Msd timing retard box?
Msd timing retard box? I'm looking for a device where I can hit a switch and it automatically pulls timing when my nitrous is armed so I can still race my car on motor without the timing pulled if that makes sense. Is there anything out there from msd that could allow me to do that not looking to spend 700 on a lpe progressive controller.
Ls1tech & Truck Sponsor
iTrader: (4)
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 2,267
Likes: 1
From: Wichita falls Texas
I'm looking for a device where I can hit a switch and it automatically pulls timing when my nitrous is armed so I can still race my car on motor without the timing pulled if that makes sense. Is there anything out there from msd that could allow me to do that not looking to spend 700 on a lpe progressive controller.
TECH Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 620
Likes: 0
From: Katherine N.T Australia
Why not use the factory PCM and have someone with EFI LIVE tune it. Its a feature in Custom OS 5 to pull timing when you ground pin 56. I'm doing my system this way and also running it dry as the OS also has the capability to add extra fuel when you pull the nitrous trigger.
Why not use the factory PCM and have someone with EFI LIVE tune it. Its a feature in Custom OS 5 to pull timing when you ground pin 56. I'm doing my system this way and also running it dry as the OS also has the capability to add extra fuel when you pull the nitrous trigger.
Trending Topics
LS1 Tech Stories
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
6 Common C5 Corvette Failures and What's Involved In Repairing Them
Pouria Savadkouei
Retro Modern Bandit Pontiac Trans AM Comes With Burt Reynolds' Autograph
Verdad Gallardo
Top 10 Greatest Cadillac V Series Performance Models Ever, Ranked
Pouria Savadkouei
Top 10 Most Powerful Chevy Trucks Ever Made!
Hennessey's New Supercharged Silverado ZR2 Has 700 HP
Verdad Gallardo
Coachbuilt N2A Anteros Is an LS2-Powered C6 Corvette In Italian Clothes
Verdad Gallardo
Awesome K5 Blazer Restomod Comes With C7 Corvette Power
Verdad Gallardo
10 Camaros You Should Never Buy
10 LS Engine Myths That Refuse to Die
Verdad Gallardo Which requires him to have HPT and to know what he is doing. If he doesn't know what he is doing then that means he will have to go back to the tuner everytime he wants the timing changed. That is just too much to be doing to keep going back and forth with the laptop and such.
Put the LNC 2000 in your glove box and keep a pocket screwdriver. Done.
Put the LNC 2000 in your glove box and keep a pocket screwdriver. Done.
TECH Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 620
Likes: 0
From: Katherine N.T Australia
Which requires him to have HPT and to know what he is doing. If he doesn't know what he is doing then that means he will have to go back to the tuner everytime he wants the timing changed. That is just too much to be doing to keep going back and forth with the laptop and such.
Put the LNC 2000 in your glove box and keep a pocket screwdriver. Done.
Put the LNC 2000 in your glove box and keep a pocket screwdriver. Done.
If the owner didn't want to go all out and pay for the software, they could always just purchase a Autocal from a tuner.
That way the tuner can email them any number of tunes with different amounts of timing retard or any other aspect for that matter for them to store in the Autocal and flash in at will.
Cost wise an Autocal is competitive with a timing box too, but has a lot more features.
http://www.efilive.com/product-info-autocal
Last edited by macca_779; Jan 8, 2014 at 04:46 PM.
Which requires him to have HPT and to know what he is doing. If he doesn't know what he is doing then that means he will have to go back to the tuner everytime he wants the timing changed. That is just too much to be doing to keep going back and forth with the laptop and such.
Put the LNC 2000 in your glove box and keep a pocket screwdriver. Done.
Put the LNC 2000 in your glove box and keep a pocket screwdriver. Done.
The LNC-2000 is exactly what the OP needs.
Last edited by brandon@nitrousoutlet; Jan 10, 2014 at 01:27 PM.
HPT can't do it without using something like the IAT harness and skewing the sensor. Only EFI LIVE has a Nitrous supported Operating System.
If the owner didn't want to go all out and pay for the software, they could always just purchase a Autocal from a tuner.
That way the tuner can email them any number of tunes with different amounts of timing retard or any other aspect for that matter for them to store in the Autocal and flash in at will.
Cost wise an Autocal is competitive with a timing box too, but has a lot more features.
http://www.efilive.com/product-info-autocal
If the owner didn't want to go all out and pay for the software, they could always just purchase a Autocal from a tuner.
That way the tuner can email them any number of tunes with different amounts of timing retard or any other aspect for that matter for them to store in the Autocal and flash in at will.
Cost wise an Autocal is competitive with a timing box too, but has a lot more features.
http://www.efilive.com/product-info-autocal
It does more on the abilities end of functions but I don't like the idea that I have to upload a certain tune to spray a certain shot.
The autocal is better suited for someone who doesn't have a good tuner locally. Since it has the data log feature and such.
TECH Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 620
Likes: 0
From: Katherine N.T Australia
You better re-read that link you posted. The tuner has to buy those auto cal things and its 1500 bucks for a pack of five. Then he has to load the tunes into it. So if you just divide 1500 by 5, its just 300 bucks alone for one of the autocal things from the tuner and we all know he is not going to give you those tunes for free. So, you're looking at 4-500 bucks or more and the LNC is $274.95, to me that's not "competitive" at all. 10 bucks is competitive. $25 or more to do less than what the LNC can do is not a smart idea.
It does more on the abilities end of functions but I don't like the idea that I have to upload a certain tune to spray a certain shot.
The autocal is better suited for someone who doesn't have a good tuner locally. Since it has the data log feature and such.
It does more on the abilities end of functions but I don't like the idea that I have to upload a certain tune to spray a certain shot.
The autocal is better suited for someone who doesn't have a good tuner locally. Since it has the data log feature and such.
I would hope tuners would have stock on board and not have to purchase just for one guy.
As for charging extra to provide an N20 calibration. I personally wouldn't charge anything extra to someone that already had a tune done by me. Its literally 2 tables and send an email.
Installing for an N20 calibration is literally adding 1 wire to the PCM. So you have to put a price on convenience too and reliability too. I'm sure the LNC is good. But, more wiring and an aftermarket module will never be as reliable as an OEM PCM.
This is true. But its the kind of product people could purchase at the beginning of their modification journey. Or if they haven't had a tune yet.
I would hope tuners would have stock on board and not have to purchase just for one guy.
As for charging extra to provide an N20 calibration. I personally wouldn't charge anything extra to someone that already had a tune done by me. Its literally 2 tables and send an email.
Installing for an N20 calibration is literally adding 1 wire to the PCM. So you have to put a price on convenience too and reliability too. I'm sure the LNC is good. But, more wiring and an aftermarket module will never be as reliable as an OEM PCM.
I would hope tuners would have stock on board and not have to purchase just for one guy.
As for charging extra to provide an N20 calibration. I personally wouldn't charge anything extra to someone that already had a tune done by me. Its literally 2 tables and send an email.
Installing for an N20 calibration is literally adding 1 wire to the PCM. So you have to put a price on convenience too and reliability too. I'm sure the LNC is good. But, more wiring and an aftermarket module will never be as reliable as an OEM PCM.
I don't frequent the pcm, diagnostic, tuning section much but I have never seen anyone mention them until you have in this thread so I had to do a little research on them.
Keyword: "PCM". The PCM is reliable but can you vouch for a person's wiring habits and the such with them running that 1 wire? Its just a nit pick thing. People are known to botch things up like using wire nuts for house electrical on cars. We've all seen it so, there are pros and cons of both.
TECH Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 620
Likes: 0
From: Katherine N.T Australia
That's on you if you don't charge, I can safely say that any tuner here will charge since time is money.
I don't frequent the pcm, diagnostic, tuning section much but I have never seen anyone mention them until you have in this thread so I had to do a little research on them.
Keyword: "PCM". The PCM is reliable but can you vouch for a person's wiring habits and the such with them running that 1 wire? Its just a nit pick thing. People are known to botch things up like using wire nuts for house electrical on cars. We've all seen it so, there are pros and cons of both.
I don't frequent the pcm, diagnostic, tuning section much but I have never seen anyone mention them until you have in this thread so I had to do a little research on them.
Keyword: "PCM". The PCM is reliable but can you vouch for a person's wiring habits and the such with them running that 1 wire? Its just a nit pick thing. People are known to botch things up like using wire nuts for house electrical on cars. We've all seen it so, there are pros and cons of both.
The reason you haven't heard of an Autocal is because EFI LIVE isn't used widely in the US for some reason. Also its not a sponsored product on here. I've used both EFI LIVE and HPT. EFI LIVE is the better product in my option, especially with the nitrous features available on the LS1. Makes using a dry system very economical, reliable and simple.
No different to wiring up an LNC though.
The reason you haven't heard of an Autocal is because EFI LIVE isn't used widely in the US for some reason. Also its not a sponsored product on here. I've used both EFI LIVE and HPT. EFI LIVE is the better product in my option, especially with the nitrous features available on the LS1. Makes using a dry system very economical, reliable and simple.
The reason you haven't heard of an Autocal is because EFI LIVE isn't used widely in the US for some reason. Also its not a sponsored product on here. I've used both EFI LIVE and HPT. EFI LIVE is the better product in my option, especially with the nitrous features available on the LS1. Makes using a dry system very economical, reliable and simple.
I've tuned with both....
I feel the same about each one when it comes to how well they do at tuning....both do the job well...
when it comes to the actual tuning... neither one is better than the other
they both have access to the same tables...
I like the interface better on HPTuners...and the scanner is better and easier to use....
but I have no issues with tuning on EFI Live, and I like the custom OS's better on EFI live.
(though I do really like looks of the Gauges interface in EFI live's scanner)
theres plenty of knowledge about EFI live in the US... but HP tuners has a much better interface for most Americans(we tend to be a more visual people...we like bells and whistles and "pretty" things), and comes out better priced and has a better licensing system(as in more options to keep end user costs lower)
TECH Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 620
Likes: 0
From: Katherine N.T Australia
Your right the interface provided by both solutions gets the job done. But that's no concern to the owner. It's the features of the os that shine through to the vehicles owner. You even said it yourself. EFI live has the features. It's for this reason if nothing else as to why it's the better solution especially for nitrous applications where a lot of control can be handled by the PCM without having the requirement for further controllers. The LNC is a fantastic product and it has it's place in the nitrous world. But it's standout feature is timing retard when spraying. Something which can be accomplished in the os quite easily. Sure if you want to tinker with shot size yourself and can't justify buying the software or using a tuner then go for the LNC without a doubt
I found a place that still stocks the timing twister and not the lnc 2000. I like that the msd box allows you to pull a little more timing than lpe box if I read the descriptions right. Thoughts??
LS1Tech Sponsor
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 603
Likes: 1
From: Decatur, IN
Max timing retard On late model engines with fairly fast combustion (where maximum power timing is usually in the 24 to 28 degrees of timing range) I am not aware of many applications that need more than 15 degrees of timing retard for nitrous. Much below that and combustion becomes pretty poor.
If you really need more timing retard than that we make a torque reduction box (LNC-TRM) for use with transmission controllers and traction control devices that has up to 50 degrees of timing retard authority:
http://www.lingenfelter.com/mm5/merc...=#.U5IAR_ldUh8
If you really need more timing retard than that we make a torque reduction box (LNC-TRM) for use with transmission controllers and traction control devices that has up to 50 degrees of timing retard authority:
http://www.lingenfelter.com/mm5/merc...=#.U5IAR_ldUh8