OLD XE vs XE-R question....
Thread Starter
TECH Fanatic
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,946
Likes: 1
OLD XE vs XE-R question.... Putting cam in friends C5, engine noise is a concern…
If all other variables are the same (PR length, spring-type, head-milling, etc…) XE lobes make less valve-train-noise than XE-R, right??? Say something like 220/224 XE vs. 220/224 XE-R…
I have never used a XE based cam so I have no experience in that area...
If all other variables are the same (PR length, spring-type, head-milling, etc…) XE lobes make less valve-train-noise than XE-R, right??? Say something like 220/224 XE vs. 220/224 XE-R…
I have never used a XE based cam so I have no experience in that area...
formerly silverbrick (changed 02/17/2013)
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 4,523
Likes: 0
From: Pasadena, Tx
XER lobes, im sure you know, include faster ramping rate. it will pop up the rocker and snap it down. IMO if you had the exact pushrod length necessary, decent springs and lifters that are in good shape the noise level should be about the same but as with any aftermarket valvetrain noise will be there...
i have the XER 224/224 and it can sound like a sewing maching at certain RPM's basically with my exhaust you hear the car and vavles closing and opening, but cats or any muffler would help that out a bunch
Staging Lane
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
XE-R lobes do have a very fast ramp and have more lift. They are an aggressive cam
XtremRPM cams
Comp has two types, XtremRPM, and XtremRPM high lift
Now Comp has LSK lobes and are more aggressive than XE-R
Since XtremRPM cams high lift are not really high lift at all when compared with XE-R
and LSK they can use 26915 springs but I would still use the 26918 springs
All other variables are the same (PR length, head milling, spring type etc.)
I would think that they make less noise
XtremRPM cams
Comp has two types, XtremRPM, and XtremRPM high lift
Now Comp has LSK lobes and are more aggressive than XE-R
Since XtremRPM cams high lift are not really high lift at all when compared with XE-R
and LSK they can use 26915 springs but I would still use the 26918 springs
All other variables are the same (PR length, head milling, spring type etc.)
I would think that they make less noise
Thread Starter
TECH Fanatic
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,946
Likes: 1
Originally Posted by Black Z28 M6
XE-R lobes do have a very fast ramp and have more lift. They are an aggressive cam
XtremRPM cams
Comp has two types, XtremRPM, and XtremRPM high lift
Now Comp has LSK lobes and are more aggressive than XE-R
Since XtremRPM cams high lift are not really high lift at all when compared with XE-R
and LSK they can use 26915 springs but I would still use the 26918 springs
All other variables are the same (PR length, head milling, spring type etc.)
I would think that they make less noise
XtremRPM cams
Comp has two types, XtremRPM, and XtremRPM high lift
Now Comp has LSK lobes and are more aggressive than XE-R
Since XtremRPM cams high lift are not really high lift at all when compared with XE-R
and LSK they can use 26915 springs but I would still use the 26918 springs
All other variables are the same (PR length, head milling, spring type etc.)
I would think that they make less noise
noise and reliability were the two main reasons i went with the xe-lobe..The exhaust valve is the one that is making the noise so if you went with a xe-r lobe on the intake valve and a xe lobe on the exhaust it would help..My setup is pretty quite and i am pleased with the power output for the older xe lobe design..
Trending Topics
Thread Starter
TECH Fanatic
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,946
Likes: 1
Originally Posted by redtail2426
..My setup is pretty quite and i am pleased with the power output for the older xe lobe design..
When you say pretty quiet... do you have any valve-train noise???
LS1 Tech Stories
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
6 Gifts Neither Your Dad Nor Grad Will Shove Into the 'Trinket Drawer'
Brett Foote
Topdon ONE vs. Artidiag 800 BT2: Which is the Diagnostic Tablet For You?
Pouria Savadkouei
Gas Monkey Built a 6-Wheel Ferrari Testarossa With a Corvette LT4 Engine
Verdad Gallardo
7 Most Reliable High-Performance Engines GM Has Ever Built
Verdad Gallardo
Amazing '71 Camaro Restomod Is Modern Muscle Car Under the Skin
Verdad Gallardo
6 Common C5 Corvette Failures and What's Involved In Repairing Them
Pouria Savadkouei
Retro Modern Bandit Pontiac Trans AM Comes With Burt Reynolds' Autograph
Verdad Gallardo
Top 10 Greatest Cadillac V Series Performance Models Ever, Ranked
Pouria Savadkouei
Top 10 Most Powerful Chevy Trucks Ever Made!
um i would say yes i do.. When my car was bone stock it was not that quite either though...Its just a very little bit where you cant hear it when the hood is closed or from inside the car.My valvetrain was much louder when i had the gt2-3 cam and comp 918's..The gt2-3 is supposed to have mild lobes to.Both of my setups have the correct length pushrods to maintain the stock preload of .080 to .100" .The only time you hear the valvetrain is when the hood is open and you are stading over the engine.I thought it was going to be loud because of the dual springs(patriot gold dual) but i was pleasantly suprised.
Staging Lane
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
If AFR or CompCams would come up with a REV-Kit all these problems would really matter.
Cause as long as you dont float valves who cares about valvetrain noise
Your making alot of power
The more aggressive cam you get (The big ***** cams) are going to have valvetrain noise
My Camaro makes noise and my 71 chevy short bed also makes noise but the truck has a XE solid roller (350 I gen) AFR 195 heads AFR REV-Kit and it make 429rwhp on a 770cfm Holley (Caborator engine)
I wish some come out with a REV-Kit for LS1/LS2 we all were make more power
Cause as long as you dont float valves who cares about valvetrain noise
Your making alot of power
The more aggressive cam you get (The big ***** cams) are going to have valvetrain noise
My Camaro makes noise and my 71 chevy short bed also makes noise but the truck has a XE solid roller (350 I gen) AFR 195 heads AFR REV-Kit and it make 429rwhp on a 770cfm Holley (Caborator engine)
I wish some come out with a REV-Kit for LS1/LS2 we all were make more power
Staging Lane
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
If AFR or CompCams would come up with a REV-Kit all these problems wouldn't really matter.
Cause as long as you dont float valves who cares about valvetrain noise
Your making alot of power
The more aggressive cam you get (The big ***** cams) are going to have valvetrain noise
My Camaro makes noise and my 71 chevy short bed also makes noise but the truck has a XE solid roller (350 I gen) AFR 195 heads AFR REV-Kit and it make 429rwhp on a 770cfm Holley (Caborator engine)
I wish some come out with a REV-Kit for LS1/LS2 we all were make more power
Cause as long as you dont float valves who cares about valvetrain noise
Your making alot of power
The more aggressive cam you get (The big ***** cams) are going to have valvetrain noise
My Camaro makes noise and my 71 chevy short bed also makes noise but the truck has a XE solid roller (350 I gen) AFR 195 heads AFR REV-Kit and it make 429rwhp on a 770cfm Holley (Caborator engine)
I wish some come out with a REV-Kit for LS1/LS2 we all were make more power
which means fickled...
TECH Resident
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 855
Likes: 0
From: AUSTIN TX
If he is that concerned about noise he should invest in a set of adjustable rocker arms, or better yet, a set of adjustable rocker shafts. I still think most of the valvetrain noise associated with cam swaps is due to the fact that we are trying to set preload with different length pushrods and can only get it close. Perhaps I am just old school, but you should use different length pushrods to get your geometry correct, then an adjustable valvetrain to set your lash/preload.
TECH Resident
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 855
Likes: 0
From: AUSTIN TX
Originally Posted by Black Z28 M6
If AFR or CompCams would come up with a REV-Kit all these problems wouldn't really matter.
Cause as long as you dont float valves who cares about valvetrain noise
Your making alot of power
The more aggressive cam you get (The big ***** cams) are going to have valvetrain noise
My Camaro makes noise and my 71 chevy short bed also makes noise but the truck has a XE solid roller (350 I gen) AFR 195 heads AFR REV-Kit and it make 429rwhp on a 770cfm Holley (Caborator engine)
I wish some come out with a REV-Kit for LS1/LS2 we all were make more power
Cause as long as you dont float valves who cares about valvetrain noise
Your making alot of power
The more aggressive cam you get (The big ***** cams) are going to have valvetrain noise
My Camaro makes noise and my 71 chevy short bed also makes noise but the truck has a XE solid roller (350 I gen) AFR 195 heads AFR REV-Kit and it make 429rwhp on a 770cfm Holley (Caborator engine)
I wish some come out with a REV-Kit for LS1/LS2 we all were make more power
TECH Resident
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 855
Likes: 0
From: AUSTIN TX
Originally Posted by Black Z28 M6
Yeah I remember that. When I auctualy got the ***** to do a head and cam swap, they stop selling that REV-Kit.
Hey you got some good number on just bolt-ons
Hey you got some good number on just bolt-ons
