six of sixteen rockers breaking after h/c swap
#21
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (5)
didn't you degree the cam, check installed spring height, shim to .060" or so from coil bind, check ptv clearance, measure for proper push rod length? no disrespect but I think its time to call in a professional. also im sure your motor is fucked, those needle bearings can cause some carnage.
#22
TECH Fanatic
Thread Starter
iTrader: (15)
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: _Nor caL_ (Bay areA)
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You bought a cam from one guy got a pr length recomendation from someone else and springs from someone else and are wondering why you are having issues.
I would contact the person who speced the cam and get the springs for that cam measure the pr length and upgrade the rockers
Im not wondering why im having issues. Im trying to resolve the problem i got myself into. The springs were rated above the cam lift so.i figured they would be fine; that way they didnt run out of spring. The spring recommended is 650 lift spring but for 644 lift i wanted more cusion. Guess thats a problem. I have pac seat locators. Like i said it was a kit. the seals.that im using came with my felpro head gasket kit. They are the bulky metal.kind. I put.them over the pac seat.
Tim
I would contact the person who speced the cam and get the springs for that cam measure the pr length and upgrade the rockers
Im not wondering why im having issues. Im trying to resolve the problem i got myself into. The springs were rated above the cam lift so.i figured they would be fine; that way they didnt run out of spring. The spring recommended is 650 lift spring but for 644 lift i wanted more cusion. Guess thats a problem. I have pac seat locators. Like i said it was a kit. the seals.that im using came with my felpro head gasket kit. They are the bulky metal.kind. I put.them over the pac seat.
Tim
#24
TECH Fanatic
Thread Starter
iTrader: (15)
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: _Nor caL_ (Bay areA)
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
well yes now im going to pay to have springs pulled. cant i remove shims and be fine? you guys make it seem like nobody has done this before. this cam is been used by many people with same heads and pushrods. whats so different from mine? i feel like the springs are coil binding because of shims that i put. maybe the installed hight is different from 1.8 that pac says they should be. yes i know i should have measured but instead of bashing on me can we try and figure it out? ive done multiple cam installs and never had this happen before. went with what was recommended and had no issue. i could see if this was some crazy *** heads and an enormous cam, but it is not. many have run this without issue. if i need new springs ill buy new springs, if i need to remove shims than thats what ill do. but saying oh u shoulda done this and that will not help me. i hope my motor is not shot. if it is than maybe i can salvage the top end and get a bigger short block. my setup is far from crazy. its pretty much a stock ls1 with ls6 top end. should not be much different from installing a cam into a 03 z06. i beleive my **** up is in the shimming. are none of you guys familiar with PatrickG and all the work he does? he knows his stuff. i agree now i need professional help. thats why im turning to you guys. good local help is not easy to come by around here. wish i lived back in texas. i would have no issues.
#26
TECH Addict
iTrader: (83)
I don't know anything about the lobe on that cam but the specs on it are not that agressive. I don't run that agressive of a spring on my engine and it is 250 250 .660 .660
You need a spring for that cam. Taking shims away is not your answer. Then measure the pr and go from there.
Again paying someone who does this every day is going to be your best bet.
Tim
You need a spring for that cam. Taking shims away is not your answer. Then measure the pr and go from there.
Again paying someone who does this every day is going to be your best bet.
Tim
#27
FormerVendor
iTrader: (13)
If you installed the "hat" style seals over the locators then there's your problem.
Simply throwing tons of spring pressure at a cam isn't very smart. Increased spring pressure over 400 lbs when using 5/16" pushrods makes the valvetrain less stable due to squashing the lifters and pole vaulting the pushrods.
These are the proper seals: http://www.briantooleyracing.com/ls-valve-seal-kit.html
These are the incorrect "hat" style that are only to be used with single beehive springs: http://www.briantooleyracing.com/ls-...hat-style.html
Simply throwing tons of spring pressure at a cam isn't very smart. Increased spring pressure over 400 lbs when using 5/16" pushrods makes the valvetrain less stable due to squashing the lifters and pole vaulting the pushrods.
These are the proper seals: http://www.briantooleyracing.com/ls-valve-seal-kit.html
These are the incorrect "hat" style that are only to be used with single beehive springs: http://www.briantooleyracing.com/ls-...hat-style.html
#29
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (60)
What Tooley said! The one piece valve seal/seat are for stock springs or stock replacement beehive springs. They don't require another spring seat because the seat is built into the piece. If you used these on top of the PAC seats, you basically are running two seats and may have coil bind issues.
#31
TECH Fanatic
Thread Starter
iTrader: (15)
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: _Nor caL_ (Bay areA)
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
They are hat style. So i will be swapping for the smaller version. I used 1.8 for installe height.measurement. The lifters are not ls7s from what summit said. I beleive they are stock replacements for an ls2 6.0. The whole spring kit is from pac. Retainer, seat, and spring. Thats how i cam up with.measurements for shims used.
.060 and .030 shims on intakes
.015 and .030 shims on exhaust
.060 and .030 shims on intakes
.015 and .030 shims on exhaust
Last edited by stangkiller2005; 12-11-2012 at 02:38 AM.
#33
FormerVendor
iTrader: (13)
They are hat style. So i will be swapping for the smaller version. I used 1.8 for installe height.measurement. The lifters are not ls7s from what summit said. I beleive they are stock replacements for an ls2 6.0. The whole spring kit is from pac. Retainer, seat, and spring. Thats how i cam up with.measurements for shims used.
.060 and .030 shims on intakes
.015 and .030 shims on exhaust
.060 and .030 shims on intakes
.015 and .030 shims on exhaust
Honestly almost .650" lift is too much lift if using stock rockers, as the scrub increases dramatically at those lifts. All in all, I would put some roller rockers on it. Also carefully inspect your inner springs since you were running them into bind.
#34
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (9)
so brian this is off topic from the OP's post somewhat:
When running the roller rockers, whats the best way to make sure they arent gonna be snapping in half like the YT's etc? I jsut got some roller rockers, but I have no idea what brand they are or anything, and when I put this 408 together I wanna be sure I wont have any problems. What do you recommend?
Last edited by Tainted; 12-11-2012 at 09:58 AM.
#36
FormerVendor
iTrader: (13)
so brian this is off topic from the OP's post somewhat:
When running the roller rockers, whats the best way to make sure they arent gonna be snapping in half like the YT's etc? I jsut got some roller rockers, but I have no idea what brand they are or anything, and when I put this 408 together I wanna be sure I wont have any problems. What do you recommend?
When running the roller rockers, whats the best way to make sure they arent gonna be snapping in half like the YT's etc? I jsut got some roller rockers, but I have no idea what brand they are or anything, and when I put this 408 together I wanna be sure I wont have any problems. What do you recommend?
When I spec cams for use with stock rockers I use conservative lift of .624" or less and gentle ramp rate lobes. Then I use springs with less than 400 lbs open pressure, oil with zinc additives and don't have any problems. I just had a turbo car run very low 8's with .621" lift, my Platinum springs that are about 390 lbs at that lift, 5/16" pushrods and stock rockers. He was turning it 7300 rpm through the traps. If people would realize that super high lift cams aren't the magic path to making power they would be better off.
It seems that everyone who is eating up valve tips with high lift cams, stock rockers and too much open spring pressure end up calling me, rather than the shops they bought the stuff from, I'm not sure why that is.
#38
TECH Fanatic
Thread Starter
iTrader: (15)
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: _Nor caL_ (Bay areA)
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just put a 1208X on the spring tester and checked it at 1.710" installed height (.060" &.030" shims) and it checked right at 200 lbs and at .650" lift it checked right at 500 lbs. That's way too much pressure if you're using stock rockers on something that will be driven a lot. As that much open pressure can damage valve tips long term. If it's a track only car then you'll be ok.
Honestly almost .650" lift is too much lift if using stock rockers, as the scrub increases dramatically at those lifts. All in all, I would put some roller rockers on it. Also carefully inspect your inner springs since you were running them into bind.
Honestly almost .650" lift is too much lift if using stock rockers, as the scrub increases dramatically at those lifts. All in all, I would put some roller rockers on it. Also carefully inspect your inner springs since you were running them into bind.
So with that installed height that
You came up with, that changes the shims i should use? Its.going to be a daily driver. Is there a way to make these springs and cam work? If not i may have to sale everything and start over. But i reallly dont wanna do that. And need my car for work. I was thinking of doing truion upgrade. Those Comp cam bearings to reinforce rockers. How do so many get away with ms4? And that lift is even higher.
Is that installed height using PAC locator aswell?
Nal- 12499225 is the part number for the lifters summit.sent me.
Last edited by stangkiller2005; 12-11-2012 at 10:53 AM.
#39
TECH Senior Member
iTrader: (9)
So with that installed height that
You came up with, that changes the shims i should use? Its.going to be a daily driver. Is there a way to make these springs and cam work? If not i may have to sale everything and start over. But i reallly dont wanna do that. And need my car for work. I was thinking of doing truion upgrade. Those Comp cam bearings to reinforce rockers. How do so many get away with ms4? And that lift is even higher.
Nal- 12499225 is the part number for the lifters summit.sent me.
You came up with, that changes the shims i should use? Its.going to be a daily driver. Is there a way to make these springs and cam work? If not i may have to sale everything and start over. But i reallly dont wanna do that. And need my car for work. I was thinking of doing truion upgrade. Those Comp cam bearings to reinforce rockers. How do so many get away with ms4? And that lift is even higher.
Nal- 12499225 is the part number for the lifters summit.sent me.
#40
FormerVendor
iTrader: (13)
So with that installed height that
You came up with, that changes the shims i should use? Its.going to be a daily driver. Is there a way to make these springs and cam work? If not i may have to sale everything and start over. But i reallly dont wanna do that. And need my car for work. I was thinking of doing truion upgrade. Those Comp cam bearings to reinforce rockers. How do so many get away with ms4? And that lift is even higher.
You came up with, that changes the shims i should use? Its.going to be a daily driver. Is there a way to make these springs and cam work? If not i may have to sale everything and start over. But i reallly dont wanna do that. And need my car for work. I was thinking of doing truion upgrade. Those Comp cam bearings to reinforce rockers. How do so many get away with ms4? And that lift is even higher.
The only way I see to make the cam and springs work is to buy roller rockers, like the new Yella Terra.
I'm not sure why these guys who have had problems with high lift cams and stock rockers don't post on these forums, unless they do and the thread disappears. I think many don't feel like they have a problem until the rocker eats the valve tip all the way down to the locks. The guys who are observant who end up hearing valve train noise generally ask questions and then inspect their valve tips. Then they see them look like the surface of a golf ball or have trenches cut in them, and then they do something about it. The valve tip should be flat and smooth, not pitted or trenched out. Just because someones car is still running, doesn't mean it doesn't have issues. Too many guys think as long as it continues to run, then everything is fine. If it's eating itself up, then it's not fine in my book.