mattf2

The other day, at shenendoah, I saw a civic pass 2 Zo6's, 1 C5 and 1 C6. In multiple sessions. These weren't the greatest drivers in the world, but they weren't bad.

Alot has to do w/ driver, power to weight, setup, etc.

subtlez28

iTrader: (15)

What is your point?

I could probably walk up behind Mike Tyson, hit him over the head with a 2x4, and knock him out. Then I could go around telling everyone about the time I knocked out Mike Tyson... Does that make a better boxer or tougher than Mike Tyson?

The question is can a f-body handle like a Z06. No. Not stock for stock or mod for mod. I love my Z28 to, but, lets start living in reality.

Stories of modded cars with good drivers passing old guys or poor drivers in stock Z06s at HPDEs does not make a civic nor a V-6 f-body a superior handling car!

Yes, a modded car on race tires with a good driver can pass an inexperienced driver in a stock car with street tires. This, however, is hardly a apple to apple comparison. Put a set of Hoosiers on an even stock Z06 (especially a C6 Z06) with a competent driver and no civic or V-6 f-body will pass it on an open track I assure you.

Mat

Great links. Thanks for the reply man!!

Mat

Well put. I think I should have phrased what I was asking a little better.

Essentially I was approaching things from a platform angle, just doing a terrible job. I love my WS6. I think it looks fantastic compared to even a new Z06. Fact is, the Z06 platform from the get-go is flat out better.

What I'm trying to figure out for myself is if the F-Body platform will give me the handling characteristics to satisfy my corner carving desires, or if I should save the cash and start with a Corvette platform to meet my goals.

What are my goals?

It's a crapshoot because I've never been in a Strano prep F-Body. I have been in a C5 Z06 absolutely flying around and I've been in a 1997 Camaro SS with a stage 2 suspension, sticky tires and a pretty peppy autocross driver behind the wheel. Both impressed me.

The more I chew on this one the more I realize I'm just going to order some proven parts from you, stick them on the WS6 and get on with it. At the end of that road, if I'm still not satisfied, then I'll look at other options.

I have a feeling I will more than happy.

subtlez28

iTrader: (15)

Don't get me wrong. I am in no way trying to discourage anyone from road racing an F-body. They are very competent and a ton (nearly 2 actually) of fun. The 4th gen is a great car, and not a bad handling platform. With the right parts it gains leaps and bounds in the car control department.

I'm just enforcing the point that the Z06 is better platform from the start, and therefore an unfair or unrealistic comparison.

WarShrike

iTrader: (5)

To tell you the truth there were others out there that were pretty skilled at auto-x. You don't need to get your panties in a bunch. You can throw your BS flag up all you want.

I in no way, shape or form said to just all go to V6's. I'm not a V6 nutswinger either. I just said it comes down to a competent driver and seat time.

It is plain as day knowledge that the Corvette is a better platform to start from. I've heard of a few guys dropping their modded F-body and going for a C5 or C6 and taking up where they left off. It is much more of a purpose built car for that niche.

subtlez28

iTrader: (15)

Gotta admit my "panties" were kind of in a bunch. I get annoyed when people make unfair comparisons.

You are right, though, a driver can make all the difference.

To that end I witnessed a new ZR1 run a mid 14 second quarter. My 02 Z28 set up for road racing and w stock LS1 was running 13.4s at 108 (horrible 2.2-2.4 60 fts). I was embarrassed for that guy! I wish I could have got lined up against him. I would have loved to had a story of smoking a new ZR1 in my Z28. That was drag racing, and the guy clearly could not muster the skill to get down the track quickly. Imagine how bad he would have looked on a road course!

Anyway, I just seem to get ryalled up when people make comparisons that are really about drivers, when the question was about cars.

WarShrike

iTrader: (5)

Yeah, it's really hard to hide when you're at a driving performance event and the times are there for everybody to see. Just glad the ZR1 owner didn't stuff it into the wall.

I love the David and Goliath battles between different class cars. It makes races that much more exciting, and it can be a very rewarding experience for the drivers.

I'd love it if we had a road course out here. I know exactly where I'd spend my free time

mattf2

My point is this:

Go to a NASA Thunder race and watch a few civics pass alot of V8's. These are CMC, AI, AIX, and whatever the corvette class is called (ST1, 2???) The fastest civics aren't passing the fastest cars in the group, but these people all have their competition licenses, and a good portion are being passed by little buzz bombs that probably weigh 1500 lbs w/ driver, if that.

In the time trial competition, a TTC civic SI was faster than EVERY TTB and all but one TTA car. He was even faster than 1/2 of the TTS field.

here's the link:
http://www.get-fast.net/temp/sunday_...july09_vir.pdf

This was at VIR, a horsepower track.

So, what was it that made the Civic faster than all but 1 higher classed driver??? Is he that great of a driver he can pass all of these high HP cars? Is his car set up better than most of the other cars? Is his power to weight better than all these cars? Maybe it's a combination of things.

I hope that I was able to clarify things for you...

Arctic2002ss

I think you've got the idea. These cars do handle well, especially with some upgrades. Do other cars handle better? Sure. I still have a blast at the track with my SS. Many people that don't know these cars are impressed how well mine does. I will say that our cars like higher speed tracks with big sweeping corners though. I will have to let cars pass me at one track that I simple out-power at another track. Just get out there and have some fun.

subtlez28

iTrader: (15)

OK....

My point, in questioning your point, is that this tread is asking if a F-body can handle like a Z06. It is a question of mechanical ability of the chassis. Not if you put a great driver in car A, can it beat car B.

The better driver issue is not the point of the thread. I'm sure his question is would he (or any same driver) be faster in a Z06, or F-body. Driver skill aside (as it doesn't change the actual cars ability to "handle") the Z06 is a better handling car, period.

Sam Strano

iTrader: (41)

I wouldn't say period.... Because one can screw up a Corvette, I've seen it done.

Is a stock Z06 better than a stock f-body? Ahhhh, yeah. Is a stock Z06 better than a well-prepped f-body? Not necessarily. Is a prepped Z06 better than a prepped f-body? Probably, but maybe not as much as one would think.

Look the Corvette is better balanced and lighter. Not bad things. But they are often run too low, with lousy shocks, way too big a rear swaybar, and by people who blindly think that it's a Corvette it must be better. And honestly, with track days all you can do is look at who it running over who in the corners, because overall lap time has so much to do with power to weight. Even a dog handling car can run pretty fast if you can out engine a better handling car.

Shadow's SS

iTrader: (1)

Im not going to Argue what car is better, But I would just like to mention that I spend a good couple days talking with and bouncing Ideas off sam back in 05 over the phone (I was deployed overseas soo seeing him in person wasnt much of an option) and with his advice and help I mirrored my gen 4 camaro off his personal setup, It handles like a dream, I have driven it for over 8 hour on road trips and put it through the corners in Auto-x events, If I ever wanted to change the set-up or look at going with a Corvette, Sam would be the first person I would give a call to when looking to replace the stock set-up.

I would just worry about what i can do with the car that i have. one of my first Auto-x events i watched a new C-6 just kill everything on the track that same day one of the worst running cars was also a Stock C-6. the Driver really make the car in the end.

toadzq8

iTrader: (43)

1. 4/4 Koni's, 2. A set of Sam's sway bars. 3. adjustable PHB, A pair of 1LE rear control arms. Don't lower it! just creates other problems with roll center and bump steer and control arm angles.