Water to Air Intercoolers
air/air will have greater simplicity, reliability, lower maintence, lower cost, greater thermal eficinecy at higher speed.
air/water better thermal eficency at low speed, may have better throttle responce, lower boost loss, less compresor surge, take up less space.
that wasn't exactly what you were asking but i thought it might help. i have always been told a good air to air is the way to go mainly for the simplicity and lack of maintence unless you plan on doing the ice in the water trick and that would only be for drag racing.

the water intercooler is much smaller than air/air and in my case wont block the radiator (important to me)
water is 9 times more thermally conductive than air.
my research has shown with about 15# of boost you are leaving about 60hp on the table by using air/air vs air/water assuming water is at ambient temperature. nearly 90 hp when using ice.
also the discharge temperature will remain to be lower than any air/air intercooler until water temperatures over 100*F at that boost level... this is really an impossibility when you add a small radiator to the system.
if you can... do it!
there is more to keep track of but hey.. you allready got an F-1 going in there!
My dyno pulls were melting 10 to 12lbs of ice per pull, and the few track runs the car has seen resulted in 16 lbs of ice turned to warm water. intake temps remained a comfortable 75° to 80°, i'll have actual before and after temps on the cooler in the spring.
I've got no cooler for street use as of yet, althoug it's on the list.
Trending Topics
The Best V8 Stories One Small Block at Time

still toying with the idea of making the power tour

I'd like to get a water to ambient heat exchanger in there so i'm not relying on the IC cores to cool the system when outta boost. Cause how often does that happen??
would you be able to say, drive 90 miles on the freeway under little boost or in 20 miles in stop and go traffic with an occasional boost of boost without having to refresh your water supply? I gotta find my Corky Bell book.... my question is if you have pleanty of time for the liquid to get to ambiant air temps will it actualy work better than an air to air?







