BMR Spring Question?
#62
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
You think the cars seen in this thread look stock? https://ls1tech.com/forums/suspensio...ng-setups.html
My rear springs aren't really low, on purpose because that is a primary reason for terrible manners and ride quality. Anyone could also do the isolator mod if they wanted a bit more drop....
My rear springs aren't really low, on purpose because that is a primary reason for terrible manners and ride quality. Anyone could also do the isolator mod if they wanted a bit more drop....
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
#63
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
Right now I have the 1" BMR springs and revalved Bilsteins that I got from you. I ran the springs with the factory DeCarbons for a while until I got the shocks, and like you said, it made a HUGE difference. Would I see any performance difference swapping from the old BMRs to yours with new shocks? My car handles really well right now, but I want more!
If you want more performance and it came down to a spring change or a change to Koni's, it'd for sure be the Koni's I'd recommend.
Now, don't interpret that as my thinking the springs are the same. I don't think that anymore than I think an LT1 is the same as an LS1 because they are similar in being about 5.7 liter GM V-8's....
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
#64
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
You say that, and seem to forget the BMR springs are stiffer than mine are in the rear of the car.... So please enlighten me on how you come to the conclusion my springs can't launch as well as BMR's which are stiffer when you say that mine are too stiff for launching?
And to address the Koni side, well I have a lot of customers with springs and Koni's in the 1.6's and 1.7's with that setup. And one customer who pulled a 1.50 on Koni's vs. his previous best of 1.58 on a combination of Afco and QA1's. (both setups on stock springs).
I know you have a theory, but that's all it is. And I had forgotten about another car that many know... The GMHTP magazine Camaro called "1SC-YA" has a suspension I did on it. Not only did it go 3.4 seconds faster on a road course on street tires... but with Strano Springs, bars and Koni's also ran a 12.23. Now that might not be impressive until you realize the mph was 109. That ET came from the launch, showing that a handling car can indeed leave pretty freaking well.
Strano springs are not drag springs. Eibach drag springs are drag springs. And if drag racing is most important with decent handling, then NO lowering spring is right for that job and you'd be best served with stock spring and good shocks.
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
Last edited by Sam Strano; 11-14-2008 at 11:03 AM.
#65
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
Sure thing, anytime.
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
#66
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
I have had BMR and now have Sams springs on my car, I have Sams sway bars and 4/4 Koni's . I like Sams linear spring rate on the front much better, But like the BMR spring on the rear better. I swaped them out a couple of times just to make sure. With Sams springs with nothing in the car they are great but put anything more than a guitar case in the rear they bottom, crank up the Koni's to compensate and they seem to over power the 150lb spring rate. I like to travel and carry stuff alot. With the BMR's and anything in the car I don't bottom out like Sams do. If all you ever put in the car is you and your girl and have desent roads go with Sams springs. and the Koni's. I think Sams spring in a 160lb rate would be perfect for my use. Just my 2Cents.
Fair enough.... but let's not forget the amount of weight the car is supposed to carry is only about 700 pounds in total. Considering that most of that mass is likely to be carried in the seats (between the wheels) and not cantilevered out back, mass does has an effect on my springs more because they are not as stiff. But they are still about 25% stiffer than stock in the rear.
And from a handling standpoint, I don't know many that go driving all that hard with a lot of weight in the car.
From the shock standpoint, as Bryan said the Koni's adjust rebound. If you just turn the shocks up to "compensate" for weight, you can overdamp the springs (and you can overdamp the BMR's too, but wtih more rate is takes a little more shock to do it). The shocks do not adjust compression, and even if they did compression damping deals with unsprung weight *not* sprung weight. In short you are turning the shocks up for the wrong reasons and they are not responding in they way you think because that's not how they work.
In situations like yours there is an easy fix that allows you to keep my springs on and get the rate you like better when "empty", but give you some more spring rate when you load up. Best of both worlds. Called airbags. They fit inside the springs, and only cost about $100. Deflate them when empty and you ahve my springs. Add air when you pile in weight and you have as much extra spring rate as you want.
But other considerations. If anyone as an SS or WS6, we change rear bumpstops to the softer more progressive Z28/Formula versions so the "hit" when you contact the bumpstop (and all springs do) isn't as sudden. Now you can do that with more spring rate too, but more spring is always more spring, and we don't always need that much spring. So I prefer the softer spring and less abrupt rising rate bumpstop (which don't return energy like springs do, so they aren't the same as a progressive spring).
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
#67
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: San Jose, CA
Posts: 1,607
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Says somone who's not done it.
You say that, and seem to forget the BMR springs are stiffer than mine are in the rear of the car.... So please enlighten me on how you come to the conclusion my springs can't launch as well as BMR's which are stiffer when you say that mine are too stiff for launching?
And to address the Koni side, well I have a lot of customers with springs and Koni's in the 1.6's and 1.7's with that setup. And one customer who pulled a 1.50 on Koni's vs. his previous best of 1.58 on a combination of Afco and QA1's. (both setups on stock springs).
I know you have a theory, but that's all it is.
Strano springs are not drag springs. Eibach drag springs are drag springs. And if drag racing is most important with decent handling, then NO lowering spring is right for that job and you'd be best served with stock spring and good shocks.
You say that, and seem to forget the BMR springs are stiffer than mine are in the rear of the car.... So please enlighten me on how you come to the conclusion my springs can't launch as well as BMR's which are stiffer when you say that mine are too stiff for launching?
And to address the Koni side, well I have a lot of customers with springs and Koni's in the 1.6's and 1.7's with that setup. And one customer who pulled a 1.50 on Koni's vs. his previous best of 1.58 on a combination of Afco and QA1's. (both setups on stock springs).
I know you have a theory, but that's all it is.
Strano springs are not drag springs. Eibach drag springs are drag springs. And if drag racing is most important with decent handling, then NO lowering spring is right for that job and you'd be best served with stock spring and good shocks.
#68
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Flagstaff, AZ
Posts: 582
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Because I'm honest, I have to tell you that a huge change would not be forthcoming. The rates and heights are overall too similar to see anything massive. That said, you would end up dragging around less weight, and having a bit more supple ride from the back of the car.
If you want more performance and it came down to a spring change or a change to Koni's, it'd for sure be the Koni's I'd recommend.
Now, don't interpret that as my thinking the springs are the same. I don't think that anymore than I think an LT1 is the same as an LS1 because they are similar in being about 5.7 liter GM V-8's....
If you want more performance and it came down to a spring change or a change to Koni's, it'd for sure be the Koni's I'd recommend.
Now, don't interpret that as my thinking the springs are the same. I don't think that anymore than I think an LT1 is the same as an LS1 because they are similar in being about 5.7 liter GM V-8's....
#69
TECH Apprentice
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It depends on how much control you want over the rear shock damping. The 4th gen rears allow for more precise adjustment and let you do the adjusting while they are on the car. The 3rd gen rears have a more course adjustment (only 4 settings) and must be adjusted off the car. I went with the third gens because I felt I could get the setting close enough to what I wanted (and I did) and I didn't see myself adjusting the shocks very often. Also the 3rd gens were a bit cheaper.
#70
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
And no problem on the spring info. The truth is not every spring is decent, or even workable, but some are as long as you know what the differences are and the result of them. In this case, the thing you need are shocks, and good ones.
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
#71
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Flagstaff, AZ
Posts: 582
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
4/4's are the most recommended due to the ease and range of adjustment. 4/3's are about being more cost effective (I know, not inexpensive, but $120 less is $120 less). Niether is wrong, and frankly 4/3's are better than anything else you could put on except for 4/4's, so it's a classic cost vs. potential thing, just like buying anything.
And no problem on the spring info. The truth is not every spring is decent, or even workable, but some are as long as you know what the differences are and the result of them. In this case, the thing you need are shocks, and good ones.
And no problem on the spring info. The truth is not every spring is decent, or even workable, but some are as long as you know what the differences are and the result of them. In this case, the thing you need are shocks, and good ones.
Once again, I really appreciate your help with this!!
#72
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
It's a lack of rebound damping added to messed up compression damping. As the stock stuff (or any other shock wears) they are less able to control what's going on. This is why the ride gets worse and worse as the miles add up. The springs don't get stiffer, the dampers get worse.
And the above reasons are why folks are well served to run quality dampers that not only have enough damping to suit their needs to start, but will down the road. Otherwise the same thing can happen again. And it's not all down to quality. This is where a Bilstein is great for a stock spring, but as the springs get stiffer and shorter start to get overworked. The quality is excellent, the damping, not as well suited.
And the above reasons are why folks are well served to run quality dampers that not only have enough damping to suit their needs to start, but will down the road. Otherwise the same thing can happen again. And it's not all down to quality. This is where a Bilstein is great for a stock spring, but as the springs get stiffer and shorter start to get overworked. The quality is excellent, the damping, not as well suited.
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
#73
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Flagstaff, AZ
Posts: 582
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's a lack of rebound damping added to messed up compression damping. As the stock stuff (or any other shock wears) they are less able to control what's going on. This is why the ride gets worse and worse as the miles add up. The springs don't get stiffer, the dampers get worse.
And the above reasons are why folks are well served to run quality dampers that not only have enough damping to suit their needs to start, but will down the road. Otherwise the same thing can happen again. And it's not all down to quality. This is where a Bilstein is great for a stock spring, but as the springs get stiffer and shorter start to get overworked. The quality is excellent, the damping, not as well suited.
And the above reasons are why folks are well served to run quality dampers that not only have enough damping to suit their needs to start, but will down the road. Otherwise the same thing can happen again. And it's not all down to quality. This is where a Bilstein is great for a stock spring, but as the springs get stiffer and shorter start to get overworked. The quality is excellent, the damping, not as well suited.
#74
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
The shocks you have are suited to stock springs, which are around 300 lbs/in front and 115 or so rear. The springs you have are much stiffer at both ends of the car. The rears getting to 170 lbs/in or about 35% stiffer than stock.
It's a double edge sword. Both the springs and the shocks effect how well the axle works over bumps. I prefer a little softer rear rate so the axle moves more easily up and over bumps. BMR goes a little stiffer. So there is an effect there and shocks can't make the spring rate softer. However, shocks do effect how the car impacts the bump, and damp the movement of the impact on the springs and how the car reacts to it. Remember how jumpy the back of the car was with stock shocks (if you experienced them)? That was with much softer springs, but the shocks didn't match them well and the result was a jittery, jumpy car that was prone to skip and over broken pavement.
Parts have to work with each other for the best results. Your shocks are not a good match for lowering springs, and the stiffer the springs get the more you ask of the shocks and these are pretty far from stock rates.
To put it in perspective. GM and Bilstein have done setups for years together. Lots of GM vehicles come with OEM Bilstein's (valved to GM spec). But the 1LE's had for the first 3 years specially valved DeCarbon's, then in 1996 through to the end of the 1LE package came with Koni DA's. This is relevant as the spring rate on a rear 1LE spring was 130-170 (some claim 180). Sound familiar? Except you are trying to damp that rate in lesser travel, which again demands more damping.
So GM added Koni's and not Bilstein's to the 1LE with similar rear rates. But the 1LE would have been easier to damp given the taller height and greater range of travel the shock had to do it's damping.
The "problems" you are having now are not something I can assess by e-mail or PM. The rear jumping out can happen for a number of reasons, and in different ways. Binding LCA's can cause it to be worse. The car is still a solid axle too.
I think this is a classic case of a little face to face talk, so to speak is the best way to get an appropriate answer. I can't know the details I need. But yes, Koni's are better dampers for your springs. And if you find anyone who's had lowering springs and gone from Bilstein to Koni, you'll find they think it's worth the change.
It's a double edge sword. Both the springs and the shocks effect how well the axle works over bumps. I prefer a little softer rear rate so the axle moves more easily up and over bumps. BMR goes a little stiffer. So there is an effect there and shocks can't make the spring rate softer. However, shocks do effect how the car impacts the bump, and damp the movement of the impact on the springs and how the car reacts to it. Remember how jumpy the back of the car was with stock shocks (if you experienced them)? That was with much softer springs, but the shocks didn't match them well and the result was a jittery, jumpy car that was prone to skip and over broken pavement.
Parts have to work with each other for the best results. Your shocks are not a good match for lowering springs, and the stiffer the springs get the more you ask of the shocks and these are pretty far from stock rates.
To put it in perspective. GM and Bilstein have done setups for years together. Lots of GM vehicles come with OEM Bilstein's (valved to GM spec). But the 1LE's had for the first 3 years specially valved DeCarbon's, then in 1996 through to the end of the 1LE package came with Koni DA's. This is relevant as the spring rate on a rear 1LE spring was 130-170 (some claim 180). Sound familiar? Except you are trying to damp that rate in lesser travel, which again demands more damping.
So GM added Koni's and not Bilstein's to the 1LE with similar rear rates. But the 1LE would have been easier to damp given the taller height and greater range of travel the shock had to do it's damping.
The "problems" you are having now are not something I can assess by e-mail or PM. The rear jumping out can happen for a number of reasons, and in different ways. Binding LCA's can cause it to be worse. The car is still a solid axle too.
I think this is a classic case of a little face to face talk, so to speak is the best way to get an appropriate answer. I can't know the details I need. But yes, Koni's are better dampers for your springs. And if you find anyone who's had lowering springs and gone from Bilstein to Koni, you'll find they think it's worth the change.
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
#76
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (43)
Sam you were talking about softer bump stops than my SS factory ones, do you have a part number by chance. I would admit that would help when its loaded down and I bottom it hits hard, and worry about breaking something.
Thanks as allways for your honest answers, thats what's great about these forums
Thanks as allways for your honest answers, thats what's great about these forums
#77
TECH Apprentice
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The stock bump stops off Z28 cars are what he recommended earlier. I think the stealership is the only place in town that we can get them. I've been looking everywhere else around here for a set with no success.
#78
LS1TECH Sponsor
iTrader: (41)
I recommend exactly what tpunk stated. Stock Z28 stops w/o the SS/WS6 spacers. Use the GM parts.
But the majority of the slamming hits is usually due to the shocks, not the stops. The bumpstop change is simply an additional help by replacing the harder, square stops with the more progressively stiffer triangular type Z28 stops. The shocks matter more because the SS stops aren't rock hard, just harder. And the harder and faster you hit any bumpstop the more you feel it. That's why the dampers are so key, to slow the rate at which you impact the stops regardless of which type they are.
But the majority of the slamming hits is usually due to the shocks, not the stops. The bumpstop change is simply an additional help by replacing the harder, square stops with the more progressively stiffer triangular type Z28 stops. The shocks matter more because the SS stops aren't rock hard, just harder. And the harder and faster you hit any bumpstop the more you feel it. That's why the dampers are so key, to slow the rate at which you impact the stops regardless of which type they are.
__________________
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion
www.stranoparts.com --814-849-3450
Results matter. Talk is cheap. We are miles beyond the success anyone else has had with the 4th gens, and C5, C6, C7 Corvettes,
10 SCCA Solo National Championships, 2008 Driver of they Year, 2012 Driver of Eminence
13 SCCA Pro Solo Nationals Championships
2023 UMI King of the Mountain Champion