Harrop 8-throttel intake finaly installed !
#22
I've seen the sticking throttle issue on every thread about these intakes. They are definetly an awesome design, but still rough around the edges. Every person I've seen on here has given up on them.
#23
I am not about to give up on mine yet ! It is a fantastic manifold and the problems do not look to difficult to fix . The most obvious ones are the butterflies which are ( on mine ) not elliptical enough and made out of steel. The linkage to the throttle spindles could also probably do with adjusters on each link to make balancing easier . I assume the Harrop fix is some brass butterflies cut differently but they seem to be quite slow in getting back to me so I may have to get them done myself by a ITB manufacturer here . They say it is easy and cheap which is refreshing and surprising that Harrop have not just stuck some in the post .
#25
With the Air filter on...
With the Air Box on...
Having a better efficiency at least than a Fast 90 hood closed...
Beeing tuned as it's theoretically possible, meaning an ovelap of 32° @ 0.050 idling at 800rpm with zero surging...
Waiting for the snow in August in south Florida...
Christian
#26
I am not about to give up on mine yet ! It is a fantastic manifold and the problems do not look to difficult to fix . The most obvious ones are the butterflies which are ( on mine ) not elliptical enough and made out of steel. The linkage to the throttle spindles could also probably do with adjusters on each link to make balancing easier . I assume the Harrop fix is some brass butterflies cut differently but they seem to be quite slow in getting back to me so I may have to get them done myself by a ITB manufacturer here . They say it is easy and cheap which is refreshing and surprising that Harrop have not just stuck some in the post .
Have you made contact with us yet??
Perhaps I have not connected your Handle here with an email, but we have not had an enquiry about the throttle blade replacement for quite a while.
Please email me via ken@harrop.com.au
Please ensure your return email address is noted ... we had an enquiry (quite a while back) that is from an address that constantly bounces.
#28
#29
TECH Addict
iTrader: (24)
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,608
Likes: 0
From: Webb City, MO...out in the garage
you'll gain all over the powerband. this manifold lets the heads flow whatever they flow basically. there isn't a shared plenum so when the intake valve opens, it has it's own atmosphere to pull air from, almost positive air pressure on top of it at the time it opens. Due to cost, this is not an intake for a stock car, although it would see gains, it would be a massive waste of time not to put this manifold on a higher performance motor....IMHO
#30
you'll gain all over the powerband. this manifold lets the heads flow whatever they flow basically. there isn't a shared plenum so when the intake valve opens, it has it's own atmosphere to pull air from, almost positive air pressure on top of it at the time it opens. Due to cost, this is not an intake for a stock car, although it would see gains, it would be a massive waste of time not to put this manifold on a higher performance motor....IMHO
Do you have any results to provide of the Harrop with Air Filter(s) ON and hood closed, in real driving...very interested...
Christian
#31
And you are wrong on this one...
THERE IS A PLENUM...last results I saw with the two Air Boxes ON (which IS a plenum, one on each side or cylinder bank...) the results were bad...
But I am waiting to be updated about my questions on this Harrop since almost four years...and you might bring some light.
Christian
THERE IS A PLENUM...last results I saw with the two Air Boxes ON (which IS a plenum, one on each side or cylinder bank...) the results were bad...
But I am waiting to be updated about my questions on this Harrop since almost four years...and you might bring some light.
Christian
#33
TECH Addict
iTrader: (24)
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,608
Likes: 0
From: Webb City, MO...out in the garage
And you are wrong on this one...
THERE IS A PLENUM...last results I saw with the two Air Boxes ON (which IS a plenum, one on each side or cylinder bank...) the results were bad...
But I am waiting to be updated about my questions on this Harrop since almost four years...and you might bring some light.
Christian
THERE IS A PLENUM...last results I saw with the two Air Boxes ON (which IS a plenum, one on each side or cylinder bank...) the results were bad...
But I am waiting to be updated about my questions on this Harrop since almost four years...and you might bring some light.
Christian
I'm more than willing to bet that if this intake showed poor results, it was in the tune. They are historically difficult to make perfect, but i've never seen one NOT make phenominal gains, although i'm sure its happened somewhere.
#34
Nothing new is showing on their website
http://www.harrop.com.au/products/intake_systems.html
and if I wanted a racing intake manifold, my choice woudln't be this one...
BTW, let me correct a mistake I did in post #31...there is no plenum on those intakes...plenum is before the TB...
BTW again...what is the AIT with the king of mounting in the picture above
Christian
http://www.harrop.com.au/products/intake_systems.html
and if I wanted a racing intake manifold, my choice woudln't be this one...
BTW, let me correct a mistake I did in post #31...there is no plenum on those intakes...plenum is before the TB...
BTW again...what is the AIT with the king of mounting in the picture above
Christian
#35
TECH Addict
iTrader: (24)
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,608
Likes: 0
From: Webb City, MO...out in the garage
Nothing new is showing on their website
http://www.harrop.com.au/products/intake_systems.html
and if I wanted a racing intake manifold, my choice woudln't be this one...
BTW, let me correct a mistake I did in post #31...there is no plenum on those intakes...plenum is before the TB...
BTW again...what is the AIT with the king of mounting in the picture above
Christian
http://www.harrop.com.au/products/intake_systems.html
and if I wanted a racing intake manifold, my choice woudln't be this one...
BTW, let me correct a mistake I did in post #31...there is no plenum on those intakes...plenum is before the TB...
BTW again...what is the AIT with the king of mounting in the picture above
Christian
I have no idea what's going on in that picture but it DOES work, and it is just a racecar....
#36
In a race car application, having IAT as close as possible of ambient is a huge priority...at least since the end of the 40's...
And managing the sonics and wawes in the air box is definitivally a huge budget in R&D in racing...at least since the early 80's
I don't see those two goals reached in the above combo...
As for tuning those ITB...I don't see the OEM PCM managing the injectors individually...
Christian
#37
TECH Addict
iTrader: (24)
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,608
Likes: 0
From: Webb City, MO...out in the garage
I am just questionning what kind of Intake Air Temperature is obtained with the way the intake is in the picture...
In a race car application, having IAT as close as possible of ambient is a huge priority...at least since the end of the 40's...
And managing the sonics and wawes in the air box is definitivally a huge budget in R&D in racing...at least since the early 80's
I don't see those two goals reached in the above combo...
As for tuning those ITB...I don't see the OEM PCM managing the injectors individually...
Christian
In a race car application, having IAT as close as possible of ambient is a huge priority...at least since the end of the 40's...
And managing the sonics and wawes in the air box is definitivally a huge budget in R&D in racing...at least since the early 80's
I don't see those two goals reached in the above combo...
As for tuning those ITB...I don't see the OEM PCM managing the injectors individually...
Christian
i have a PDF blueprint of the intake showing only final dimensions and a few views of it. i copied the pertinent parts and saved as a .BMP, the PDF and the pic above were sent to me by Michael at Harrop, here it is:
The image didn't turn out quite as i'd hoped, but you can see all the vacuum provisions on the backside and the mounting places for the oem TB sensors on the front side...i'm GUESSING there might be a place for an IAT on there somewhere...but could be wrong.
As for tuning, i know they're very difficult, or can be, and that's why a lot of people don't run them or try and give up. I'm going to give it a shot on my 454 and see what happens. I may even go so far as to trailer the car across the country to have the right person tune it. That may not sound like much to some people on here, but i'm just a broke-*** kid with a $14K engine in a used camaro It's going to take an act of God to get my car running once i finally have all the parts to finish it, which at this point is just the intake, EWP, and a driveshaft that will hold the power.