I agree with your assessment. Sounds like you took good care of the car. You just can't expect the big $$ though. The insurance company is probably accurate in this instance at about $2,000 - $3,000 for the whole damaged car. A healthy non-damaged example will only bring so much with those miles. Maybe $6k on a good day??? I doubt much higher. I always hypothetically put myself into others shoes. If I had the same accident with my car (still under 50,000 miles and one owner) I would realize the car would be worth well under $10,000. I mean, you have to ask, who wants it?? Now if I added another 100,000+ miles on it, what is it worth? Not much. I really dislike insurance agencies using broad brushed comparisons on cars but IMO they are certainly close in this instance. The fact that they consider a one or two owner well cared for garage kept car the same as a 5 owner car left out in the elements is just so wrong on so many levels. The price guides do the same thing. No consideration. Unfortunately there is little price spread anymore as the cars get old. Your toughest task ahead is finding another nice ride. Best of luck!