opinions on dry sump vs. wet sump
#1
On The Tree
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2015
Location: Grew up in Charleston, SC live in Moncure, NC
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
2 Posts
opinions on dry sump vs. wet sump
I have searched the forum and haven't quite found the answer I am looking for.
I will be getting an LS7 crate engine from an aftermarket company, still researching - Mast, Texas Speed, etc. Something similar to the Mast 427 SS 650 HP rated one. This will be a street car for now with maybe a few engine upgrades as I become more familiar with LS engines.
Most offer a choice between dry and wet sump oiling. The dry sump would be the GM/LS7 version...I would like to get a few opinions. With cost aside, what would be your choice?
thanks
I will be getting an LS7 crate engine from an aftermarket company, still researching - Mast, Texas Speed, etc. Something similar to the Mast 427 SS 650 HP rated one. This will be a street car for now with maybe a few engine upgrades as I become more familiar with LS engines.
Most offer a choice between dry and wet sump oiling. The dry sump would be the GM/LS7 version...I would like to get a few opinions. With cost aside, what would be your choice?
thanks
#2
Unless you are planning to make a pretty radical road track car, there is no need for a dry sump. Wet sump oiling is preferred for most applications for ease/cost vs benefit. Dry sump is great if you are moving to high corner g loads, sustained 7000+ rpm. Even if you find yourself needing to move to a dry sump application you should not go with the LS7 setup. It's actually considered to be more of a hybrid setup. For a truly effective dry sump system you'll want to go with a company like AVAID and pumps designed with multiple scavenging points.
#3
On The Tree
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2015
Location: Grew up in Charleston, SC live in Moncure, NC
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
2 Posts
Unless you are planning to make a pretty radical road track car, there is no need for a dry sump. Wet sump oiling is preferred for most applications for ease/cost vs benefit. Dry sump is great if you are moving to high corner g loads, sustained 7000+ rpm. Even if you find yourself needing to move to a dry sump application you should not go with the LS7 setup. It's actually considered to be more of a hybrid setup. For a truly effective dry sump system you'll want to go with a company like AVAID and pumps designed with multiple scavenging points.
#4
Thanks for your reply. Taking "ease/cost" out of the equation, I was wondering if there was a benefit for my application. As far as dry sump oiling goes in general, I agree the LS7 system is not the best choice for road racing, etc. But, GM chose to install them on a "street" vehicle for a reason...guess I tend to wonder why.
Theres also a HP benefit with dry sump, in that it reduces the amount of oil caught up in crank shaft windage.
Trending Topics
#8
Moderator
iTrader: (20)
Even though the LS7 is a hybrid/half *** dry sump, it's still packaged better than a true dry sump. No external pump and pulley with a belt that could slip or come off. It's crank driven so as long as the crank is turning, you are getting oil.
It's still better than a wet sump system too. One of the LS engine's major flaws is how badly it aerates the oil. Pulling the oil into a seperate reservoir helps in keeping the crank from whipping up the oil as badly and the internal design of the reservoir helps deaerate the oil. It also helps to have the large oil capacity as well.
It's still better than a wet sump system too. One of the LS engine's major flaws is how badly it aerates the oil. Pulling the oil into a seperate reservoir helps in keeping the crank from whipping up the oil as badly and the internal design of the reservoir helps deaerate the oil. It also helps to have the large oil capacity as well.
#9
On The Tree
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2015
Location: Grew up in Charleston, SC live in Moncure, NC
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
2 Posts
Even though the LS7 is a hybrid/half *** dry sump, it's still packaged better than a true dry sump. No external pump and pulley with a belt that could slip or come off. It's crank driven so as long as the crank is turning, you are getting oil.
It's still better than a wet sump system too. One of the LS engine's major flaws is how badly it aerates the oil. Pulling the oil into a seperate reservoir helps in keeping the crank from whipping up the oil as badly and the internal design of the reservoir helps deaerate the oil. It also helps to have the large oil capacity as well.
It's still better than a wet sump system too. One of the LS engine's major flaws is how badly it aerates the oil. Pulling the oil into a seperate reservoir helps in keeping the crank from whipping up the oil as badly and the internal design of the reservoir helps deaerate the oil. It also helps to have the large oil capacity as well.
All of the replies are great info. Thanks. I guess I'm still undecided - will need to think more about this over the next few weeks...
#10
On The Tree
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2015
Location: Grew up in Charleston, SC live in Moncure, NC
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
2 Posts
Another quick question. Hopefully someone can answer this here without me starting another thread.
On the LS7 style dry sump, what keeps the oil in the external tank from emptying into the engine after sitting for prolonged periods? The pump? I'm guessing it is a positive displacement gear pump?
On the LS7 style dry sump, what keeps the oil in the external tank from emptying into the engine after sitting for prolonged periods? The pump? I'm guessing it is a positive displacement gear pump?
#11
TECH Resident
iTrader: (1)
Another quick question. Hopefully someone can answer this here without me starting another thread.
On the LS7 style dry sump, what keeps the oil in the external tank from emptying into the engine after sitting for prolonged periods? The pump? I'm guessing it is a positive displacement gear pump?
On the LS7 style dry sump, what keeps the oil in the external tank from emptying into the engine after sitting for prolonged periods? The pump? I'm guessing it is a positive displacement gear pump?
It sucks from the pan and pumps to the external tank, then sucks from the external tankandpumps throughout the enginewhere oil drains back to the pan,starting the process over.
#12
Moderator
iTrader: (10)
I would like to get a few opinions. With cost aside, what would be your choice?