What causes A4's to break?
What causes A4's to break? I am looking into modding my car. I have a TR224 / TCI 3500 right now, and have plans for lt's, ls6 intake then heads. As I am thinking more about it, I have been thinking about FAST intake, bigger cam etc. Then I realized I could be putting out over 400rwhp - sounds like the stock a4 wouldn't take kindly to that! Would for some reason the TR224 be more gentle on the stock a4 than the TREX? What are your thoughts?
Tech Resident
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,117
Likes: 3
From: Philly
Originally Posted by nomorews6
I am looking into modding my car. I have a TR224 / TCI 3500 right now, and have plans for lt's, ls6 intake then heads. As I am thinking more about it, I have been thinking about FAST intake, bigger cam etc. Then I realized I could be putting out over 400rwhp - sounds like the stock a4 wouldn't take kindly to that! Would for some reason the TR224 be more gentle on the stock a4 than the TREX? What are your thoughts?
1.) RPM's
2.) power
3.) heat
probably in that order. if you run that through a stock A4 with STOCK SHIFT POINTS, it may last a while. if you run that through an A4 with shift points over 6,000 rpm's, i give it a week.
Originally Posted by ChocoTaco369
what causes A4's to break?
1.) RPM's
2.) power
3.) heat
probably in that order. if you run that through a stock A4 with STOCK SHIFT POINTS, it may last a while. if you run that through an A4 with shift points over 6,000 rpm's, i give it a week.
1.) RPM's
2.) power
3.) heat
probably in that order. if you run that through a stock A4 with STOCK SHIFT POINTS, it may last a while. if you run that through an A4 with shift points over 6,000 rpm's, i give it a week.
Tech Resident
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,117
Likes: 3
From: Philly
Originally Posted by camscam02
umm i would say heat more than anything and miles ofcourse! keep good fluid! but as for the statement above with shiftpoints over 6000! mine are at 6800 and i have 40 passes or so on the car and i daily drive it! just keep good fluid in it!
I've got several friends running high RPM's (H/C) through stock trannies and zero issues. Does it contribute? I'm not saying it doesn't, but my personal experience is no. It takes more than a theory to convince me. Heat is an obvious killer, but like Choco said, that doesn't really become a factor until you introduce a TC.
Heat is a long term minor issue , torque and rpm are the killers , heat will eventually harden seals ect but thats all
__________________
Trending Topics
Tech Resident
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,117
Likes: 3
From: Philly
the point i'm trying to make is that a stock trans probably runs hotter than a stalled, cooled trans. stock trans are known to last 100k-150k miles in a bone stock or near stock f-body all the time, so the point i'm trying to make is, if your car has a tranny cooler on it, heat shouldn't be much of an issue for you, at least no more of an issue than it is for a stock trans, and they are known to live well past the 100k mark.
now, you'll be highly modified, so heat should be the least of your worries. your biggest worry is RPM's for sure, then power. just note that the higher in the rpm range you make your power, the sooner your 4L60E will go boom. it's not unheard of for it to start slipping after a single, solitary WOT blast.
make sure you have the money for a built tranny before you get this done. IMO, you should get a tranny before you even do these mods. that way, you can sell your stock 4L60E to cut the costs or you can keep it around in case the built one goes in the distant future.
now, you'll be highly modified, so heat should be the least of your worries. your biggest worry is RPM's for sure, then power. just note that the higher in the rpm range you make your power, the sooner your 4L60E will go boom. it's not unheard of for it to start slipping after a single, solitary WOT blast.
make sure you have the money for a built tranny before you get this done. IMO, you should get a tranny before you even do these mods. that way, you can sell your stock 4L60E to cut the costs or you can keep it around in case the built one goes in the distant future.
LS1 Tech Stories
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
6 Common C5 Corvette Failures and What's Involved In Repairing Them
Pouria Savadkouei
Retro Modern Bandit Pontiac Trans AM Comes With Burt Reynolds' Autograph
Verdad Gallardo
Top 10 Greatest Cadillac V Series Performance Models Ever, Ranked
Pouria Savadkouei
Top 10 Most Powerful Chevy Trucks Ever Made!
Hennessey's New Supercharged Silverado ZR2 Has 700 HP
Verdad Gallardo
Coachbuilt N2A Anteros Is an LS2-Powered C6 Corvette In Italian Clothes
Verdad Gallardo
Awesome K5 Blazer Restomod Comes With C7 Corvette Power
Verdad Gallardo
10 Camaros You Should Never Buy
10 LS Engine Myths That Refuse to Die
Verdad Gallardo Ah allmost a qoute of my common statment , tranny is the foundation if i was doing a build up it would be my first move not as glorious or fun but sure makes the mods more fun when its not dying the next day
__________________
Mine has lasted with a 4K stall, Trans Go shift kit, and tranny cooler. I spray 200hp out of the hole and do not spray through the shifts. The shift rpm is set at 6800rpm. I know it is just a matter of time before it goes. But I don't care. I want to get all I can out of this stock tranny before I drop 3K for a built one.
12 Second Club
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 142
Likes: 0
From: Dallas, TX
Originally Posted by performabuilt
Heat is a long term minor issue ,torque and rpm are the killers , heat will eventually harden seals ect but thats all
as long as you have a cooler, heat is not an issue. rpm's are not an issue. its torque and time. ive heard of people with a 4000 stall spraying and the tranny lasting two years. ive heard of stock ones going out. just a matter of time.
Tech Resident
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,117
Likes: 3
From: Philly
Originally Posted by JustAnIlluzion
it's heat, I know many a4 ls1s that have raised their shift points and are doing fine so far.
So how do you explain the multitude of people who have spun their stock trannies to 6500-6800 RPM's with no issues whatsoever? Granted, there are people who have done it and blown the tranny almost immediately, but enough have had success going against what you are saying. I don't believe the proof is there. And many builders stand by the heat argument. How long do you think a stalled tranny without a cooler will last? My bet is much shorter than a cammed A4 that spins to 6800.
I personally think DRIVING HABITS break a4's more than power or rpms.....stock engines tear up trannies when the wrong person is driving....I have made well over 500 rwhp on N20 and stock trans....In other words....driving 50 mph and nailing it while the tranny drops from "lockup" down to 2nd. equals HUGE stress load on clutches and rest of internals..or doin a "top end" run...shifting from 3rd to 4th gear under WOT at 130 plus equals toasted 3-4 clutch pack....never changing fluid...etc.. 
Not saying that a stock A4 will live forever behind 500 plus hp...and 4000 rpm launches but knowing how the tranny operates and responsible care taking will definantly increase the life of it.... 
Not saying that a stock A4 will live forever behind 500 plus hp...and 4000 rpm launches but knowing how the tranny operates and responsible care taking will definantly increase the life of it.... Tech Resident
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,117
Likes: 3
From: Philly
Originally Posted by 99Hawk262
So how do you explain the multitude of people who have spun their stock trannies to 6500-6800 RPM's with no issues whatsoever?
it's also important to note that they may not be going WOT much. you're only going to touch those 6000+ shift points when you go WOT. if you never race your car and never go over 6000 rpm's, it's not going to matter.
Originally Posted by 99Hawk262
Granted, there are people who have done it and blown the tranny almost immediately, but enough have had success going against what you are saying. I don't believe the proof is there. And many builders stand by the heat argument. How long do you think a stalled tranny without a cooler will last? My bet is much shorter than a cammed A4 that spins to 6800.
proof of this is that there are plenty of people making 400rwhp with a forced induction setup and stock shift points and their tranny lasts a while. talk to the FI guys. a cammed car with raised shift points and a lesser rwhp rating will kill a 4L60E faster than an FI guy making more rwhp and stock shift points.
Heat is a slow killer. RPM and torque are instant killers. Get a part that is just barely within manufacturing tolarance and load it with more force and spin it to 6800 and watch it fly apart. Like Choco, I have had trans builders tell me that going over 6400 is really tough on them.
Based upon my experience, I think it is torque that is the bigger killer. You see guys on the spray with a stock cam chew up these trannies and they're not spinning higher than 6200. I think you see more burnt clutches and trashed bands then hard part breaks. Guys with stalls and drag tires are really loading the drivetrain.
The final killer on H&C cars is tuning. Improper line pressure resulting in too little or too much slip burns clutches or adds shock on every shift.
Based upon my experience, I think it is torque that is the bigger killer. You see guys on the spray with a stock cam chew up these trannies and they're not spinning higher than 6200. I think you see more burnt clutches and trashed bands then hard part breaks. Guys with stalls and drag tires are really loading the drivetrain.
The final killer on H&C cars is tuning. Improper line pressure resulting in too little or too much slip burns clutches or adds shock on every shift.