View Poll Results: Drive by Wire or Cable Pull throttle body
Drive by Wire
54
48.21%
Cable Pull
58
51.79%
Voters: 112. You may not vote on this poll
Drive by Wire or Throttle Cable
Thar's only because you had to install the TAC module already, which isn't required for DBC. You need to install it with DBW, even if you don't want cruise
just saying my own opinion here and its already been stated 20 times. DBC all the way. instant response, full control, nothing to worry about, oh did i say instant throttle response? i drive new GMs with DBW and i hate it, i could never get used to it. delay, pisses me off, and im a guy who when i want to go, i want to go, i dont want the computer to tell me when i can go.
I rolled this issue around with myself for a while and came to the conclusion that since my car is mostly a street car, I do plan on cruising from time to time in, with a little autocrossing and maybe hit the strip from time to time, DBW made the most sense. My ECM is already DBW, I have both kinds of throttle bodies (LS1/LQ4 style), and I plan on going L92 heads with a 90mm LS3 intake in the long run, so it was a lot cheaper to grab a used LS2 throttle body vs finding an aftermarket 90mm DBC throttle body.
Also, aren't the corvette DBW throttle bodies faster than the truck ones? It was my understanding they had bigger motors in them or something allowing them to be a little faster. I admit I would go with a cable if I wasn't going to use cruise control, or if it was primarily more of a race car.
Also, aren't the corvette DBW throttle bodies faster than the truck ones? It was my understanding they had bigger motors in them or something allowing them to be a little faster. I admit I would go with a cable if I wasn't going to use cruise control, or if it was primarily more of a race car.
Why is everyone afraid of using cruise on a cable TB?
Its very simple and well covered
https://ls1tech.com/forums/conversio...driven-tb.html
http://www.thirdgen.org/techboard/lt...e-ltx-lsx.html
Its very simple and well covered
https://ls1tech.com/forums/conversio...driven-tb.html
http://www.thirdgen.org/techboard/lt...e-ltx-lsx.html
Thread Starter
Teching In
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 43
Likes: 0
just saying my own opinion here and its already been stated 20 times. DBC all the way. instant response, full control, nothing to worry about, oh did i say instant throttle response? i drive new GMs with DBW and i hate it, i could never get used to it. delay, pisses me off, and im a guy who when i want to go, i want to go, i dont want the computer to tell me when i can go.
The non turbo Solstice ain't so bad either.So, Tunercat has more control of the DBW than HPT. Can anyone comment on EFiLive's DBW tuning capabilities?
The cost debate is neither here nor there. If you start with a DBW system it sure does seem like an expensive PITA to swap to cable. Vice versa.
What pedals are you using? I'm using an '05 Corvette Pedal and it isn't any bigger than any DBC pedal:
I have seen bigger pedals though ...
I've driven DBW vehicles that seems like the throttle was way crisper than DBC. In fact on the 4x4 boards many of the complaints are that DBW is TOO sensitive.
I'm using DBW on my current buggy project because that's what my engine came with. I highly doubt I'll ever swap it out, especially if I can tune the performance of it. What about changing those tables in HPT causes the ECM to fry???
DBW has so many redundant failsafes its ridiculous. Have you EVER heard of a GM DBW setup defaulting to full throttle? I've only heard of one or two failiures in aftermarket applications and in both of them it defaulted to zero throttle. Here's a video of a cable throttle rig defaultign to full throttle and what can happen:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Efsfw...next=1&index=9
The driver was knocked out and the frame crumpled, pinning the cable against the intake and causing an uncontrolled full throttle situation. This particular incident would have been impossible with DBW.
Currently my vote is for DBw. Not having to fool with cables and linkage during a complete ground up buggy fab is nice.
I AM VERY INTERESTED IN SEEING SOME DBW CALIBRATION TABLES in either HPT or anythign else. Just some screen shots would be nice. I plan on getting HPT whent he time comes.
J. J.
What pedals are you using? I'm using an '05 Corvette Pedal and it isn't any bigger than any DBC pedal:
I have seen bigger pedals though ...
I've driven DBW vehicles that seems like the throttle was way crisper than DBC. In fact on the 4x4 boards many of the complaints are that DBW is TOO sensitive.
I'm using DBW on my current buggy project because that's what my engine came with. I highly doubt I'll ever swap it out, especially if I can tune the performance of it. What about changing those tables in HPT causes the ECM to fry???
DBW has so many redundant failsafes its ridiculous. Have you EVER heard of a GM DBW setup defaulting to full throttle? I've only heard of one or two failiures in aftermarket applications and in both of them it defaulted to zero throttle. Here's a video of a cable throttle rig defaultign to full throttle and what can happen:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Efsfw...next=1&index=9
The driver was knocked out and the frame crumpled, pinning the cable against the intake and causing an uncontrolled full throttle situation. This particular incident would have been impossible with DBW.
Currently my vote is for DBw. Not having to fool with cables and linkage during a complete ground up buggy fab is nice.
I AM VERY INTERESTED IN SEEING SOME DBW CALIBRATION TABLES in either HPT or anythign else. Just some screen shots would be nice. I plan on getting HPT whent he time comes.
J. J.
LS1 Tech Stories
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
Topdon ONE vs. Artidiag 800 BT2: Which is the Diagnostic Tablet For You?
Pouria Savadkouei
Gas Monkey Built a 6-Wheel Ferrari Testarossa With a Corvette LT4 Engine
Verdad Gallardo
7 Most Reliable High-Performance Engines GM Has Ever Built
Verdad Gallardo
Amazing '71 Camaro Restomod Is Modern Muscle Car Under the Skin
Verdad Gallardo
6 Common C5 Corvette Failures and What's Involved In Repairing Them
Pouria Savadkouei
Retro Modern Bandit Pontiac Trans AM Comes With Burt Reynolds' Autograph
Verdad Gallardo
Top 10 Greatest Cadillac V Series Performance Models Ever, Ranked
Pouria Savadkouei
Top 10 Most Powerful Chevy Trucks Ever Made!
Hennessey's New Supercharged Silverado ZR2 Has 700 HP
Verdad Gallardo
Teching In
Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
I was wondering the same thing. While it does not say one way or another I did find this interesting as well as wiring diagrams for different vehicles:
http://chevythunder.com/drive_by_wire.htm
I think I am going to go with DBW if I can make it work.
http://chevythunder.com/drive_by_wire.htm
I think I am going to go with DBW if I can make it work.
TECH Fanatic
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 1,081
Likes: 8
From: Atlanta, Ga
I have used DBW in this car with 2 different setups. I now have the 92MM LS3 style TB and 06 GTO pedal. I have often heard of the throttle lag but I have to say I have not experienced it in this application. I have had DBW in lots of daily drivers and never had any sort of issue.
DBW vs cable I'm putting DBW in my '39. It has been a PITA because of failing to limp home mode but still want to use DBW. The throttle pedal is longer with less travel than a usual aftermarket street rod cable pedal. The pedal lends itself to my application much better than a cable pedal. Got a nice smooth firewall too.
Find it a little funny some people "don't want no stinkin electronic pedal" yet they fully embrace fuel injeciton. Of course it took a while for more people to start using F.I. just as DBW will.
Find it a little funny some people "don't want no stinkin electronic pedal" yet they fully embrace fuel injeciton. Of course it took a while for more people to start using F.I. just as DBW will.
TECH Resident
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 800
Likes: 1
From: Simi VAlley,CA
I like the response of my cable pulled throttle...but then when I started my LS project in 1997 "fly-by-wire" was in it's infancy as was the LS design. I have electronic throttle vehicles (2008 HHR SS) and I don't see any problem, it works pretty well...especially in the launch mode.
My throttle still works flawless since I did the Victor Jr. conversion too, maybe even more so. The guy who did the speed density tune on it commented on how awesome the car responded, specifically right off-idle.
My throttle still works flawless since I did the Victor Jr. conversion too, maybe even more so. The guy who did the speed density tune on it commented on how awesome the car responded, specifically right off-idle.
I use the DBW and love it. I had Speartech build the wiring, including for the cruise control, into my harness. All I had to find to make cruise control work was a turn signal stalk with the right switch. I also have a 2001 Silverado with DBW and I have never noticed any lag with either one of them.
Pat
Pat
On The Tree
Joined: Aug 2013
Posts: 188
Likes: 0
I dont have any issues with this DBW setup. I have driven numerous driveby wire setups that were very non linear, and some (bmw) you cant drive the car 35mph, the throttle response for the first 15% in those cars is totally outa wack. Lots of cars have horrible throttle feel for a DBW setup, but this one isnt too bad really. I like the lack of idle control valve and cruise module. The ease of plugging in the pedal. I haven't spent much time in the olds I did the swap in yet, but so far im pretty pleased, even with my 'fabbed' pedal. Some careful measuring and angle placement, the stock pedal is right where it should be, had good travel, is WOT when it hits the carpet, all in all it came out nice. Only think I had to do was remove that extra coil return spring thats on the truck pedal. There are 2 springs already on it, one on each side, that last spring was #3, and because this pedal setup is shorter than the truck, less leverage, that spring made it feel too stiff. Couldn't rest your foot on it to keep to steady with out any effort.
So my vote is for a driver or cruiser, something you wanna use all the time DBW, for a race car, purpose built I would think cable is the way to go.
So my vote is for a driver or cruiser, something you wanna use all the time DBW, for a race car, purpose built I would think cable is the way to go.
Teching In
Joined: Mar 2016
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
I have a few vehicles that have both DBW and DBC. I can say that driving a vehicle with DBW - you loose the touch. Shifts are not accurate. I have stalled the car with DBW a few times as when Im pushing the pedal down - nothing happens and then sometimes learches. Its been to the dealer for a calibration and they say "thats as good as it gets".
I will only do cable or manual operated stuff from here on out.
As for looks, I personally dont think a motor hanging off the side of a throttle body with a few wires poking out looks good at all. I have made numerous DBC set ups look bitchen, and same with rod and bellcrank set ups.
You can easily put a cruse control set up on any system for around $175 if thats a must have...
I will only do cable or manual operated stuff from here on out.
As for looks, I personally dont think a motor hanging off the side of a throttle body with a few wires poking out looks good at all. I have made numerous DBC set ups look bitchen, and same with rod and bellcrank set ups.
You can easily put a cruse control set up on any system for around $175 if thats a must have...
Registered User
Joined: May 2016
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Drive ByWire Pedal Fault I have an 08 z06 corvette. It has been converted by RPM Transmissions to a 4L65E Automatic Transmission. It just started this problem. It will show an engine light and Traction control light and go into limp mode. Code shows Pedal fault. Cleared code drove about 30 miles and did it again. Replaced Throttle Pedal, Maybe drove 30-50 miles and did it again. I have cleared the code but I know the question is when not if. Anyone had this problem or how hard is it to convert from DBW to DBC. HELP!!
TECH Fanatic
Joined: May 2016
Posts: 1,292
Likes: 436
From: St. Louis
I've driven both and I really prefer the cable to the dbw throttle. I've got a a sensitive foot and I like the simple reliability of it. I'm telling the engine what to do not the computer. Yes, I'm an old soul.
TECH Fanatic
Joined: May 2016
Posts: 1,292
Likes: 436
From: St. Louis
I would try and search the forums, I don't know exactly all you would need as all c5-c6's are dbw but it would be worth it. I imagine that there would have to be a little fabrication involved. Someone more familiar with the tuning software needs to chime in. Maybe start a thread in the conversions or fabrication forums?