No warning, how can this be?
Enjoy knowing your starter aint gonna break off or block crack rod break etc. Plus the fact if it doesn't completely break it the 1st time it happens it weakens and can do hidden damage that bites yer azz later.
I think you should do a leak-down AND compression test. Inspect the rocker arms, valve springs and push rods thoroughly. Any excessive wear to the rocker arm to valve tip? Any on the valve tip?
How many miles on this car? Any modifications?
157K on odom. No, blemishes on the valve cover, passenger side.
I have a video of it, but not sure how to actually post it. Hold on, I'll try to send a link.
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
From your first post, you had the problem (this noise) changed the starter (it was cracked) and then it was OK-you drove the car a few days.
Then the noise came back.
It sounds to me that this noise comes and goes randomly.
Auto or stick car? Auto car, it may have a cracked flex plate.
Curious, where in LI were you from?
I am originally from Holbrook, St. James area. I graduated from Sachem. My husband is from Kings Park. ;-)
The car, Firehawk is an automatic.
Yes, The very first time it made that clunking noise we brought it to the shop, the mechanics said the starter had broke away off the bolts.
New starter was replaced and the flex plate and flywheel are in great shape. I saw portions of the flywheel, and no teeth were broken.
Brought the car home, ran fabulous, then it sat for two days, then noise came back.
Converter bolt? check to see if they are all there.
I am originally from Holbrook, St. James area. I graduated from Sachem. My husband is from Kings Park. ;-)
The car, Firehawk is an automatic.
Yes, The very first time it made that clunking noise we brought it to the shop, the mechanics said the starter had broke away off the bolts.
New starter was replaced and the flex plate and flywheel are in great shape. I saw portions of the flywheel, and no teeth were broken.
Brought the car home, ran fabulous, then it sat for two days, then noise came back.
I thought about the flex plate because sometimes damage to it is at the hub making it hard to see unless it's removed. The sound it makes could come and go as the torque converter moves in & out of the pump.
Did you try the thing with holding the valve cover in place by hand?
The fact that the sound comes & goes is what has me stumped. If it was an engine bearing, the sound would never go away.

My husband was born in Queens NY.
He just bought a compression tester, so I think he will do that too once it warms up a bit.
Thanks so much for all your inputs.
Let me ask you something,
if it was a bad valve or piston or ring or something, wouldn't it have still made the sound without the valve cover on?
Frequently when a repair is made it temporarily moves or changes something affecting the problem then after a while it comes back.
I agree with Paul Bell that you should check the flew plate. If it was turned by hand to inspect it that could have taken it out of contact with what ever it was hitting the with driving it moved back.
One last suggestion, try to find a good reputable shop that knows LS engines. A shop might be great on mant things but if they don't know LS engines they can get lost.
Good luck, lets us know what you discover.








