LS3 wear questions with pics
#1
LS3 wear questions with pics
Stock 2008 c6 with 115k miles. Seen 6 track days and many autocrosses, a couple of drift days. Daily driver.
I've been hearing a bit of a tapping/growling noise under part throttle beginning about two-three months ago. No noise during cruise or idle. No constant knocking, like rod bearings.
Oil test showed a small spike of lead at 96k and nothing else. No noise then. By 115k there was everything. Same lead, but iron, aluminum, tin, nickel, chrome also up. Indicating bearings, pistons and rings.
Here are the problem wear metals. The order of the numbers is: this last oil test at 115k, second last oil test at 96k, average from previous tests.
Al 47, 7, 7
Pb 23, 29, 9
Sn 6, 0, 0
Mg 840, 620, 15
Fe 55, 35, 35
Cr 5, 2, 2
Ni 5, 3, 3
Cu 61, 65, 82 - lower
Measured low compression (130 vs 180) and high leak down by the rings (40% vs 10%) in #4 and #5.
I've always heard a bit of a ticking/tapping at high throttle that I think might've been piston slap, since new. Some slight piston slap at startup since new. Could this have exacerbated into the current condition, or unrelated?
I also ran the engine with no oil for a few minutes by accident at around 70k. Surprised if that took this long to manifest.
I'm here because from what I've taken apart so far with the engine in the car - #2,3,4 main caps and #4 piston/rod/rod bearing - I see no obvious wear. Can you guys see anything from the pics (below)?
I see a bit of a rub mark on the back/passemnger side of the #4 cylinder wall, but I can't feel it much. Didn't have a bore gauge yet to measure. Is this enough to cause leakage by the rings? Can I just hone it out?
All the bearings look nice to me (pics are probably worse than real life), and I don't see bad wear on the piston crown or skirt. Rings also feel smooth. But please let me know if you see anything from the pics.
http://s1094.beta.photobucket.com/us...vt=email_share
Trying to figure out where all the metal is coming from. It's indicating bearings, pistons, and rings. Not seeing that much metal loss. Is lead and tin 100% indicating bad bearings?
At this point I might have to pull the engine to get a look at the #4 and #5 main bearings and the #5 piston/cylinder. I guess the cam bearings might be the bad ones, as well.
Any similar experiences? Any tips?
Thanks a lot!
I've been hearing a bit of a tapping/growling noise under part throttle beginning about two-three months ago. No noise during cruise or idle. No constant knocking, like rod bearings.
Oil test showed a small spike of lead at 96k and nothing else. No noise then. By 115k there was everything. Same lead, but iron, aluminum, tin, nickel, chrome also up. Indicating bearings, pistons and rings.
Here are the problem wear metals. The order of the numbers is: this last oil test at 115k, second last oil test at 96k, average from previous tests.
Al 47, 7, 7
Pb 23, 29, 9
Sn 6, 0, 0
Mg 840, 620, 15
Fe 55, 35, 35
Cr 5, 2, 2
Ni 5, 3, 3
Cu 61, 65, 82 - lower
Measured low compression (130 vs 180) and high leak down by the rings (40% vs 10%) in #4 and #5.
I've always heard a bit of a ticking/tapping at high throttle that I think might've been piston slap, since new. Some slight piston slap at startup since new. Could this have exacerbated into the current condition, or unrelated?
I also ran the engine with no oil for a few minutes by accident at around 70k. Surprised if that took this long to manifest.
I'm here because from what I've taken apart so far with the engine in the car - #2,3,4 main caps and #4 piston/rod/rod bearing - I see no obvious wear. Can you guys see anything from the pics (below)?
I see a bit of a rub mark on the back/passemnger side of the #4 cylinder wall, but I can't feel it much. Didn't have a bore gauge yet to measure. Is this enough to cause leakage by the rings? Can I just hone it out?
All the bearings look nice to me (pics are probably worse than real life), and I don't see bad wear on the piston crown or skirt. Rings also feel smooth. But please let me know if you see anything from the pics.
http://s1094.beta.photobucket.com/us...vt=email_share
Trying to figure out where all the metal is coming from. It's indicating bearings, pistons, and rings. Not seeing that much metal loss. Is lead and tin 100% indicating bad bearings?
At this point I might have to pull the engine to get a look at the #4 and #5 main bearings and the #5 piston/cylinder. I guess the cam bearings might be the bad ones, as well.
Any similar experiences? Any tips?
Thanks a lot!
#2
TECH Junkie
iTrader: (9)
I also ran the engine with no oil for a few minutes by accident at around 70k. Surprised if that took this long to manifest.
I make the decisions after events like this quickly. Option 1. Turn up the radio when driving and get a mechanical oil pressure gauge piped into the oil pump feed and stick it right in front of your face on the dash and run the hell out of it until you lose oil pressure then stop the car and rebuild it. or option 2. Run it til she blows.
Of course theres always everyones favorite option 3a. Pull it out and freshen everything and start over right now
#3
3a is what I'm doing. I'm just not seeing the damage I'm supposed to fix. I also don't wanna fully machine the block and replace everything, because I can't be without a car for that long. I was hoping I'd get in there, see the bad bearings and pistons as the oil test suggested, replace them, hone the bad cylinders, and hope she runs for another year or two. But I'm not seeing the damage.
#4
TECH Enthusiast
Geeeeeeeeez
Did you check the valvetrain(Lifters,etc..)
After all of the events that have occurred, you are lucky the **** still runs.
I have seen less **** happen and cause a rebuild.
Either refreshen it or just run that bitch till she blows.
Did you check the valvetrain(Lifters,etc..)
After all of the events that have occurred, you are lucky the **** still runs.
I have seen less **** happen and cause a rebuild.
Either refreshen it or just run that bitch till she blows.
Last edited by bozzhawg; 01-04-2013 at 08:23 AM.
#5
12 Second Club
iTrader: (49)
I'll put money on the bearings being washed. Sometimes, they can wear and it will be hard to see with the naked eye.
Here's what I see happened..
You ran it without oil at 70k. Which took any coating left off the bearing. Shortly after, you started to lose the ring seal for whatever reason, causing excessive blow by. This caused fuel loaded oil, washing thru the already worn bearings, causing the spike in abnormal metals in the analysis.
Here's what I see happened..
You ran it without oil at 70k. Which took any coating left off the bearing. Shortly after, you started to lose the ring seal for whatever reason, causing excessive blow by. This caused fuel loaded oil, washing thru the already worn bearings, causing the spike in abnormal metals in the analysis.
#6
I'll put money on the bearings being washed. Sometimes, they can wear and it will be hard to see with the naked eye.
Here's what I see happened..
You ran it without oil at 70k. Which took any coating left off the bearing. Shortly after, you started to lose the ring seal for whatever reason, causing excessive blow by. This caused fuel loaded oil, washing thru the already worn bearings, causing the spike in abnormal metals in the analysis.
Here's what I see happened..
You ran it without oil at 70k. Which took any coating left off the bearing. Shortly after, you started to lose the ring seal for whatever reason, causing excessive blow by. This caused fuel loaded oil, washing thru the already worn bearings, causing the spike in abnormal metals in the analysis.
Heck, I am surprised it lasted this long!
#7
TECH Enthusiast
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Tampa FL
Posts: 714
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If the damage is undetectable to the naked eye just throw a new set of bearings, rings and a dingle ball hone in it. Have a valve job done on the heads and you will be okay for a stock daily.
Trending Topics
#8
12 Second Club
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Renton, WA
Posts: 2,563
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pull the engine:
-Polish the crank
-Tank the block, and hone just enough to break any glaze. There are some nice DIY hones avalible.
-New rod bolts
-New bearings
-Re ring kit
-New head bolts
-Quality gasket kit.
-Get the heads tanked and freshend up with new valves seal, and springs
With a crank polish you might need +.001 oversized bearings, and you might want to order some hand gapped rings. So, double, tripple check all clearences, and use a top notch torqure wrench. You will come in under a grand, and be down for a few weeks.
Good luck!
#9
Note that my oil tests, even the last one, showed very good oil quality, not diluted by fuel. Was surprising to me, too...
Checking the lifters is a good idea. Though I don't see them causing the various metal spikes, like lead. The rockers and pushrods look good... The one valve I removed showed no wear.
Why do a couple of you insist on a valve job? I'm not losing much if any compression by the valves on any cylinders.
Not keen on dropping anything off at a shop. Bad experiences with downtime.
Any tips on popping the retainers loose with the head off the engine? They're very stuck, and I can't figure out a good way to push up on the valve and not have the retainers fly randomly around the garage, or possibly even bend a valve...
Checking the lifters is a good idea. Though I don't see them causing the various metal spikes, like lead. The rockers and pushrods look good... The one valve I removed showed no wear.
Why do a couple of you insist on a valve job? I'm not losing much if any compression by the valves on any cylinders.
Not keen on dropping anything off at a shop. Bad experiences with downtime.
Any tips on popping the retainers loose with the head off the engine? They're very stuck, and I can't figure out a good way to push up on the valve and not have the retainers fly randomly around the garage, or possibly even bend a valve...
#10
TECH Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
What was the ring end gap installed in the cylinder? This will be a better indicator rather then just looking at the ring
-I prefer not to have my oil analyzed as it will most likely freak me out and make me over think the issue...I keep my oil clean and changed and make sure it has oil pressure...thats it.
-I prefer not to have my oil analyzed as it will most likely freak me out and make me over think the issue...I keep my oil clean and changed and make sure it has oil pressure...thats it.
#11
I wouldn't be so afraid of the oil test. I did them every couple of oil changes and the numbers were consistent until the real problems appeared.
I thought about checking the end gaps on the current rings, then forgot to do it. Will do tomorrow.
I did hit the cylinders with a bore gauge tonight. I don't see anything different in the bad cylinder. Measurements vary by up to 0.002in per bore depending on the position in the bore (0.001 or less at nearby points is more common). Saw both taper and out of round. The numbers are quite wild, and consistent in the same spot no matter how many times I measure, but I dismiss it since the head's not torqued down, it's the same in all cylinders, and only two don't seal.
The "rub" spot visible in the pics doesn't really measure different than the pristine cylinder wall around it, so I doubt it would cause sealing issues.
I assume piston to wall clearance is measured near the bottom of the skirt. Going by that, I have around 0.003 - 0.0015 piston to wall clearance. In some spots it tightens up though, and at the bottom of bore #4, perpendicular to the crank, I measure slight negative clearance (the bore really tightens up there). At least compared to the brand new piston. The old piston is a tiny bit smaller, by one thou or less. I'll try sliding the new piston down and make sure it doesn't bind... Maybe the bore shape will change enough when the head's torqued down, and open up...
I thought about checking the end gaps on the current rings, then forgot to do it. Will do tomorrow.
I did hit the cylinders with a bore gauge tonight. I don't see anything different in the bad cylinder. Measurements vary by up to 0.002in per bore depending on the position in the bore (0.001 or less at nearby points is more common). Saw both taper and out of round. The numbers are quite wild, and consistent in the same spot no matter how many times I measure, but I dismiss it since the head's not torqued down, it's the same in all cylinders, and only two don't seal.
The "rub" spot visible in the pics doesn't really measure different than the pristine cylinder wall around it, so I doubt it would cause sealing issues.
I assume piston to wall clearance is measured near the bottom of the skirt. Going by that, I have around 0.003 - 0.0015 piston to wall clearance. In some spots it tightens up though, and at the bottom of bore #4, perpendicular to the crank, I measure slight negative clearance (the bore really tightens up there). At least compared to the brand new piston. The old piston is a tiny bit smaller, by one thou or less. I'll try sliding the new piston down and make sure it doesn't bind... Maybe the bore shape will change enough when the head's torqued down, and open up...
#12
TECH Enthusiast
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Tampa FL
Posts: 714
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Note that my oil tests, even the last one, showed very good oil quality, not diluted by fuel. Was surprising to me, too...
Checking the lifters is a good idea. Though I don't see them causing the various metal spikes, like lead. The rockers and pushrods look good... The one valve I removed showed no wear.
Why do a couple of you insist on a valve job? I'm not losing much if any compression by the valves on any cylinders.
Not keen on dropping anything off at a shop. Bad experiences with downtime.
Any tips on popping the retainers loose with the head off the engine? They're very stuck, and I can't figure out a good way to push up on the valve and not have the retainers fly randomly around the garage, or possibly even bend a valve...
Checking the lifters is a good idea. Though I don't see them causing the various metal spikes, like lead. The rockers and pushrods look good... The one valve I removed showed no wear.
Why do a couple of you insist on a valve job? I'm not losing much if any compression by the valves on any cylinders.
Not keen on dropping anything off at a shop. Bad experiences with downtime.
Any tips on popping the retainers loose with the head off the engine? They're very stuck, and I can't figure out a good way to push up on the valve and not have the retainers fly randomly around the garage, or possibly even bend a valve...
#13
Launching!
iTrader: (16)
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Harrisburg PA
Posts: 241
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'd get a close look up in the block at each of the 5 cam bearings. If one of them is going you'll see lead in the oil. In my case I had a cam bearing moving out of it's bore and rubbing a lifter, putting lead in the oil. Found it from oil analysis just as you have done.
I'd pull all the mains/rods at this time...would only take one bearing to be putting the metal in the oil. The ones you have pulled so far certainly look just fine.
with 115K I'd agree with Gunslinger on this ....have the heads freshened up and guides checked. Break glaze on the cylinders to restore cross hatch
I'd pull all the mains/rods at this time...would only take one bearing to be putting the metal in the oil. The ones you have pulled so far certainly look just fine.
with 115K I'd agree with Gunslinger on this ....have the heads freshened up and guides checked. Break glaze on the cylinders to restore cross hatch
#14
Ended up pulling the engine cause I couldn't see anything wrong.
Turned out that it was the cam bearings. Upper halves are rough, lower halves have a copper spot. I'm assuming if I hadn't run it with no oil two years ago, they'd still be fine.
Cam journals look perfect, and rod and main bearings look perfect. Even pistons and rings look perfect.
I checked the ring gap on #4 that had a bad compression and leakdown, and the gap was .016 top and .025 bottom. That's pretty much spec. I really can't figure out how air was getting by those rings, given that the bore looks great as well. Any ideas?
Either way, doing a full rebuild. Valve job, heads checked, decked. Block hot tanked and honed just a touch to break in new rings. All new bearings of course. Crank polished (though it looks perfect).
That should do er...
Hope to have it running by the end of this long weekend.
Turned out that it was the cam bearings. Upper halves are rough, lower halves have a copper spot. I'm assuming if I hadn't run it with no oil two years ago, they'd still be fine.
Cam journals look perfect, and rod and main bearings look perfect. Even pistons and rings look perfect.
I checked the ring gap on #4 that had a bad compression and leakdown, and the gap was .016 top and .025 bottom. That's pretty much spec. I really can't figure out how air was getting by those rings, given that the bore looks great as well. Any ideas?
Either way, doing a full rebuild. Valve job, heads checked, decked. Block hot tanked and honed just a touch to break in new rings. All new bearings of course. Crank polished (though it looks perfect).
That should do er...
Hope to have it running by the end of this long weekend.
#18
TECH Junkie
iTrader: (9)
I checked the ring gap on #4 that had a bad compression and leakdown, and the gap was .016 top and .025 bottom. That's pretty much spec. I really can't figure out how air was getting by those rings, given that the bore looks great as well. Any ideas?
Either way, doing a full rebuild. Valve job, heads checked, decked. Block hot tanked and honed just a touch to break in new rings. All new bearings of course. Crank polished (though it looks perfect).
That should do er...
Hope to have it running by the end of this long weekend.