What to look at for upper rpm power loss? Opti? Coil?
#1
What to look at for upper rpm power loss? Opti? Coil?
Info about the car.
stock heads, pacesetter long tubes, ory, loudmouth, no cats. Ws6 hood and airbox (suncoast creations). 219/227@50 .534/.544 camshaft w 1.7 roller rockers. Hardened pushrods with guide plates. Crane dual valve springs set up at 136# on the seat, 340# over the nose. Walbro 255lph fuel pump with 41psi through the rpm band wot all the way to redline. Plugs are fairly new tr55 gapped at .040, wires are duralast about 3 years old. Optispark is non-vented chinese replacement case rebuilt using the original mitsubishi sensor and wheel from the original opti. Rotor and cap are about 2 years old. Rotor screws were attached with locktite.
@5500-5700 rpm the car stops gaining power. The maf starts bouncing @ around 270-280 afgs and doesn't get any higher than that. The map doesn't show anything unusual, it drops a little bit in the upper rpm, but nothing out of the ordinary. AFR looks good, 12.8 to around 13.0, with a rich spike right at the shift point of 6150. The sound of the engine changes when this happens, but it is not super prominent and it's hard to describe, it's just different. The rate of acceleration just slows down at that point, but the engine keeps gaining rpm, and doesn't stutter any. I am not getting any knock retard when it happens.
I'm at a bit of a loss and don't want to just throw money at it blindly. I'm thinking of replacing the plug wires anyway, but could the opti be the problem? The coil? Does it sound like the ignition at all?
I could really use some ideas for what to check next.
The car feels strong. It ran a 12.81@108 with a DA of 1100, but I think I'm leaving something on the table here. It's done it with 2 different ICMs. It's also still did with a set of 1.6 rockers.
Help!!
stock heads, pacesetter long tubes, ory, loudmouth, no cats. Ws6 hood and airbox (suncoast creations). 219/227@50 .534/.544 camshaft w 1.7 roller rockers. Hardened pushrods with guide plates. Crane dual valve springs set up at 136# on the seat, 340# over the nose. Walbro 255lph fuel pump with 41psi through the rpm band wot all the way to redline. Plugs are fairly new tr55 gapped at .040, wires are duralast about 3 years old. Optispark is non-vented chinese replacement case rebuilt using the original mitsubishi sensor and wheel from the original opti. Rotor and cap are about 2 years old. Rotor screws were attached with locktite.
@5500-5700 rpm the car stops gaining power. The maf starts bouncing @ around 270-280 afgs and doesn't get any higher than that. The map doesn't show anything unusual, it drops a little bit in the upper rpm, but nothing out of the ordinary. AFR looks good, 12.8 to around 13.0, with a rich spike right at the shift point of 6150. The sound of the engine changes when this happens, but it is not super prominent and it's hard to describe, it's just different. The rate of acceleration just slows down at that point, but the engine keeps gaining rpm, and doesn't stutter any. I am not getting any knock retard when it happens.
I'm at a bit of a loss and don't want to just throw money at it blindly. I'm thinking of replacing the plug wires anyway, but could the opti be the problem? The coil? Does it sound like the ignition at all?
I could really use some ideas for what to check next.
The car feels strong. It ran a 12.81@108 with a DA of 1100, but I think I'm leaving something on the table here. It's done it with 2 different ICMs. It's also still did with a set of 1.6 rockers.
Help!!
#2
Does it feel like a ignition miss or does the car just "nose over" aka stop making power?
even though the Chinese Opti has the Mitsubishi optical sensor in it...that opti "could" be the problem.
The Auto zone wires...replace with anything of better quality. Magnacore, Taylor or MSD
but I would first confirm the Crane springs you have are good for.600 lift assuming your cam lift specs of .544 are WITH 1:5 RR. With your cam AND 1:6 RR your lift is .580 and you really want .030 margin on spring lift above that. with the 1.7 RR your lift would have been .616
If you have exceeded lift of the spring you run...don't drive the motor, replace the springs
even though the Chinese Opti has the Mitsubishi optical sensor in it...that opti "could" be the problem.
The Auto zone wires...replace with anything of better quality. Magnacore, Taylor or MSD
but I would first confirm the Crane springs you have are good for.600 lift assuming your cam lift specs of .544 are WITH 1:5 RR. With your cam AND 1:6 RR your lift is .580 and you really want .030 margin on spring lift above that. with the 1.7 RR your lift would have been .616
If you have exceeded lift of the spring you run...don't drive the motor, replace the springs
#3
It's .544 with the 1.7s
it does it with the 1.6 rockers at .512 lift also
it doesn't really nose over, it just kinda goes flat.
crane spring say: Maximum Net Lift w/.060" Clearance 0.710, so I would think that I am good there.
it does it with the 1.6 rockers at .512 lift also
it doesn't really nose over, it just kinda goes flat.
crane spring say: Maximum Net Lift w/.060" Clearance 0.710, so I would think that I am good there.
Last edited by fbody_brian; 12-02-2017 at 04:44 PM.
#4
Good on the lift than with the Crane springs
If the motor has previously run right with this set up but now the high rpm issue, and given what you have tested, Opti would be the leading candidate to swap
My MSD opti did this...and being a new opti I assumed it was something else....several part changes later....it was the MSD opti. Started and ran fine but lost power in upper rpm's.
I have never had a failed or failing opti throw a code which was frustrating in finding cause of problem
If the motor has previously run right with this set up but now the high rpm issue, and given what you have tested, Opti would be the leading candidate to swap
My MSD opti did this...and being a new opti I assumed it was something else....several part changes later....it was the MSD opti. Started and ran fine but lost power in upper rpm's.
I have never had a failed or failing opti throw a code which was frustrating in finding cause of problem
#6
I suppose it's possible that the cam is done by then, but I expected it to keep gaining power above 5500-5700rpm
cam card says:
cam card says:
- RPM Range: 1800-6000
Trending Topics
#8
shift is complete at around 6150.
doesn't really recover after 5700. It's hard to describe. I go WOT, car pulls good, datalog shows maf reading steadily climbing with rpm, between 5500-5700 rpm the maf stops climbing with rpm. It stalls out around 270-280 afgs and just bounces around that area, the rate of acceleration slows ever so slightly, though it never noses over or stutters. My first thought was valve float, possibly bouncing the intake valves off the seats and bleeding off compression. I threw on lower ratio rockers and the problem remained, with no change in the RPM that it happens.
I would think that if i were getting a misfire that it would be reflected in the AFR.
Just a little stumped.
I really think that I am going to swap out the ignition stuff and let her rip. If it doesn't fix it, I'll just have to live with it.
i also have had this strange issue with the logged rpm during WOT runs, where the RPM is really jagged, like the car is struggling to accelerate, but it's not, so I am thinking that thereis something wrong with the optical sensor or the shuttle wheel.
Probably going to try out a Pantera EFI optispark.
doesn't really recover after 5700. It's hard to describe. I go WOT, car pulls good, datalog shows maf reading steadily climbing with rpm, between 5500-5700 rpm the maf stops climbing with rpm. It stalls out around 270-280 afgs and just bounces around that area, the rate of acceleration slows ever so slightly, though it never noses over or stutters. My first thought was valve float, possibly bouncing the intake valves off the seats and bleeding off compression. I threw on lower ratio rockers and the problem remained, with no change in the RPM that it happens.
I would think that if i were getting a misfire that it would be reflected in the AFR.
Just a little stumped.
I really think that I am going to swap out the ignition stuff and let her rip. If it doesn't fix it, I'll just have to live with it.
i also have had this strange issue with the logged rpm during WOT runs, where the RPM is really jagged, like the car is struggling to accelerate, but it's not, so I am thinking that thereis something wrong with the optical sensor or the shuttle wheel.
Probably going to try out a Pantera EFI optispark.
Last edited by fbody_brian; 12-04-2017 at 04:45 PM.
#9
Just changing from one rocker ratio to another doesn't necessarily mean the springs are fine.
I know you said your AFR is good, but FP should be in the 43 to 45psi range.
I had an Opti issue where it would stumble in the 6500 range when I was shifting at 7200 with my last motor, so...
I know you said your AFR is good, but FP should be in the 43 to 45psi range.
I had an Opti issue where it would stumble in the 6500 range when I was shifting at 7200 with my last motor, so...
#10
The GM Factory Service Manual says 41-47, though I understand that 43.5 is nominal, and it's what the factory tune is based on. Where did 43-45 come from?
How do I confirm that it's valve springs, opti, coil, something else, without swapping parts?
Is there anything to look for in the datalog to confirm valve float or an ignition misfire?
How do I confirm that it's valve springs, opti, coil, something else, without swapping parts?
Is there anything to look for in the datalog to confirm valve float or an ignition misfire?
#11
How do I confirm that it's valve springs, opti, coil, something else, without swapping parts?
Is there anything to look for in the datalog to confirm valve float or an ignition misfire?
Is there anything to look for in the datalog to confirm valve float or an ignition misfire?
https://www.summitracing.com/parts/mor-62390/overview/
Because of the cowl you will not be able to test all of them, but the ones you can, you may be able to get an idea if they're okay.
As far as opti, I just bought another and hoped for the best. However that was a few years ago when you could still get ahold of a quality opti for a reasonable price.
#12
You will need the specs of the springs, get a spring pressure tester and see where they're at.
https://www.summitracing.com/parts/mor-62390/overview/
Because of the cowl you will not be able to test all of them, but the ones you can, you may be able to get an idea if they're oka.
https://www.summitracing.com/parts/mor-62390/overview/
Because of the cowl you will not be able to test all of them, but the ones you can, you may be able to get an idea if they're oka.
this is what LE had to say about them:
https://ls1tech.com/forums/lt1-lt4-m...l#post10499303
Appreciate the suggestions, hopefully I can get it all sorted out. This car has been one issue after the next. Glad it's not the DD anymore!
Last edited by fbody_brian; 12-05-2017 at 12:47 PM.
#13
You can also put it on a chassis dyno and see what happens in the upper RPM. If your power starts to significantly nose over after 5700rpm (usually the graph remains smooth) that could be a good indication of valve float.
#14
if the springs have more than 20k mi on them ....they are "wear" items and need replacing with cams other than stock. Stock cams springs last longer but still lose their open & seat pressure and need to be replaced typically after the 75k mi mark if you want to spin the motor higher than stock
pull a few springs and measure their pressure...and confirm their "installed height" is on spec to provide the open & seat pressure. So many people just "throw" on springs without measuring for Installed Height....
not saying this is OP's issue but if springs have miles on them with a cam...check them
pull a few springs and measure their pressure...and confirm their "installed height" is on spec to provide the open & seat pressure. So many people just "throw" on springs without measuring for Installed Height....
not saying this is OP's issue but if springs have miles on them with a cam...check them
#16
I had a hair line crack in a spark plug and a loose opti rotor from the plastic rivers failing that caused similar symptoms in my car a few years ago.. Those two problems eventually took my coil out also. I guess the coil got over heated from the resistance maybe idk..
Last edited by NewOrleansLT1; 12-06-2017 at 08:33 PM.
#18
Oh, and to further explain the opti issue on mine, I changed the cap and rotor and had the same problem. It must've been the sensor or wheel that had issues with higher RPM.
If you chose to put the car on the dyno ignition anomolies may show up where the power line may continue to rise, but the line is really rough. Of course, do so on a wide band to ensure fuel is good.
If you chose to put the car on the dyno ignition anomolies may show up where the power line may continue to rise, but the line is really rough. Of course, do so on a wide band to ensure fuel is good.
#19
I ran those springs with a larger cam and never ran into issues. Pulled clean to 6300, and had over 20k on them when I put the car away with no signs of valve float or fatigue. I would be surprised if you had issues with those springs and that cam with only 3k miles.
Honestly sounds like opti...does it happen both when hot and cold? If only when hot it could be the ICM overheating and spacing it from the head with washers may help. I see its stock heads but has the HG been changed? If its higher than stock compression dropping the plug gap to .035 may help - my tuner recommended it with a thinner HG even though I had an MSD coil since we run pretty high compression on these cars.
Trying to find a way to not blame the opti like everyone always does but in this case... .
Honestly sounds like opti...does it happen both when hot and cold? If only when hot it could be the ICM overheating and spacing it from the head with washers may help. I see its stock heads but has the HG been changed? If its higher than stock compression dropping the plug gap to .035 may help - my tuner recommended it with a thinner HG even though I had an MSD coil since we run pretty high compression on these cars.
Trying to find a way to not blame the opti like everyone always does but in this case... .
#20
I had a hair line crack in a spark plug and a loose opti rotor from the plastic rivers failing that caused similar symptoms in my car a few years ago.. Those two problems eventually took my coil out also. I guess the coil got over heated from the resistance maybe idk..
Last edited by NewOrleansLT1; 12-07-2017 at 01:20 PM.