Stock vs Aftermarket ECU for swap
#1
Teching In
Thread Starter
Stock vs Aftermarket ECU for swap
Hello all! I'm currently in the planning/parts gathering phase of my project. It will be a 5.3/T56 powered '71 Nova. I've been reading the great info here for awhile and I have soaked up a lot. Trying to decide if better to run stock based, modified harness and ecu or something aftermarket like the Holley HP or Fast EZ-EFI LS setup. I've already gotten an LS6 intake and injectors as well as the 5.3 and T56. There will be a head/cam swap but I wanted to wait until I had the engine installed and fired up. Any advice on the fuel injection system choices?
#3
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (7)
If you aren't afraid of doing your own tuning, then the Holley HP system is a great value. You get the tuning software, harness, ECU, and most importantly, a wideband O2. As Slow Sedan pointed out, by the time you add up all the OEM parts, the cost is about a wash. And after witnessing how painful it is to tune a car with EFILive, I would never want to tune a stock computer.
I run the Dominator on my Cougar, mostly because I am using dual DBW throttle bodies.
Andrew
I run the Dominator on my Cougar, mostly because I am using dual DBW throttle bodies.
Andrew
#4
TECH Apprentice
I went with the stock ecu and hp tuners... its a bitch. Nothing is more frustrating than having the tools to do something and not know how to use it. Im literally going nuts trying to figure out how to use the software and manipulate the thousands of tables.Go with something more user friendly like holley. Hope that helps
#5
Teching In
Thread Starter
Thanks! I was thinking along the lines of Holley because it does have a self learn feature to get it pretty close. I've never tuned anything before and don't think I want the headache of learning.
#6
Not sure I'm in line with the cost assumptions you guys are using for GM ECU and harness. You can go to any local LKQ and buy a truck harness and ECU for under $100. Rewire it yourself and then have a professional dyno tune it so you are not frustrated with the learning curve associated with EFI live.
#7
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (7)
Will the Holley system control a 4L80E transmission?
Not sure I'm in line with the cost assumptions you guys are using for GM ECU and harness. You can go to any local LKQ and buy a truck harness and ECU for under $100. Rewire it yourself and then have a professional dyno tune it so you are not frustrated with the learning curve associated with EFI live.
Not sure I'm in line with the cost assumptions you guys are using for GM ECU and harness. You can go to any local LKQ and buy a truck harness and ECU for under $100. Rewire it yourself and then have a professional dyno tune it so you are not frustrated with the learning curve associated with EFI live.
Andrew
Trending Topics
#10
10 Second Club
iTrader: (10)
I think it depends on your long term goals. Are you going to be changing combinations often or adding a power adder in the near future? If yes, then a system like the Holley is the way to go. If not, then the stock system and a good tuner is really all that is required. That being said, I have done a lot of research and the Holley systems have overwhelmingly positive feedback where many of the FAST systems do not.
#14
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (1)
Ecu
I'm 73 and have no background in electronics. Years ago I put a tuned port in my '50 Chevy, factory ECU then an LT1 in my 33 ******, again factory ECU. Got interested in Megasquirt. Thought I knew a little about F.I. and purchased the Megasquirt 2 which required assembly. Only took several nights to put it together and learned lots about f.i. and electronics in general. There is so much info on the Megasquirt sites that it's like drinking from a fire hose. Cost back then was $247 but now they have a plug and play system for just about any application. I used the unit I put together to start and run an LT1 on a test stand. Pure joy going from a box of parts to a running engine. Firmware is free, software is free, tuning program is free (neat dashboards) and tech support is free. Think the products are at www.diyautotune.com.