P0420 just won't go away!
#1
P0420 just won't go away! / Fixed Feb 22nd
In May of 2005, I installed a Comp Cams cam & springs & a ported throttle body. In October of 2005, I started seeing SES codes for: P0135 O2 Sensor Heater Circuit Malfunction (Bank 1 Sensor 1) and P0420 Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1).
I went back to my tuner in Oct and had him delete the rear O2's.
In Jan of this year, I got SES Codes: P0135 O2 Sensor Heater Circuit Malfunction (Bank 1 Sensor 1) and P0420 Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1) again! I thought something might be weird with the front O2, so I replaced Bank 1 Sensor 1 with a Bosch O2 sensor and cleared the codes with AutoTap.
Now, I’m getting a SES AGAIN for P0420, Catalyst System Low Efficiency, Bank 1.
In October I’m sure I saw the tuner delete the code and save the bin to my PCM. So WTF is going on here? Is this P0420 indicative of something going awry somewhere else in the computer, or did the write to my PCM not ‘take’ for some strange reason?
Any ideas on what I can do to get rid of the problem for once and for all?
I went back to my tuner in Oct and had him delete the rear O2's.
In Jan of this year, I got SES Codes: P0135 O2 Sensor Heater Circuit Malfunction (Bank 1 Sensor 1) and P0420 Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1) again! I thought something might be weird with the front O2, so I replaced Bank 1 Sensor 1 with a Bosch O2 sensor and cleared the codes with AutoTap.
Now, I’m getting a SES AGAIN for P0420, Catalyst System Low Efficiency, Bank 1.
In October I’m sure I saw the tuner delete the code and save the bin to my PCM. So WTF is going on here? Is this P0420 indicative of something going awry somewhere else in the computer, or did the write to my PCM not ‘take’ for some strange reason?
Any ideas on what I can do to get rid of the problem for once and for all?
Last edited by fnbrowning; 02-22-2006 at 10:33 PM.
#2
TECH Apprentice
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: San Diego, CA
Posts: 328
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If it's still thowing the code I'd imagine it either was deleted or not deleted properly. Are you still running cats? and has one gone bad? I'd address the code itself instead of just deleting it. Installing a cam and springs shouldn't make you throw those codes.
#6
Originally Posted by Zombie
I've had an issue with tunercat and deleting that code before. I deleted the code but it was still present. What software was the tuner using?
#7
P0420 usually means you have a bad cat. if you're still running cats, then change the bad one (I think the p0420 is the driver's side). If you have under 80K miles, your delaer should replace the cat for free. If you're not runnig cats, something else is hay-wire .
Trending Topics
#8
there is a PCM update for false setting of p0420 codes. i had them in my car and im a tech at a chevy dealer so we put both cats in and new rear 02s in both like a week later it came back on. i found a reflash for it setting false p0420 and whatever the other bank code is p04(& and has never came on yet
#9
Originally Posted by KillerWS6
P0420 usually means you have a bad cat. if you're still running cats, then change the bad one (I think the p0420 is the driver's side). If you have under 80K miles, your delaer should replace the cat for free. If you're not runnig cats, something else is hay-wire .
Originally Posted by camarokid94
there is a PCM update for false setting of p0420 codes. i had them in my car and im a tech at a chevy dealer so we put both cats in and new rear 02s in both like a week later it came back on. i found a reflash for it setting false p0420 and whatever the other bank code is p04(& and has never came on yet
#11
I went to back to my first tuner today. He wanted $70.00 to fix what he forgot to program!
Needless to say, I won’t be dealing with him again. I called a local guy that uses tunercat software. He found the O2's were deleted, but the P0420 settings were not turned off. He pulled up code p0420 and set it to off, as SmokingWS6 suggested.
I’m driving a few hundred miles this weekend, so we’ll see if the SES stays off, but I can’t see why I’d ever throw a code P0420 again.
Makes me mad that the first guy did not use due diligence to program properly. Now, I’m beginning to question the entire tune. This spring, I just may have it done over, done right.
Thanks for everyone’s help!
Needless to say, I won’t be dealing with him again. I called a local guy that uses tunercat software. He found the O2's were deleted, but the P0420 settings were not turned off. He pulled up code p0420 and set it to off, as SmokingWS6 suggested.
I’m driving a few hundred miles this weekend, so we’ll see if the SES stays off, but I can’t see why I’d ever throw a code P0420 again.
Makes me mad that the first guy did not use due diligence to program properly. Now, I’m beginning to question the entire tune. This spring, I just may have it done over, done right.
Thanks for everyone’s help!
#12
Launching!
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Humble, Texas
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have found that when deleting rear 02's, sometimes you have to delete the low catalyst efficiency codes as well.
You have to delete these to start:
Bank1: 137,138, 140, 141, Bank2: 157, 158, 160, 161
Some cars will still throw these codes if left undeleted:
P0420- Low catalyst efficiency
P0430- Low catalyst efficiency B2
Its weird how one specifies a bank and one does not. I wonder if it was implied B1?
I left 420 & 430 on in my car, does not throw codes, but then I do not have cats.
My buddy's car would not stop throwing codes until they were deleted
Now 135 is usually a tell tale of a bad o2 sensor, 135 is B1 S1, so the only remedy is to replace it, deleting sensor one on either banks is not an option, they are needed for fuel trim adjustments by the PCM. Bosh replcements at the parts store are about $70, replace and clear the DTC.
You have to delete these to start:
Bank1: 137,138, 140, 141, Bank2: 157, 158, 160, 161
Some cars will still throw these codes if left undeleted:
P0420- Low catalyst efficiency
P0430- Low catalyst efficiency B2
Its weird how one specifies a bank and one does not. I wonder if it was implied B1?
I left 420 & 430 on in my car, does not throw codes, but then I do not have cats.
My buddy's car would not stop throwing codes until they were deleted
Now 135 is usually a tell tale of a bad o2 sensor, 135 is B1 S1, so the only remedy is to replace it, deleting sensor one on either banks is not an option, they are needed for fuel trim adjustments by the PCM. Bosh replcements at the parts store are about $70, replace and clear the DTC.
Last edited by mike s.; 02-23-2006 at 11:23 AM.
#13
TECH Senior Member
Originally Posted by fnbrowning
I went to back to my first tuner today. He wanted $70.00 to fix what he forgot to program!
wow... that's utter BS ... that should have been removed when he disabled the other rear O2 codes....