Valve stem tip gouged?
What you just did, was to put giant dig marks in the valve guides.
That looks like something bad happened during a previous install.
Given that stock valves are kinda crappy for the most part anyway, best to just replace them all. The Manley "street flo" ones are a VAST improvement over stock, for not too much $$$. Much harder material, better made altogether, noticeable improvement in engine output.








