GM Head bolts? Why does everyone complain so much?
#1
TECH Fanatic
Thread Starter
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Florence, Al
Posts: 1,162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
GM Head bolts? Why does everyone complain so much?
Ok..
I am down to the last 2 items for my H/C swap..
1.) Gaskets..
I am pretty sure I am going to go with GM MLS Gaskets.. See no real reason not to.. My car is not a strip car.. I think the GM gaskets will be fine..
Next item...
2.) Head Bolts..
Now, this is down to the ARP Head Bolts or GM Head bolts..
I do not plan (that is the plan at least) on removing the heads EVER again.. I'm not into racing, etc.. Once the H/C is done, I hope (again that is the plan) to leave the engine alone..
Now..
I've been trying to decide between $40 dollar bolts and $150 dollar bolts..
While I can afford the ARP bolts, I see no reason to spend the money if I don't HAVE to spend the money.. I mean, If I wanted to blow and extra $100 bucks I could find much more creative ways than spending it on bolts..
So.. From what I can tell, the BIGGEST thing for my situation that the ARP's have over the GM's is that they are a "torque and forget about" type deal..
Torque'em all down @30lbs...
Torque'em again @50lbs..
Torque'em again @70lbs..
Done..
While with the GM bolts you gotta:
Torque'em to 22lbs..
Turn all 10 15mm bolts an additional 90 degrees...
Then turn bolts 1 through 8 another 90 degrees...
Then turn bolts 9 and 10 an additional 50 degrees...
and finally torque bolts 11 through 15 to 22 lb-ft...
Is that the gist? Would the ARP's hold any other value FOR ME other the perceived ease of install?
Are they less likely to shear versus the GM bolts with all the twists and turns?
Like I said, I don't mind buying the ARP's if I *NEED* them.. The way I see it, many guys are using GM bolts and their cars are doing just fine.. My current GM bolts have lasted me 84K so far, albeit at less power...
Anyone want to convince me I need the ARPS?
Jeff
I am down to the last 2 items for my H/C swap..
1.) Gaskets..
I am pretty sure I am going to go with GM MLS Gaskets.. See no real reason not to.. My car is not a strip car.. I think the GM gaskets will be fine..
Next item...
2.) Head Bolts..
Now, this is down to the ARP Head Bolts or GM Head bolts..
I do not plan (that is the plan at least) on removing the heads EVER again.. I'm not into racing, etc.. Once the H/C is done, I hope (again that is the plan) to leave the engine alone..
Now..
I've been trying to decide between $40 dollar bolts and $150 dollar bolts..
While I can afford the ARP bolts, I see no reason to spend the money if I don't HAVE to spend the money.. I mean, If I wanted to blow and extra $100 bucks I could find much more creative ways than spending it on bolts..
So.. From what I can tell, the BIGGEST thing for my situation that the ARP's have over the GM's is that they are a "torque and forget about" type deal..
Torque'em all down @30lbs...
Torque'em again @50lbs..
Torque'em again @70lbs..
Done..
While with the GM bolts you gotta:
Torque'em to 22lbs..
Turn all 10 15mm bolts an additional 90 degrees...
Then turn bolts 1 through 8 another 90 degrees...
Then turn bolts 9 and 10 an additional 50 degrees...
and finally torque bolts 11 through 15 to 22 lb-ft...
Is that the gist? Would the ARP's hold any other value FOR ME other the perceived ease of install?
Are they less likely to shear versus the GM bolts with all the twists and turns?
Like I said, I don't mind buying the ARP's if I *NEED* them.. The way I see it, many guys are using GM bolts and their cars are doing just fine.. My current GM bolts have lasted me 84K so far, albeit at less power...
Anyone want to convince me I need the ARPS?
Jeff
#2
10 Second Club
iTrader: (35)
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Indiana boy
Posts: 4,174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would always use better bolts. An engine is only as good as it's parts. But you may be fine with the stockers. Since you will not be taking it apart again unless something happens.
#5
TECH Addict
iTrader: (22)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: tennessee
Posts: 2,639
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i really didn't like the degree method. some of the bolts were very hard to get the ratchet turned anywhere near 90 degrees at one time without reversing it. arp bolts/studs are much stronger and a heck alot easier to install.
#6
12 Second Club
iTrader: (116)
What made them so hard to install?? I didn't have any problems & my motor stayed in the car. There was plenty of room to stand in the engine bay in front of the motor & get to the heads/bolts. As long as you have a good torque wrench & the right extensions, it shouldn't be a problem.
#7
11 Second Club
iTrader: (1)
As long as your not spraying the heck out of it or blowing on it the stock GM head bolts are fine, they can even take some of that since the factory puts superchargers on. I am pretty sure that GM has a couple of years of experience in designing the engines so they will last. ARP bolts are great but the hype is as big as the price on a street engine. Race engines are a whole different thing.
Trending Topics
#8
TECH Enthusiast
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: San Antonio,Texas
Posts: 642
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
make sure u clean the cylinder bolt holes, i broke a bolt way inside the hole and now i have to take the motor out and to a machine shop so yea but gm bolts are fine but the holes need to be clean..
#10
UNDER PRESSURE MOD
iTrader: (19)
I thought the same thing... I'm not a racer, and I don't see myself pulling the heads ever again. Well, I snapped a header bolt, stripped another, so I had to have the bolt holes drilled, filled, and rethreaded so the head came off. I decided to go with studs because if I everhave to pull them again, I won't have to clean another bolt hole, and torquing to a specific torque ft/lb is easier than a degree angle in my oppinion. On top of that, studs don't stress the block like bolts do.
So a better question is why would you go with ARP bolts at all. I say either go cheap and get the GM torque to yeild bolts, or spend the money right and go for studs. Studs are just future insurance.
So a better question is why would you go with ARP bolts at all. I say either go cheap and get the GM torque to yeild bolts, or spend the money right and go for studs. Studs are just future insurance.
#11
11 Second Club
iTrader: (1)
First I need to figure out how a MLS head gasket some how leaks upon initial torqueing of the heads. I have seen this in a few threads and I am amazed that this happens.
The header bolt thing, I guess you should have bought ARP header bolts so they wouldn't break.
Do you reuse your head gaskets? I didn't think so, GM bolts are even cheaper than head gaskets per head. Like I said, run them if you want but for a street car they are not needed. Do you actually think that ARP knows more about the structural strength and metallurgy of the engine block than the actual manufacturer? Torqueing in three steps or torqueing in one step plus 3-4 angles isn't much different.
The header bolt thing, I guess you should have bought ARP header bolts so they wouldn't break.
Do you reuse your head gaskets? I didn't think so, GM bolts are even cheaper than head gaskets per head. Like I said, run them if you want but for a street car they are not needed. Do you actually think that ARP knows more about the structural strength and metallurgy of the engine block than the actual manufacturer? Torqueing in three steps or torqueing in one step plus 3-4 angles isn't much different.
#13
On The Tree
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Hotlanta
Posts: 126
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'd go with the ARPs. While you technically don't need them, and don't plan to ever go into the heads again, they will sure be nice if you do.
I see it as being a lot like buying road hazard insurance on your tires. Sure, you might go through the entire lifetime of them without ever picking up a nail, but if you do - life is a lot easier.
Dan
I see it as being a lot like buying road hazard insurance on your tires. Sure, you might go through the entire lifetime of them without ever picking up a nail, but if you do - life is a lot easier.
Dan
#14
No, but I think ARP isn't as concerned about cost as the actual manufacturer. The bolts are different. GM headbolts are Torque-to-yield. Once they stretch, that's it, they're done, game over. ARP headbolts are not, and can be reused.
#16
UNDER PRESSURE MOD
iTrader: (19)
First I need to figure out how a MLS head gasket some how leaks upon initial torqueing of the heads. I have seen this in a few threads and I am amazed that this happens.
The header bolt thing, I guess you should have bought ARP header bolts so they wouldn't break.
Do you reuse your head gaskets? I didn't think so, GM bolts are even cheaper than head gaskets per head. Like I said, run them if you want but for a street car they are not needed. Do you actually think that ARP knows more about the structural strength and metallurgy of the engine block than the actual manufacturer? Torqueing in three steps or torqueing in one step plus 3-4 angles isn't much different.
The header bolt thing, I guess you should have bought ARP header bolts so they wouldn't break.
Do you reuse your head gaskets? I didn't think so, GM bolts are even cheaper than head gaskets per head. Like I said, run them if you want but for a street car they are not needed. Do you actually think that ARP knows more about the structural strength and metallurgy of the engine block than the actual manufacturer? Torqueing in three steps or torqueing in one step plus 3-4 angles isn't much different.
And yes, I should have gone with header studs from the beggining, but you live and learn, and I'm trying to give someone else useful advice that I've learn through mistakes I've made.
Working with all alluminum items, from the block to the heads, you'd be surprised how easy it is to strip a bolt or break a bolt in a head or block. Don't beleive me, watch this area and the external engine for how often you see posts on how to remove broken bolts.
Personally, I like knowing that when I bolted down my heads this past time, I didn't stress the block nearly as much as if I had used torque to yeild bolts or ARP bolts. If you're going through the hassle of pulling the heads, buck up and buy a set of studs and call it a day.
#17
On The Tree
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Pewaukee, WI
Posts: 143
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1) GM MLS gaskets are great, IF their thickness serves your compression and quench needs.
After all the money spent on heads/cam (and all the supporting parts), I wouldn't let $100 stop me from achieving optimum compression and quench
2) GM head bolts are fine too. They work, they're cheap, what's to complain about?
I used ARP studs, not because I plan to change heads often, but because studs/nuts deliver more direct clamping force for a given tq value than those long bolts do. 70 lbs/ft on a bolt is not clamping your heads down near as tightly as 70lbs on a nut is. It was piece of mind for me, especially given the reputation Cometic gaskets have for not being as forgiving in terms of potential leakage.
For all your justifying of the cheaper parts, you seemed to not mention some of the real advantages to the more expensive stuff.
After all the money spent on heads/cam (and all the supporting parts), I wouldn't let $100 stop me from achieving optimum compression and quench
2) GM head bolts are fine too. They work, they're cheap, what's to complain about?
I used ARP studs, not because I plan to change heads often, but because studs/nuts deliver more direct clamping force for a given tq value than those long bolts do. 70 lbs/ft on a bolt is not clamping your heads down near as tightly as 70lbs on a nut is. It was piece of mind for me, especially given the reputation Cometic gaskets have for not being as forgiving in terms of potential leakage.
For all your justifying of the cheaper parts, you seemed to not mention some of the real advantages to the more expensive stuff.
#18
TECH Addict
iTrader: (22)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: tennessee
Posts: 2,639
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What made them so hard to install?? I didn't have any problems & my motor stayed in the car. There was plenty of room to stand in the engine bay in front of the motor & get to the heads/bolts. As long as you have a good torque wrench & the right extensions, it shouldn't be a problem.
#19
TECH Fanatic
Thread Starter
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Florence, Al
Posts: 1,162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Anyway, I found a great deal on some ARP head bolts today, NIP for a price I am willing to pay.. So.. I'm going ARP head Bolts..