C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
#41
TECH Enthusiast
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Redondo Beach, CA
Posts: 610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
There is still some issues with the Darton wet sleeve application. It's a head gasket sealing problem in the 12 oclock area. There's not enough material left between the edge of the water jacket and lifter area. I saw some head gaskets that is supposed to fix the problem and I also saw the latest version of the sleeve with the updated o-rings at the bottom. The jury is still out in my opinion.
#42
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (1)
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
I am one of the designers of the Darton kit and do the block machine work and installs so I thought I would fill you folks in on the product.
The Darton MID kit is a wet sleeve design not to be confused with dry kits using Darton sleeves. The material used is the same special ductile iron in both the wet and dry liners but the MID wet sleeves are .237" wall thickness at 4.125" bore size. They do not rely on the old cylinder wall for support as do the dry liners. The dry liners are considerably thinner ~ .060" wall at 4.125" bore with little parent block material left to support them. The MID sleeves can be individually replaced if damaged (broken piston, wrist pin, rings, etc.).
The wet sleeves have three buna rubber o'rings sealing coolant from the crankcase (same as diesel engines) where they are interference fit in the block. They are seated at the very bottom of the block water jacket and can not "drop" as can the dry sleeves since they are solidly seated with deck plates during the installation.
Early kits had problems with gasket seal between head and block but this problem has been resolved through R&D. We recommend only FelPro 1041 gaskets be used but copper will work also if one o'rings the sleeves. Multi layer steel gaskets are not recommended.
Advantages over the C5R and dry sleeves: much stronger than either, individually replacement of liners, no chance of dropped sleeves, will go to 4.165" bore, all machine work done on CNC equipment ensuring quality, cost effective solution for those wanting maximum output from their engines - you can have roughly three Darton MID sleeved blocks for the price of one C5R.
The Darton MID kit is a wet sleeve design not to be confused with dry kits using Darton sleeves. The material used is the same special ductile iron in both the wet and dry liners but the MID wet sleeves are .237" wall thickness at 4.125" bore size. They do not rely on the old cylinder wall for support as do the dry liners. The dry liners are considerably thinner ~ .060" wall at 4.125" bore with little parent block material left to support them. The MID sleeves can be individually replaced if damaged (broken piston, wrist pin, rings, etc.).
The wet sleeves have three buna rubber o'rings sealing coolant from the crankcase (same as diesel engines) where they are interference fit in the block. They are seated at the very bottom of the block water jacket and can not "drop" as can the dry sleeves since they are solidly seated with deck plates during the installation.
Early kits had problems with gasket seal between head and block but this problem has been resolved through R&D. We recommend only FelPro 1041 gaskets be used but copper will work also if one o'rings the sleeves. Multi layer steel gaskets are not recommended.
Advantages over the C5R and dry sleeves: much stronger than either, individually replacement of liners, no chance of dropped sleeves, will go to 4.165" bore, all machine work done on CNC equipment ensuring quality, cost effective solution for those wanting maximum output from their engines - you can have roughly three Darton MID sleeved blocks for the price of one C5R.
__________________
Steve Demirjian
Race Engine Development
Oceanside, Ca.
760-630-0450
web: www.raceenginedevelopment.com/
e-mail: race-engine-development@***.net
Steve Demirjian
Race Engine Development
Oceanside, Ca.
760-630-0450
web: www.raceenginedevelopment.com/
e-mail: race-engine-development@***.net
#44
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
Hey MTI427:
Lots of companies will resleeve our blocks using Darton wet sleeves....the one below charges $1,000 for the machining
http://www.strokerkits.com/darton_sleeves.htm
Lots of companies will resleeve our blocks using Darton wet sleeves....the one below charges $1,000 for the machining
http://www.strokerkits.com/darton_sleeves.htm
#45
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
I think Ive got JPR's first darton sleeved block. Ive got about 5k miles on it so far, no problems with the block (although all kinds of other problems like a broken moser 12 bolt, tuning issues because of larger injectors, etc..). All the internals are forged except the rods and crank, you can check on JPRs website for pricing, which included for me upgraded timing gears and chain, ported and shimmed oil pump, diamond pistons and rings, and excellent service which included joe driving 2+ hrs to my house and then riding 2 hours with me to the dyno to help break the motor in. I hope to get a set of his heads on the car too within the next month or so.
#47
TECH Veteran
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Hartsdale, NY
Posts: 4,055
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
Steve:
Great info - thanks.
Block = $600
Darton wet sleeves = $1,300
Machining = $1,000
...So the cost is about $3K, plus shipping, tax, ect. ...with a C5R costing about $6K you can only get about two Darton-sleeved blocks for the price of one C5R, right?
Great info - thanks.
Block = $600
Darton wet sleeves = $1,300
Machining = $1,000
...So the cost is about $3K, plus shipping, tax, ect. ...with a C5R costing about $6K you can only get about two Darton-sleeved blocks for the price of one C5R, right?
#48
On The Tree
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Hollywood Beach A1A
Posts: 104
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
Steve how can you state that your wet sleeve design is better then the dry?? 2 maybe three years ago this may have been true but not now! If you were aware of whats been happening in the real world you could see that atleast one company has surely perfected the dry sleeve and until you match what they have done you should becareful of what you claim!! By the way how much power have you been able to run through one of these ls1,ls6 blocks so far looks like dry sleeves can hold 1200 flywheel HP until then dry is the way to go for me.I still think your design relies on the head bolts to hold the sides of the block together and we all know how good they are!!!!
#50
On The Tree
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Hollywood Beach A1A
Posts: 104
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
why in this world would you all think that a wet sleeved LS1 not ecotec is better were not talking about other motors we are talking about LS1 ya you all are right lets take all the strength out of the block and yeah HOPE for the best! HAVE A NICE DAY DREAMER.Bring your sprinkler to the next shootout and water the grass BUD.
#52
TECH Enthusiast
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Toronto, Canada
Posts: 650
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
I would like to hear why you guys believe a wet sleeve is better and what the advantages you believe there to be.
I was probably the first person to have a resleeved LS1, period. My first block went together in October of 1999. I'm more than ready to relay the story. Aside from some minor differences my original design was virtually identical to this new Darton wet sleeve design.
I am painfully and intimately knowledgeable on most of the failure points of a wet sleeve interlocking and not.
To say the least the wet sleeves failed for a number of reasons. I'll write it up in the next day or so and post.
In the meantime explain why this new process is superior. Many of the old timers will likely remember back then.
Paul
p.s. I have seen a dry sleeved 422 that broke and severely damaged a sleeve. The sleeve was machined out, the block welded, a new one put in its place, the motor still runs very very strong and reliably to this day. The argument about being able to replace a sleeve the other way doesn't wash either.
I was probably the first person to have a resleeved LS1, period. My first block went together in October of 1999. I'm more than ready to relay the story. Aside from some minor differences my original design was virtually identical to this new Darton wet sleeve design.
I am painfully and intimately knowledgeable on most of the failure points of a wet sleeve interlocking and not.
To say the least the wet sleeves failed for a number of reasons. I'll write it up in the next day or so and post.
In the meantime explain why this new process is superior. Many of the old timers will likely remember back then.
Paul
p.s. I have seen a dry sleeved 422 that broke and severely damaged a sleeve. The sleeve was machined out, the block welded, a new one put in its place, the motor still runs very very strong and reliably to this day. The argument about being able to replace a sleeve the other way doesn't wash either.
#53
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
Actually, going along those lines, MTI has my confidence because a Vette running their 427 + Nitrous won One of Lap of America - drove across the US and raced on various roadcourses..
Why bother with anybodys sleeves other then ARE's They just went 8.50s gotta be the strongest block out there
#54
TECH Veteran
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Hartsdale, NY
Posts: 4,055
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
BadMood:
OK but the guy who designed the Darton wet sleeve says in this post that it is stronger than the C5R and the Darton dry sleeve blocks.... in addition, the wet sleeves have better thermal properties...
I would take this as knowledge straight from the horses' mouth; right?
We have all heard a ton of bad things about dropped dry sleeves. Do you really think the dry sleeved process has been perfected and no longer results in busted blocks?
I will say this. LPE advertises the Darton wets in their web page, ------>
....but I heard from others here that they have not shipped any yet. This does make you wonder if they have identified a problem with the wet sleeves....
OK but the guy who designed the Darton wet sleeve says in this post that it is stronger than the C5R and the Darton dry sleeve blocks.... in addition, the wet sleeves have better thermal properties...
I would take this as knowledge straight from the horses' mouth; right?
We have all heard a ton of bad things about dropped dry sleeves. Do you really think the dry sleeved process has been perfected and no longer results in busted blocks?
I will say this. LPE advertises the Darton wets in their web page, ------>
....but I heard from others here that they have not shipped any yet. This does make you wonder if they have identified a problem with the wet sleeves....
#55
TECH Veteran
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Hartsdale, NY
Posts: 4,055
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
BadMood:
OK but the guy who designed the Darton wet sleeve says in this post that it is stronger than the C5R and the Darton dry sleeve blocks.... in addition, the wet sleeves have better thermal properties...
I would take this as knowledge straight from the horses' mouth; right?
We have all heard a ton of bad things about dropped dry sleeves. Do you really think the dry sleeved process has been perfected and no longer results in busted blocks?
I will say this. LPE advertises the Darton wets in their web page, ------>
....but I heard from others here that they have not shipped any yet. This does make you wonder if they have identified a problem with the wet sleeves....
OK but the guy who designed the Darton wet sleeve says in this post that it is stronger than the C5R and the Darton dry sleeve blocks.... in addition, the wet sleeves have better thermal properties...
I would take this as knowledge straight from the horses' mouth; right?
We have all heard a ton of bad things about dropped dry sleeves. Do you really think the dry sleeved process has been perfected and no longer results in busted blocks?
I will say this. LPE advertises the Darton wets in their web page, ------>
....but I heard from others here that they have not shipped any yet. This does make you wonder if they have identified a problem with the wet sleeves....
#56
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Round Lake, IL
Posts: 731
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
Actually, going along those lines, MTI has my confidence because a Vette running their 427 + Nitrous won One of Lap of America - drove across the US and raced on various roadcourses..
Why bother with anybodys sleeves other then ARE's They just went 8.50s gotta be the strongest block out there
#58
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (4)
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
Why bother with anybodys sleeves other then ARE's They just went 8.50s gotta be the strongest block out there
#59
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Elmhurst, IL (Chicago Suburb)
Posts: 1,851
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
I have personally seen up close and heard idling the MTI Z07 car that won the one lap of america and spoke for a 1/2 hour with one of the owners trusted employees who was there with the car. I can assure you guys that said car runs the C5R block also in response to the following:
"OK but the guy who designed the Darton wet sleeve says in this post that it is stronger than the C5R and the Darton dry sleeve blocks.... in addition, the wet sleeves have better thermal properties..."
Do you always believe what people tell you or what a salesman claims about his product? I hope not!!!!!!!!!! At any rate, not to discredit the DARTON SLEEVES REP. here who has provided alot of info and claims about his DARTON BLOCKS, his block may turn out to be kick azz and reliable/durable as claimed, but the jury is out on this product as it has not yet been battled tested like the C5R block has, time and time again, in hardcore racing circuit like LEMANS, etc.
ALso, i personally spoke with ED POTTER at LPE and he told me that their DARTON sleeved block is not offered yet as they are still doing R&D b/c of their block is not yet perfected, etc.
GO THREAD HERE no doubt!
"OK but the guy who designed the Darton wet sleeve says in this post that it is stronger than the C5R and the Darton dry sleeve blocks.... in addition, the wet sleeves have better thermal properties..."
Do you always believe what people tell you or what a salesman claims about his product? I hope not!!!!!!!!!! At any rate, not to discredit the DARTON SLEEVES REP. here who has provided alot of info and claims about his DARTON BLOCKS, his block may turn out to be kick azz and reliable/durable as claimed, but the jury is out on this product as it has not yet been battled tested like the C5R block has, time and time again, in hardcore racing circuit like LEMANS, etc.
ALso, i personally spoke with ED POTTER at LPE and he told me that their DARTON sleeved block is not offered yet as they are still doing R&D b/c of their block is not yet perfected, etc.
GO THREAD HERE no doubt!
#60
10 Second Club
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: New to South Carolina
Posts: 910
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: C5R block Vs. Darton wet sleeves
So,if money were no object,go the C5R block.I cant do that,so,
MTI sleeve motor = early on they had some dropped sleeves[I think Nineball dropped one]but now they have changed something and cut down the percentage of bad sleeves?
ARE = I have no idea what the failure rate is but from this post,it seems to be low.
Darton = well I guess we have to wait and see.I think if LPE is still not offering them,well I dont know.ARE,Darton,once again from this post they seem to have a low rate of failure but ARE uses their own priority system.
Question,when sleeves drop or Dartons leak,when does it show up? Is it usually fairly quick or does it take a while?
MTI sleeve motor = early on they had some dropped sleeves[I think Nineball dropped one]but now they have changed something and cut down the percentage of bad sleeves?
ARE = I have no idea what the failure rate is but from this post,it seems to be low.
Darton = well I guess we have to wait and see.I think if LPE is still not offering them,well I dont know.ARE,Darton,once again from this post they seem to have a low rate of failure but ARE uses their own priority system.
Question,when sleeves drop or Dartons leak,when does it show up? Is it usually fairly quick or does it take a while?