Possibly making the Jump
*Whichever comes first from original in-service date, 2005 through 2011 models only. Some 2005 models will not be eligible based on their in-service date. See your dealer for limited warranty details.
If your lookin for one, id suggest making sure it doesn't have a rebuilt trans. GM rebuilt trannies don't have a good track record at all. Also, get an 07-08 for the 100k powertrain warranty.
The fact is, these transmissions fail because of design and execution compromises made by GM in the name of comfort and cost-cutting. They simply can't reliably handle the power of even a stock LS4. I seriously suggest you do a search of the LS4 section for transmission problems, going back maybe 6 months or so and see for yourself the shear number of failures and/or problems.
Anytime you have KR, the knock causing it is doing damage to the engine. Yes, I know, the retarded timing is supposed to protect it, but over the years and miles, it adds up. Also, knock causes carbon build-up inside the combustion chambers and on the pistons, which can cause hot spots and make the motor even more susceptible to knock. It's a viscous cycle. Lastly, a lot of KR can hurt mileage. These engines run a lot of timing to get the mileage and power out of them, and if that timing is retarded often due to knock, your mileage and power will be reduced. The factory tune is also excessively lean, so the combination of the two factors is a recipe for lots of knock.
Sorry to be so long winded, but these are the main issues with the car. There are others like bad wheel-hub assemblies, flaky TPMS sensors, etc., but these could be expected with any car. The trans is the biggest risk, and the tune has the biggest impact on drivability.
If you do buy an LS4 car, I would strongly suggest budgeting for some trans work and a tune of some sort. I would contact Lew (06MonteSS) to discuss the ins and outs of a tune, as he's a great guy to work with. As for the transmission, I'm trying something a bit different to try and prevent mine from dying again. If you want more info, PM me. Or you can call Dave at Triple Edge Performance and learn first hand how badly compromised our trannies are.
Anyway, good luck with your decision.
But please, don't just take my word for it. Do the search I suggested on this site and see for yourself.
For the sake of balance, these are nice, comfortable cruising cars. And the GXPs are exceptional handlers right out of the box for cars their size.
It's just that you gotta take the bad with the good.
But please, don't just take my word for it. Do the search I suggested on this site and see for yourself.
For the sake of balance, these are nice, comfortable cruising cars. And the GXPs are exceptional handlers right out of the box for cars their size.
It's just that you gotta take the bad with the good.
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time
If you like it and have driven other things, then buy it, just keep in the back of your mind, that there is a possibility the trans may fail, doesn't mean it will.
If you like it and have driven other things, then buy it, just keep in the back of your mind, that there is a possibility the trans may fail, doesn't mean it will.
You know, I would have thought that 6 months ago, but as time goes on, and more and more people are posting problems as their miles increase, I'm starting to believe that the failure rate at 100k miles is higher than 50%. I have no data to support this, but it sure seems like there's a new tranny issue every week.
And even if the failure rate is lower, say 25-35% range @100k miles, it's still a 1-in-3 or 1-in-4 chance, which in my opinion, is unacceptably high for such a relatively pricey and new car.
You know, I would have thought that 6 months ago, but as time goes on, and more and more people are posting problems as their miles increase, I'm starting to believe that the failure rate at 100k miles is higher than 50%. I have no data to support this, but it sure seems like there's a new tranny issue every week.
And even if the failure rate is lower, say 25-35% range @100k miles, it's still a 1-in-3 or 1-in-4 chance, which in my opinion, is unacceptably high for such a relatively pricey and new car.
PM returned





