No luck solving intake back fire from idle $100 to winner who can help find issue.
#1
No luck solving intake back fire from idle $100 to winner who can help find issue.
I have a 96 Impala with 77000miles . Super clean and cared for which I bought from older retired gentleman.
I have been chasing a intake back fire.
Here is video
The intake back fire only happens off of idle when you hammer throttle fast. if you get into throttle slowly no issues.
First repair I completed was fuel system. This originally was low psi so I thought to start here. (it was around 20 psi)
-New fuel pump
-New sending unit
-New Delco fuel filter
-New Bosch injectors
-New Delco fuel pressure regulator.
As you can see in video system pressure looking good . This really helped car cold start etc .glad I did this all.
I am now confident fuel system is now corrected.
Moving on
Tune up and optispark
-New Delco O2 sensors all 4.
-New Delco coolant temp sensor.
-New Delco MAF.
-New NGK spark plugs and Delco wires
-New Delco opti cap and rotor.
-New Delco PCV valve
I used a mini scope and from what others telling me its looking correct and clean signals. This test is at the opti spark connector.
This is testing at the ICM
Next testing
I used a smoke machine to check for vacuum leaks. No smoke no vac leaks detected.
I also ran sea foam into intake just to give her a cleaning.
Next test was to confirm exhaust system is not clogged. I did both sides. I removed the upstream 02 and reading came back at idle and around 3000rpm (0-0.5 psi )
so confirmed exhaust is not blocked.
Scanner has no trouble codes..................
Fuel trims
STFT B1 2%
STFT B2 2%
LTFT B1 -1%
LTFT B2 5%
my understanding is if the total stays under 10 we are ok on older cars
Next testing spark advance
at idle we are at 16.
at 2500 rpm 37.
Lastly I wanted to test knock system some more.
I noticed my knock count activity is in the red which has me wondering why (see vid)
Testing I have performed to KS.
Back probed KS and getting 4.87v and with wire unplugged from KS 4.97 so that's looking good. This is with key on not running.
With car running around 4.87v.
Next up connecting scope. Looking good and with rev up clean signal.(see pic)
I also removed both KS from car and fit onto vise. My ohm reading were in spec.
Spec from GM 93K to 107K. I was around 98k so both are in spec.
I then connected to scope while on the vise and used hammer to create signal and they are beautiful on the scope.
I will work on loading more in images but this is where I am at
Thank you I hope to one day enjoy this car. if not I can film car at junk yard getting crushed
I have been chasing a intake back fire.
Here is video
The intake back fire only happens off of idle when you hammer throttle fast. if you get into throttle slowly no issues.
First repair I completed was fuel system. This originally was low psi so I thought to start here. (it was around 20 psi)
-New fuel pump
-New sending unit
-New Delco fuel filter
-New Bosch injectors
-New Delco fuel pressure regulator.
As you can see in video system pressure looking good . This really helped car cold start etc .glad I did this all.
I am now confident fuel system is now corrected.
Moving on
Tune up and optispark
-New Delco O2 sensors all 4.
-New Delco coolant temp sensor.
-New Delco MAF.
-New NGK spark plugs and Delco wires
-New Delco opti cap and rotor.
-New Delco PCV valve
I used a mini scope and from what others telling me its looking correct and clean signals. This test is at the opti spark connector.
This is testing at the ICM
Next testing
I used a smoke machine to check for vacuum leaks. No smoke no vac leaks detected.
I also ran sea foam into intake just to give her a cleaning.
Next test was to confirm exhaust system is not clogged. I did both sides. I removed the upstream 02 and reading came back at idle and around 3000rpm (0-0.5 psi )
so confirmed exhaust is not blocked.
Scanner has no trouble codes..................
Fuel trims
STFT B1 2%
STFT B2 2%
LTFT B1 -1%
LTFT B2 5%
my understanding is if the total stays under 10 we are ok on older cars
Next testing spark advance
at idle we are at 16.
at 2500 rpm 37.
Lastly I wanted to test knock system some more.
I noticed my knock count activity is in the red which has me wondering why (see vid)
Testing I have performed to KS.
Back probed KS and getting 4.87v and with wire unplugged from KS 4.97 so that's looking good. This is with key on not running.
With car running around 4.87v.
Next up connecting scope. Looking good and with rev up clean signal.(see pic)
I also removed both KS from car and fit onto vise. My ohm reading were in spec.
Spec from GM 93K to 107K. I was around 98k so both are in spec.
I then connected to scope while on the vise and used hammer to create signal and they are beautiful on the scope.
I will work on loading more in images but this is where I am at
Thank you I hope to one day enjoy this car. if not I can film car at junk yard getting crushed
Last edited by J16; 08-10-2021 at 10:29 AM.
The following users liked this post:
J16 (08-10-2021)
#3
Village Troll
iTrader: (2)
That sounds like a classic case of plug wires being on the wrong plugs. Double/triple/quadruple check to ensure they are routed correctly. Backfiring almost always leads to either a vacuum or timing issue.
The following users liked this post:
J16 (08-10-2021)
#4
Village Troll
iTrader: (2)
Check them again. Doesn't matter if intake or exhaust backfire when it's a timing issue. Combustion can come out of either valve. As stated a vacuum leak can also cause an intake backfire. Engine is not accelerating like it should when you blip the throttle, which is leading me to those two possible causes.
The following users liked this post:
J16 (08-10-2021)
#5
Check them again. Doesn't matter if intake or exhaust backfire when it's a timing issue. Combustion can come out of either valve. As stated a vacuum leak can also cause an intake backfire. Engine is not accelerating like it should when you blip the throttle, which is leading me to those two possible causes.
As to vacuum leak i did perform a smoke machine test and found no leaks not sure what ease i can do.
and to confirm this is what it should be
#7
Village Troll
iTrader: (2)
possible it's an EGR failure. Usually those don't act up until there's a high amount of vacuum put on them at cruising speeds. Did you check the EGR gasket surface with the smoke machine? Can also spray starter fluid/brake clean/carb cleaner to see if the idle changes.
Trending Topics
#8
#9
Check them again. Doesn't matter if intake or exhaust backfire when it's a timing issue. Combustion can come out of either valve. As stated a vacuum leak can also cause an intake backfire. Engine is not accelerating like it should when you blip the throttle, which is leading me to those two possible causes.
#11
Is there more testing I can do on EGR or should I just replace it?
#12
TECH Resident
Scope the MAP and TPS. Both are responsible for fueling enrichment especially on throttle stomp. A momentary lean spike can cause an intake backfire.
#13
Here is my approach to testing EGR system:
1. Engine Off - Check the valve can be moved manually with finger or tool (valve not frozen)
2. Engine Off - Test valve diaphragm by disconnecting vacuum line at EGR valve. Move valve by hand and place finger over vacuum port, or apply vacuum with pump (valve should hold position and vacuum, should move then hold position and vacuum using pump)
3. Engine Idling - Move the valve manually or with vacuum pump while idling to see if you get a stumble (yes is good - internal EGR passages open)
4. Drive Test - Disconnect vacuum line at EGR valve, attach vacuum gage and place where you can see it while driving. At light/med cruise should see the gage move from zero to near manifold vacuum. May have variable vacuum since this is not just an on-off solenoid but is rapidly pulsed by PCM. Will drop back to zero under other conditions. Scan tool is great here to see the PCM commands and the vacuum gage response. (problems here could be the solenoid valve, wiring, vacuum lines,).
5. Continue with basic vacuum, mechanical, electrical checks as needed to isolate problems in those areas.
Hope this helps -
Jim
#14
TECH Resident
With a dual channel scope, you may be able to scope the MAP and Low res opti signal to see if the same cylinder is causing the back fire all the time. A cranking relative compression test using an amp clamp might also give you an idea if there is a compression/valve lash/wear issue. If it shows a compression issue, follow it up with the standard compression testing. Leak down testing on each cylinder might not be a bad idea either.
#15
Village Troll
iTrader: (2)
Here's a shade tree way to test if you have an EGR leak- Either buy or make a block off plate using a piece of aluminum and cut it to size/drill bolt holes using an EGR gasket. Bolt into place with gasket. See what happens. Keep EGR plugged into harness so the SES light doesn't trigger.
Has this backfire only been in the intake or has there been any through the exhaust?
Has this backfire only been in the intake or has there been any through the exhaust?
#17
Here is my approach to testing EGR system:
1. Engine Off - Check the valve can be moved manually with finger or tool (valve not frozen)
2. Engine Off - Test valve diaphragm by disconnecting vacuum line at EGR valve. Move valve by hand and place finger over vacuum port, or apply vacuum with pump (valve should hold position and vacuum, should move then hold position and vacuum using pump)
3. Engine Idling - Move the valve manually or with vacuum pump while idling to see if you get a stumble (yes is good - internal EGR passages open)
4. Drive Test - Disconnect vacuum line at EGR valve, attach vacuum gage and place where you can see it while driving. At light/med cruise should see the gage move from zero to near manifold vacuum. May have variable vacuum since this is not just an on-off solenoid but is rapidly pulsed by PCM. Will drop back to zero under other conditions. Scan tool is great here to see the PCM commands and the vacuum gage response. (problems here could be the solenoid valve, wiring, vacuum lines,).
5. Continue with basic vacuum, mechanical, electrical checks as needed to isolate problems in those areas.
Hope this helps -
Jim
1. Engine Off - Check the valve can be moved manually with finger or tool (valve not frozen)
2. Engine Off - Test valve diaphragm by disconnecting vacuum line at EGR valve. Move valve by hand and place finger over vacuum port, or apply vacuum with pump (valve should hold position and vacuum, should move then hold position and vacuum using pump)
3. Engine Idling - Move the valve manually or with vacuum pump while idling to see if you get a stumble (yes is good - internal EGR passages open)
4. Drive Test - Disconnect vacuum line at EGR valve, attach vacuum gage and place where you can see it while driving. At light/med cruise should see the gage move from zero to near manifold vacuum. May have variable vacuum since this is not just an on-off solenoid but is rapidly pulsed by PCM. Will drop back to zero under other conditions. Scan tool is great here to see the PCM commands and the vacuum gage response. (problems here could be the solenoid valve, wiring, vacuum lines,).
5. Continue with basic vacuum, mechanical, electrical checks as needed to isolate problems in those areas.
Hope this helps -
Jim
With a dual channel scope, you may be able to scope the MAP and Low res opti signal to see if the same cylinder is causing the back fire all the time. A cranking relative compression test using an amp clamp might also give you an idea if there is a compression/valve lash/wear issue. If it shows a compression issue, follow it up with the standard compression testing. Leak down testing on each cylinder might not be a bad idea either.
Here's a shade tree way to test if you have an EGR leak- Either buy or make a block off plate using a piece of aluminum and cut it to size/drill bolt holes using an EGR gasket. Bolt into place with gasket. See what happens. Keep EGR plugged into harness so the SES light doesn't trigger.
Yup that's a good trick. I am just debating to just buy a new egr I don't think they are big money at all I will check rock auto.
Has this backfire only been in the intake or has there been any through the exhaust?
Yup that's a good trick. I am just debating to just buy a new egr I don't think they are big money at all I will check rock auto.
Has this backfire only been in the intake or has there been any through the exhaust?
Last edited by J16; 08-13-2021 at 08:58 PM.
#18
TECH Addict
Just noticed you have the K&N, have you looked to see if the MAF is clean and still has the honey comb air guide in it?
Mafs do not like turbulence. That setup just seems like it would work better with the MAF half way between the Filter and throttle body..
Both MAF cars I owned need some tlc on the maf regularly..
Mafs do not like turbulence. That setup just seems like it would work better with the MAF half way between the Filter and throttle body..
Both MAF cars I owned need some tlc on the maf regularly..
#19
Just noticed you have the K&N, have you looked to see if the MAF is clean and still has the honey comb air guide in it?
Mafs do not like turbulence. That setup just seems like it would work better with the MAF half way between the Filter and throttle body..
Both MAF cars I owned need some tlc on the maf regularly..
Mafs do not like turbulence. That setup just seems like it would work better with the MAF half way between the Filter and throttle body..
Both MAF cars I owned need some tlc on the maf regularly..
that filter set up is a kit made for impala not custom
#20
TECH Addict
AH that makes sense, any way you could get 4" of tube between the MAF and filter?
(It looks like the filter is bolted straight to the MAF in one of the pics? I may be not seeing it well.
I worked on a Camaro that had a random stutter/pop that turned out went away
when we got some tube ahead of the MAF..
(It looks like the filter is bolted straight to the MAF in one of the pics? I may be not seeing it well.
I worked on a Camaro that had a random stutter/pop that turned out went away
when we got some tube ahead of the MAF..