Pulled the fuel rail to check injectors and found this:
The good news is that the injectors were not leaking. The bad news is that all of my injectors had these black tips on them except one.
Now what?!
Chances are it went into the head. If you don't want to pull the intake you could always stick a camera down in the injector hole.
I ended up calling a fuel injector company and was told that the tip has no mechanical function – it only helps to hold the O-ring in place. They said it is fine to run without it and most likely when it fell off it just got burned up and sent out the exhaust. Phew!

