiots that mis-diagnose problems. They are willing to give a good quote, but then try to charge you more after the fact. Furthermore this stealership just does shitting work, and their paint shop is abesolutely horrible (ex. really bad orange pell, etc..)
Screw them too!
There is another one in Irving, but they never did anything to impress me either.
My engine was on for about a week or so about a month ago and has yet to come back on. Should I still consider taking it to the stealership when they want to charge me 80 dollars if they cat does not throw the code?
And now apparently GM will only allow my car to be serviced at pontiac stealerships for warranty work???
While my car was under factory and extended warranty, it was serviced at Pontiac, Chevy and Cadillac stealerships.
And the thing is all the pontiac stealerships in Dallas/Forth Worth suck!
Ewing is always trying to charge way too much (ex. double the list price for parts, etc...). Also they do work you did not ask to be done and charge you for it. Any type of warranty work was always an arguement, where they have been known to boldly accuse me of causing the problem.
**** Ewing!
Vista Ridge is full idiots that mis-diagnose problems. They are willing to give a good quote, but then try to charge you more after the fact. Furthermore this stealership just does shitting work, and their paint shop is abesolutely horrible (ex. really bad orange pell, etc..)
Screw them too!
There is another one in Irving, but they never did anything to impress me either.
My engine was on for about a week or so about a month ago and has yet to come back on. Should I still consider taking it to the stealership when they want to charge me 80 dollars if they cat does not throw the code?
TECH Addict
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 2,498
Likes: 3
From: The dirty taint of the country. ...Los Angeles
K,...now im pissed!! I just called the dealership and I'm no longer covered by the warranty! I JUST CROSSED THE 100k MILE MARK. I didn't even know about the Fedral Emissions Warranty til today! I feel like such a dumb-**** for not knowing about this earlier. 
