Advice on good RCA cables?
Advice on good RCA cables? Hey guys, my alternator whine sounds like a siren... I'm pretty sure it's the RCA cable just being a POS. Every time there's whine and I press in on the RCA cables it goes away and comes back a few minutes later.. I had good RCA's before but the box moved and broke them. I replaced them with a set from a shop near me and it sounds like $hit now. If I'm mis-diagnosing this problem let me know, otherwise I need to know the name of a good brand of RCA cables.
Thanks guys,
Justin
Thanks guys,
Justin
Originally Posted by you2slo
I will agree to disagree. A $2 set of RCA's has the same overall tonal qualities of a gold-plated OFC shielded high-quality RCA?
now, is the $2 set going to be as durable and hold up to being pulled through a car, and possible removed and reinstalled a couple times ?
no.
12 Second Club
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 272
Likes: 0
From: Boise, ID
Wait one sec. $2.00 rca's are same as good ones?
NO NO NO NONO NO, there are reasons that there are $100 RCA Cables and $2.00 RCA cables. If you have a high end stereo, you can loose quality dramatically through crappy RCA's. Some rules of thumb are, don't run the power and rca's together. If you have power running next to a ground, have them running opposite ways (The curves in the power going different directions), this disables both electrical fields that are being emitted and cancels some noise. The quality of signal is only as good as it's weakest part. If your deck puts out a crappy signal and good rca's, then the rca's won't matter... but if you have good deck and shitty rca's, then the quality is bottlenecked there.
NO NO NO NONO NO, there are reasons that there are $100 RCA Cables and $2.00 RCA cables. If you have a high end stereo, you can loose quality dramatically through crappy RCA's. Some rules of thumb are, don't run the power and rca's together. If you have power running next to a ground, have them running opposite ways (The curves in the power going different directions), this disables both electrical fields that are being emitted and cancels some noise. The quality of signal is only as good as it's weakest part. If your deck puts out a crappy signal and good rca's, then the rca's won't matter... but if you have good deck and shitty rca's, then the quality is bottlenecked there.
Trending Topics
Teching In
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
Just like network cables (cat5 ie 'twisted pair'), the higher priced cables use a twisted pair design to reduce interference from ouside sources. In network cables, the difference between Cat 3 and Cat 5 is the number of twists per foot. more twists = less interference = higher speed. cat 3= 10mb/sec cat5=100mb/sec. Your $2 Radio Shack RCA cables will probably sound just as good as $40+ cables, until you actually run them in the car. I have 3 different RCAs in my build cause I am cheap. $10 cable fro the sub, $20 cable for the sail panel woofers (though the $10 cable would work fine because I have the corssovers set low), and $49 cable for the front component speakers. The $10 or just normal cables like you have used in your home stereo for years. The $20 ones are shielded. The $49 are twisted pair. HUGE difference in all 3 as for alternator whine when connected to the front speakers. Because the whine is at a higher frequency, it does not matter for the sub. Try it yourself and see. By cheap, medium, and expensive and try all three and see if it makes a difference in your setup. Then return what you dont need.
Last edited by Bacardi151; Apr 25, 2007 at 12:16 PM.
LS1 Tech Stories
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
6 Common C5 Corvette Failures and What's Involved In Repairing Them
Pouria Savadkouei
Retro Modern Bandit Pontiac Trans AM Comes With Burt Reynolds' Autograph
Verdad Gallardo
Top 10 Greatest Cadillac V Series Performance Models Ever, Ranked
Pouria Savadkouei
Top 10 Most Powerful Chevy Trucks Ever Made!
Hennessey's New Supercharged Silverado ZR2 Has 700 HP
Verdad Gallardo
Coachbuilt N2A Anteros Is an LS2-Powered C6 Corvette In Italian Clothes
Verdad Gallardo
Awesome K5 Blazer Restomod Comes With C7 Corvette Power
Verdad Gallardo
10 Camaros You Should Never Buy
10 LS Engine Myths That Refuse to Die
Verdad Gallardo
Originally Posted by sbusby
Wait one sec. $2.00 rca's are same as good ones?
can be..
first, let's take noise out of the picture, like we are installing the cables on a home system. In that case, what is it about the expensive cables that make them better ? All you need is a conductor of the proper gauge to conduct the signal. We are not even talking about complex signals here. Audio is very low frequency compared to whats used in general electronics and computers.
now, add the car enviornment, and I'll admit that some cables may reject noise better then others, but it's not going to make the system "sound better" if there is no noise to begin with. Some cars and installs are noisier then others. Some people may get lucky and have a quiet system with the cheapest of the cheap cables, while others may need a better shielded or twisted cable.
In my experience though, every noise issue I've troubleshooted came down to either the rca cables being damaged, or a poor ground.
mike
TECH Addict
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 2,591
Likes: 1
From: Massachusetts
Originally Posted by sbusby
Wait one sec. $2.00 rca's are same as good ones?
If you don't disconnect and reconnect your cables hundreds of times over their lifetime, and you don't put much physical strain on the wires, there's very rarely a difference between $2 cables and $100 cables other than appearance.
Teching In
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
BTW My post above only deal in the noise area. Actual difference in sound between the 3 cables is inaudible to me. But the $10 cable has way too much whine like th OP describes. The $20 set is liveable, noticeable at really lo volumes, but not at listening volumes. The $49 set is light enough that it is barely audible with the volume at zero and is imperceptable any music playing. I am intersted in seeing if a $100 cable would reduce it entirely, but I am too cheap to try it.
Originally Posted by Mike @ FbodyAudio
yep, my guess is that the audio ground in the cable is broken.
mike
mike
12 Second Club
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 272
Likes: 0
From: Boise, ID
Originally Posted by dragonrage
As far as sound quality goes, yes. What do you really think the difference is? Shielding? That's for radio frequency, which we can't even hear. At all. Durability? Yes, there can be a difference in that, be it in the jacketing of the cable or the plating on the connectors or whatnot. But I've never had RCA cables corrode on me, cheap or not. The resistance, capacitance and inductance (our powers combined, we are... impedance) are all negligible because they're so absolutely small compared to the impedance of the input of whatever device they're connected to.
If you don't disconnect and reconnect your cables hundreds of times over their lifetime, and you don't put much physical strain on the wires, there's very rarely a difference between $2 cables and $100 cables other than appearance.
If you don't disconnect and reconnect your cables hundreds of times over their lifetime, and you don't put much physical strain on the wires, there's very rarely a difference between $2 cables and $100 cables other than appearance.
I disagree.... my agrument is this
I just sat down with an expert installer in my area. He just finished installing the following:
1 set) Focal Utopia Beriliyum 6" 5 1/4" and tweeter - $5,000 speaker set
3) 13'' Focal Utopia Subs - $1,000 sub
F1 Status Alpine deck
and two rediculously priced audison amplifiers... can't remember the stupid model numbers
For sound check purposes he put a regular $15.00 rca cables from the deck to the amplifiers. Hooked them up and listened. Everything sounded pretty good. Later that day the Platinum coated RCA's showed up, pluged those in to test new rcas.. it didn't sound good, it sounded AMAZING. Vehicle was on a car charger so the battery was being depleated. Those RCA's were the only things that were changed and there was an exteremly noticable difference.
When you have a set volume on a stereo it sends a certain signal to the amplifiers to process... when you turn that volume up, the signal does change. The method that signal is being sent through a medium is going to change. Thus sound quality is going to change.
11 Second Club
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,173
Likes: 1
From: NE Ohio
At some point the return isn't worth the cost. In a car, a $50 RCA is usually fine. There are too many other noises (road, engine) that will keep you from noticing a difference when switching from a $50 cable to a $500 cable. In home audio, where there are room treatments, vibration isolation, and equally expensive equipment ($50,000+) there is a noticable different in the sound between cheap and higher quality cables.
Originally Posted by dragonrage
While I can't definitively call BS on that, I will say that it was most likely (IMO) in your head and a double blind ABX test would be required to prove it.
My Firehawk used tweeters from a $3,000 home speaker from Infinity, and the midrange from the $100,000 JBL Synthesis home theater system, and a prototype processor that you can't even buy yet. But it's all connected with basic wireing from partsexpress.com .
mike
I can honestly say that I was able to hear an audible difference in my car when I switched to some good Rockford rca's, but there is still engine noise. I will be trying Monster xln404 and sub rca's as they are supposed to be the best noise canceling rca's around. They look pretty good too.
TECH Fanatic
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 1,241
Likes: 0
From: MD
Cable is cable. If you go to extremes yes it can cause tonal issues with analog signals. By extremes I mean using a 40 foot rca cable of like 24 guage and comparing it to a decent cable. Compare any decent mid or high priced cables and they will sound the same.
What really cracks me up are the audio nuts who think high end digital cables make a difference. (rolls eyes)
What really cracks me up are the audio nuts who think high end digital cables make a difference. (rolls eyes)
