Thrust bearing gone in 1000kms
#1
Teching In
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thrust bearing gone in 1000kms
Hi all,
Not a happy day here, well proven forged LS6 with a new rebuild (pistons & rings, H bearings mains and rods, GM cam bearings, oil pump, nothing else). Motor worked awesome from minute one! Cold oil pressure 60psi idle and 80psi at 2k rpm. Hot oil pressure 50 idle, 60 at 2000rpm. All looking good........except it was making copper from the start. At 100kms, the filter was full, and the oil "glimmered". I drove it another 600kms (mostly highway), just to see if it would stop. Uhuh, this stuff never gets better. Pulled the pan today and the thrust bearing is toast...on the flywheel side. However, the crank thrust surface looks good, it's not tore up. It's a 5M with a slightly stiffer clutch, but nothing crazy. I have no idea why this happened, but I'm thinking of slipping in another set of #3 bearing sets and see what happens. The motor is in a swap car, and it's removal in not easy. Comments, advice????
Thanks
G.M.
Not a happy day here, well proven forged LS6 with a new rebuild (pistons & rings, H bearings mains and rods, GM cam bearings, oil pump, nothing else). Motor worked awesome from minute one! Cold oil pressure 60psi idle and 80psi at 2k rpm. Hot oil pressure 50 idle, 60 at 2000rpm. All looking good........except it was making copper from the start. At 100kms, the filter was full, and the oil "glimmered". I drove it another 600kms (mostly highway), just to see if it would stop. Uhuh, this stuff never gets better. Pulled the pan today and the thrust bearing is toast...on the flywheel side. However, the crank thrust surface looks good, it's not tore up. It's a 5M with a slightly stiffer clutch, but nothing crazy. I have no idea why this happened, but I'm thinking of slipping in another set of #3 bearing sets and see what happens. The motor is in a swap car, and it's removal in not easy. Comments, advice????
Thanks
G.M.
#2
8 Second Club
iTrader: (3)
Had the same thing happen on mine. Clevite H bearing.
Crank thrust surface looked fine.
My machinist couldn’t remember what the clearance was at assembly. I’m sure it was in spec though, he is very ****.
Mine is an auto trans, but it never had an issue with the stock bearings.
I switched to a forged crank and King bearings. Builders over on YB said King and ACL have a better bearing, particularly the thrust. I believe ACL sells just the thrust set.
I also did a small mod to the bearing to feed some pressurized oil to that surface. You can google it. Takes 30 seconds with a small file.
I know your frustration! Good luck with the fix.
Ron
Crank thrust surface looked fine.
My machinist couldn’t remember what the clearance was at assembly. I’m sure it was in spec though, he is very ****.
Mine is an auto trans, but it never had an issue with the stock bearings.
I switched to a forged crank and King bearings. Builders over on YB said King and ACL have a better bearing, particularly the thrust. I believe ACL sells just the thrust set.
I also did a small mod to the bearing to feed some pressurized oil to that surface. You can google it. Takes 30 seconds with a small file.
I know your frustration! Good luck with the fix.
Ron
#3
Did you assemble the engine and if you did, did you follow the recommended procedure for that bearing ? I forgot to knock the crank back and forth and didn't realize until I had a couple of pistons installed. I did not want to take everything back apart and decided to run it, I ended up with what you have. I did monitor the oil and with no improvement in 1000 miles or so I had to yank it out. Tore it down, cleaned everything, reassembled with new main and rod bearings. 15,000 miles later things are good, oil never looked that bad again and oil filters are clean. Look into that process for seating the thrust bearing and ask yourself if you think you can do that in the platform you have. I threw the time saving dice the first time and lost.
#4
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
Hi all,
Not a happy day here, well proven forged LS6 with a new rebuild (pistons & rings, H bearings mains and rods, GM cam bearings, oil pump, nothing else). Motor worked awesome from minute one! Cold oil pressure 60psi idle and 80psi at 2k rpm. Hot oil pressure 50 idle, 60 at 2000rpm. All looking good........except it was making copper from the start. At 100kms, the filter was full, and the oil "glimmered". I drove it another 600kms (mostly highway), just to see if it would stop. Uhuh, this stuff never gets better. Pulled the pan today and the thrust bearing is toast...on the flywheel side. However, the crank thrust surface looks good, it's not tore up. It's a 5M with a slightly stiffer clutch, but nothing crazy. I have no idea why this happened, but I'm thinking of slipping in another set of #3 bearing sets and see what happens. The motor is in a swap car, and it's removal in not easy. Comments, advice????
Thanks
G.M.
Not a happy day here, well proven forged LS6 with a new rebuild (pistons & rings, H bearings mains and rods, GM cam bearings, oil pump, nothing else). Motor worked awesome from minute one! Cold oil pressure 60psi idle and 80psi at 2k rpm. Hot oil pressure 50 idle, 60 at 2000rpm. All looking good........except it was making copper from the start. At 100kms, the filter was full, and the oil "glimmered". I drove it another 600kms (mostly highway), just to see if it would stop. Uhuh, this stuff never gets better. Pulled the pan today and the thrust bearing is toast...on the flywheel side. However, the crank thrust surface looks good, it's not tore up. It's a 5M with a slightly stiffer clutch, but nothing crazy. I have no idea why this happened, but I'm thinking of slipping in another set of #3 bearing sets and see what happens. The motor is in a swap car, and it's removal in not easy. Comments, advice????
Thanks
G.M.
The following users liked this post:
G Atsma (06-19-2020)
#5
Teching In
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Did you assemble the engine and if you did, did you follow the recommended procedure for that bearing ?
What was thrust clearance set at?
I put another in last night since the crank seemed fine. Lots of assembly lube, surgically clean. I pulled another main cap of, and a rod, the bearings looked perfect. The oil filter did it's job, so there is hope. We'll see how it goes when I fire it up later today.
#6
Moderator
iTrader: (20)
In my experience, something like this is more common with automatic transmissions, but I’ve seen the same thing happen in an engine I built with a manual trans. It had .007” clearance, but there was something with the drivetrain setup that caused the input shaft to load the crank forward when the bellhousing bolts were torqued.
#7
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
GM, what bearings are those in the first pic? Most aftermarket bearings have oiling grooves cut in the thrust face. For instance Clevite has 2 grooves on one side and 3 grooves on the other side. 3 grooves side always goes toward rear (flywheel) side of engine. I just fit another set of mains this morning for a big power build, and went with .0055.
Trending Topics
#8
TECH Addict
iTrader: (47)
GM, what bearings are those in the first pic? Most aftermarket bearings have oiling grooves cut in the thrust face. For instance Clevite has 2 grooves on one side and 3 grooves on the other side. 3 grooves side always goes toward rear (flywheel) side of engine. I just fit another set of mains this morning for a big power build, and went with .0055.
#9
Teching In
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
GM, what bearings are those in the first pic? Most aftermarket bearings have oiling grooves cut in the thrust face. For instance Clevite has 2 grooves on one side and 3 grooves on the other side. 3 grooves side always goes toward rear (flywheel) side of engine. I just fit another set of mains this morning for a big power build, and went with .0055.
I’ve seen the same thing happen in an engine I built with a manual trans. It had .007” clearance, but there was something with the drivetrain setup that caused the input shaft to load the crank forward when the bellhousing bolts were torqued.
#10
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
#12
Teching In
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Followup - Buttoned her up last night, and so far all is well. I drove 45 minutes, no issues, oil pressure was as good, or maybe better than before. We'll see how the oil and filter look after a few hundred kms.
There seems to be some confusion here on the grooves of my bearings. The photo shows no grooves. However, there were groove when installed, 3 facing the rear. The thrust surface is worn down below the groove. They are 2199H.
I'll let you all know how it goes in a few days. Fingers crossed!
Thanks for the advice and comments!
Gord.
There seems to be some confusion here on the grooves of my bearings. The photo shows no grooves. However, there were groove when installed, 3 facing the rear. The thrust surface is worn down below the groove. They are 2199H.
I'll let you all know how it goes in a few days. Fingers crossed!
Thanks for the advice and comments!
Gord.
#14
Teching In
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here's my follow up to this post.....and not the one I hoped for. After replacing the thrust bearing, and driving an easy 350kms, the engine is still making metal, and only copper/brass. Exactly as before. I'm sure the new TB is being consumed. I'm beyond frustrated, I'm done. The car will sit until winter. Unless I say "F" it and just drive the snot out of it as is.
This is the same look as the oil that came out before the thrust bearing replacement. Looks like a brain.
This is what was in the oil that drained out of the filter. I didn't even cut it opened yet.....why bother??
remains in the drain pan
This is the LS6 in a 84 944. We do this because the Porsche motor is unreliable ... how ironic. OK, and for more power, fair point!
This is the same look as the oil that came out before the thrust bearing replacement. Looks like a brain.
This is what was in the oil that drained out of the filter. I didn't even cut it opened yet.....why bother??
remains in the drain pan
This is the LS6 in a 84 944. We do this because the Porsche motor is unreliable ... how ironic. OK, and for more power, fair point!
#15
ModSquad
iTrader: (6)
.005-.006 is fine with a manual trans...what slave setup are you running for the clutch? Something is causing a clearance issue here. Look for input shaft wear at the tip or front of splines.
#16
Teching In
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
what slave setup are you running for the clutch?