Advice sought for my "Professionally Built" '66 Nova
#21
Torque Logs
I hope this works, attached are the logs. It's wet out and flooring it should have sent me sideways and into a ditch, but really didn't even break the tires loose. I'll see what some quick Excel graphs look like and if anything jumps out at me with ZERO experience at this.
I couldn't upload more than 100Kb text file, so the csv has an .efi extension to allow upload. If this is a problem (moderators), please let me know how best to accomplish.
Thanks,
Bryan
I couldn't upload more than 100Kb text file, so the csv has an .efi extension to allow upload. If this is a problem (moderators), please let me know how best to accomplish.
Thanks,
Bryan
#23
9 Second Club
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: on the dyno tuning in MD
Posts: 2,583
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
If you had rust in the filter, you may need to get the injectors cleaned! or, throw another set in to find out if it is the problem. May want to pull some plugs and see how they look - clogged injector(s) should show up on plugs.
#24
Staging Lane
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Bakersfield, CA
Posts: 84
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I build cars professionally for 9 years and after reading your thread I have a few questions.
#1 How did the builder get the money? Unless you have a big purchase (engine, gearbox etc) there shouldn't be any money spent for work that hasn't been done. If your builder isn't financially healthy enough to do a week or two of work and then bill you for it ask yourself why. I did a weeks worth of work and billed every friday. The customer looked at what was done, got an itemized receipt as well as a logbook for time. The bill was paid to zero and we started another week.
#2 why would you think you will get your money back for a car you paid to have custom built? Custom building a car is expensive because they are building it to suit your wants. Unless the buyer is impatient and has too much money why would they pay the cost to build a custom car for you rather than build their own? In my experience, unless your car is very desirable you will be lucky to get 70 cents on the dollar.
In my opinion if you find someone who can tune you will spend less than modifying the car to fit a carb and it will be worth more for resale.
#1 How did the builder get the money? Unless you have a big purchase (engine, gearbox etc) there shouldn't be any money spent for work that hasn't been done. If your builder isn't financially healthy enough to do a week or two of work and then bill you for it ask yourself why. I did a weeks worth of work and billed every friday. The customer looked at what was done, got an itemized receipt as well as a logbook for time. The bill was paid to zero and we started another week.
#2 why would you think you will get your money back for a car you paid to have custom built? Custom building a car is expensive because they are building it to suit your wants. Unless the buyer is impatient and has too much money why would they pay the cost to build a custom car for you rather than build their own? In my experience, unless your car is very desirable you will be lucky to get 70 cents on the dollar.
In my opinion if you find someone who can tune you will spend less than modifying the car to fit a carb and it will be worth more for resale.
#25
Thanks,
Bryan
#26
I build cars professionally for 9 years and after reading your thread I have a few questions.
#1 How did the builder get the money? Unless you have a big purchase (engine, gearbox etc) there shouldn't be any money spent for work that hasn't been done. If your builder isn't financially healthy enough to do a week or two of work and then bill you for it ask yourself why. I did a weeks worth of work and billed every friday. The customer looked at what was done, got an itemized receipt as well as a logbook for time. The bill was paid to zero and we started another week.
#2 why would you think you will get your money back for a car you paid to have custom built? Custom building a car is expensive because they are building it to suit your wants. Unless the buyer is impatient and has too much money why would they pay the cost to build a custom car for you rather than build their own? In my experience, unless your car is very desirable you will be lucky to get 70 cents on the dollar.
In my opinion if you find someone who can tune you will spend less than modifying the car to fit a carb and it will be worth more for resale.
#1 How did the builder get the money? Unless you have a big purchase (engine, gearbox etc) there shouldn't be any money spent for work that hasn't been done. If your builder isn't financially healthy enough to do a week or two of work and then bill you for it ask yourself why. I did a weeks worth of work and billed every friday. The customer looked at what was done, got an itemized receipt as well as a logbook for time. The bill was paid to zero and we started another week.
#2 why would you think you will get your money back for a car you paid to have custom built? Custom building a car is expensive because they are building it to suit your wants. Unless the buyer is impatient and has too much money why would they pay the cost to build a custom car for you rather than build their own? In my experience, unless your car is very desirable you will be lucky to get 70 cents on the dollar.
In my opinion if you find someone who can tune you will spend less than modifying the car to fit a carb and it will be worth more for resale.
As far as item #2, he "promised" me a professional estimate and told me all along my Nova SS would be around $45-$50K. A nice Nova WAS my dream car, now I hate looking at it in my driveway. I'm not prepared to give it away, but once it's running right, I'll put for $22.5K firm (about .70 to the dollar) and hope it sells.
Thanks for your thoughts, seeing as I was stationed at Edwards AFB in So Cal, wish I'd found you instead!
Bryan
#28
TECH Regular
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Jacksonville, FL
Posts: 443
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Unfortunately, we all must learn lessons in life, and the guy believes it's his lot to teach them. I paid $28K up front (yeah, I'm an idiot), but being out of the country for 3 years (Okinawa) and a year deployed, made it impossible to check progress. I have a contract, but after talking to JAG (military lawyers) and they researched the contract, car, and guy...I was advised that even if I won the lawsuit, I'd probably not collect anything from this guy and be out a few grand more.
As far as item #2, he "promised" me a professional estimate and told me all along my Nova SS would be around $45-$50K. A nice Nova WAS my dream car, now I hate looking at it in my driveway. I'm not prepared to give it away, but once it's running right, I'll put for $22.5K firm (about .70 to the dollar) and hope it sells.
Thanks for your thoughts, seeing as I was stationed at Edwards AFB in So Cal, wish I'd found you instead!
Bryan
As far as item #2, he "promised" me a professional estimate and told me all along my Nova SS would be around $45-$50K. A nice Nova WAS my dream car, now I hate looking at it in my driveway. I'm not prepared to give it away, but once it's running right, I'll put for $22.5K firm (about .70 to the dollar) and hope it sells.
Thanks for your thoughts, seeing as I was stationed at Edwards AFB in So Cal, wish I'd found you instead!
Bryan
that sucks man, i hate it when you cant trust someone especially 28k worth. i get pissed at under a 1k i cant even imagine what youre going through, best thing is to drive away any future business for him
#29
Did you see the logs I posted? Is there any value in those or does anything jump out at you as problematic?
Thanks,
Bryan
#31
Plug pics
Pulled the plugs this morning and they are NGK TR55's. I'm no expert on reading plugs, but nothing jumps out at me (all about the same). Here's the pics:
From left to right, cylinders 7, 5, 3, 1.
Same plugs - view from top:
From left to right, cylinders 2, 4, 6, 8.
Same plugs - view from top:
Lastly, I figured I'd check the gaps. They varied slightly between .050 and .057.
Thanks,
Bryan
From left to right, cylinders 7, 5, 3, 1.
Same plugs - view from top:
From left to right, cylinders 2, 4, 6, 8.
Same plugs - view from top:
Lastly, I figured I'd check the gaps. They varied slightly between .050 and .057.
Thanks,
Bryan
Last edited by yerny; 10-14-2013 at 09:29 AM. Reason: Typo's the plug part #
#32
My side project
Art Morrison chassis is assembled w/ '05 LQ4 and T-56 installed. Doing it right and NOBODY is touching it except us.
My first test drive:
Thanks,
Bryan
#33
9 Second Club
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: on the dyno tuning in MD
Posts: 2,583
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Bryan,
I enlarged the log file you posted so I could see it better, and it looks like it might be running lean. From what I can see of the LTFTs, they reached as high as 38%! Also, the O2 readings under load are extremely low... One thing I thought of - the pump setup they had on it originally, did it have a regulator? Thing is, if you have a regulator, that requires the injector tables in the tune to be different than the injector tables for cars with an in-tank regulator (like the original GTO donor car would have had). So, my thinking is that the tune may be out of whack if it has the original GTO injector tables in it. It would need a tune to fix that...
I enlarged the log file you posted so I could see it better, and it looks like it might be running lean. From what I can see of the LTFTs, they reached as high as 38%! Also, the O2 readings under load are extremely low... One thing I thought of - the pump setup they had on it originally, did it have a regulator? Thing is, if you have a regulator, that requires the injector tables in the tune to be different than the injector tables for cars with an in-tank regulator (like the original GTO donor car would have had). So, my thinking is that the tune may be out of whack if it has the original GTO injector tables in it. It would need a tune to fix that...
Last edited by BLK02WS6; 10-14-2013 at 07:17 PM.
#34
The original setup when I received my car was the stock '66 Nova tank w/ a Walbro external pump feeding a Corvette filter. It was full of crap after ~100 miles so I pulled it and changed to the Spectra tank with a new corvette filter. I also cleaned the rails and manually the injectors.
I ordered a Fuel Pressure (FP) gauge that comes with a hose so I can see the FP while driving. I guess it could also be running lean because of a pump issue vs. the tune. I should be able to confirm/deny the FP under load by Wed or Thurs of this week.
If I've got a fuel pressure issue, I'll pick up a Walbro 255 pump and put in between my current in-tank fuel pump and the vette filter. If not, then I wouldn't doubt it's an issue with the tune. Like I said, I've NEVER seen this car run worth a crap.
Where can I find a good primer on how to read these log files (O2, FTs etc)? If I can get this FI running right, I'd love to understand the data so I can fix on my own in the future without heavily relying on ls1tech.com's experts.
Thanks,
Bryan
Thanks,
Bryan
I ordered a Fuel Pressure (FP) gauge that comes with a hose so I can see the FP while driving. I guess it could also be running lean because of a pump issue vs. the tune. I should be able to confirm/deny the FP under load by Wed or Thurs of this week.
If I've got a fuel pressure issue, I'll pick up a Walbro 255 pump and put in between my current in-tank fuel pump and the vette filter. If not, then I wouldn't doubt it's an issue with the tune. Like I said, I've NEVER seen this car run worth a crap.
Where can I find a good primer on how to read these log files (O2, FTs etc)? If I can get this FI running right, I'd love to understand the data so I can fix on my own in the future without heavily relying on ls1tech.com's experts.
Thanks,
Bryan
Thanks,
Bryan
#35
#37
9 Second Club
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: on the dyno tuning in MD
Posts: 2,583
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
The original setup when I received my car was the stock '66 Nova tank w/ a Walbro external pump feeding a Corvette filter. It was full of crap after ~100 miles so I pulled it and changed to the Spectra tank with a new corvette filter. I also cleaned the rails and manually the injectors.
I ordered a Fuel Pressure (FP) gauge that comes with a hose so I can see the FP while driving. I guess it could also be running lean because of a pump issue vs. the tune. I should be able to confirm/deny the FP under load by Wed or Thurs of this week.
If I've got a fuel pressure issue, I'll pick up a Walbro 255 pump and put in between my current in-tank fuel pump and the vette filter. If not, then I wouldn't doubt it's an issue with the tune. Like I said, I've NEVER seen this car run worth a crap.
Where can I find a good primer on how to read these log files (O2, FTs etc)? If I can get this FI running right, I'd love to understand the data so I can fix on my own in the future without heavily relying on ls1tech.com's experts.
Thanks,
Bryan
I ordered a Fuel Pressure (FP) gauge that comes with a hose so I can see the FP while driving. I guess it could also be running lean because of a pump issue vs. the tune. I should be able to confirm/deny the FP under load by Wed or Thurs of this week.
If I've got a fuel pressure issue, I'll pick up a Walbro 255 pump and put in between my current in-tank fuel pump and the vette filter. If not, then I wouldn't doubt it's an issue with the tune. Like I said, I've NEVER seen this car run worth a crap.
Where can I find a good primer on how to read these log files (O2, FTs etc)? If I can get this FI running right, I'd love to understand the data so I can fix on my own in the future without heavily relying on ls1tech.com's experts.
Thanks,
Bryan
There are a few books/DVDs out there on tuning (and logging), but they are kind of pricey. I personally went to the school of hard knocks and did a lot of reading on the internet when I started way back when...
The basics of fuel trims are that they are (+) when adding fuel and (-) when subtracting fuel. They read out in a percentage of fuel added. On a PCM like yours, they only subtract fuel (-) when at part throttle; but they will add fuel (+) at part throttle and WOT. Yours was adding 38% fuel in the beginning of the run you made.
The O2 sensors read .450mv at 14.7 (stoich). They are not real accurate outside of that, but they are a decent indicator. Under load, you should be seeing high .800's to low .900's - yours stayed pretty flat until you let off the throttle, then they jumped up to the highest on the scan (which was .865 for bank 1 and .815 for bank 2). That is an indicator that it is very lean under load.
If the fuel pressure checks out, the smart thing to do would be to pull the tune and see what is in there - a lot can be learned from seeing what they did to the tune (compared to a stock tune). Then get a log on it with a wideband connected and see exactly what is going on. If it just needs tuned, then take care of that.
#38
Thank you very much for your time and advice. I'll start my quest to learn about interpreting the data logs and possible tuning in the future. I should have the fuel pressure gauge tomorrow and I'll try to take it out for a drive if the FP checks out. If it's low, I'll just order a new Walbro 255 without subjecting it to more lean punishment.
Is there any way to pull the tune with just a bluetooth OBD2 adapter? I didn't see anything in the Torque app. Also, what's it cost to get a good tune if that turns out to be my problem?
Thanks,
Bryan
Is there any way to pull the tune with just a bluetooth OBD2 adapter? I didn't see anything in the Torque app. Also, what's it cost to get a good tune if that turns out to be my problem?
Thanks,
Bryan
#40
9 Second Club
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: on the dyno tuning in MD
Posts: 2,583
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
You need tuning software to pull the tune... tuning prices will vary depending if you want a dyno tune or a street tune - for what you need, shop around and see what prices are, but I would say you should be able to get it done for $500 or less...